Loved this top so much! Would definitely buy if I wasn’t trying to keep my closet trimmed down. Will absolutely rent again!

Didn’t gap in the buttons. Nice fit. Would rent again

Comfy, cute, lightweight

Very cute top. Loved the print. I have a short torso and this was somewhat short on me. Would probably be too short on someone tall.

Wore this at least 3 times. It was perfect with high waisted jeans! Got compliments every time I wore it!

I wore this twice for work (zoom calls). It's nice and lightweight, has a cute pattern, is easy to throw on, etc. but the cut just isn't for me. It cinches in at the waist which I'm personally not a fan of feeling the elastic around my middle section but that's probably just a me problem, lol. To each their own!

A bit poofy below the elastic waist and it definitely gave me maternity vibes. On the specific shirt I received the top button was hanging on by a thread which made me a little nervous.

This top is just ok. I wish the waist seam was a bit lower...I think it would be more flattering...but it's ok for an everyday top.

The print is really pretty but the fit was not good. It looked frumpy and silly. This shirt would probably look better on smaller chested girls. The shirt was really short on me and just looked awkward. I will not be renting this again.

Felt underwhelmed in this. It fits fine but I personally felt frumpy in it. I think it would work well on someone taller with a delicate body frame

Short in torso, large enough on top to fit large chest, just weird. I pinned the material under the top button and wore it on zoom. Laughed every time I passed a mirror in my home. Runs very small for sizing.

The elastic at the waist gives this soft, flowy material great shape. The elastic cinching on the sleeves gives it a great feminine detailing.

Flowy and cute. Able to dress up or just wear with jeans.

Lightweight, pairs great with shorts and jeans

Super cute, fit a little large and I could have sized down to a medium but I liked the flowy look.

Great length and fit. Super light and comfortable. Perfect for teaching in the warmer months :)

Love the fit, it's comfortable and breezy. Great with high waisted shorts!

This shirt is so cute and flattering! Love the material, love the fit. I did wear a size up from my usual for a more relaxed vibe, but there was plenty of room - I would call it true to size. So many compliments! Easy to dress up or down, and stayed cool in the summer.

Good fit, light material, easy to dress up or down, and the pattern matched various denim colors.

I loved this too and wore it more than once. The material is light which is great for warmer months. I thought the shirt fits fairly well but it was a little big around the waistline although the neckline, shoulders, and elastic on sleeves felt right. For reference I'm 5'4'' 34B, 115lbs and go between a 0-2 or XS-S. I would recommend this shirt and would guide others to possibly size down depending how lose you want the fit to be.

Lovely fit with some elastic give. Flattering neckline. This shirt checks all the boxes for staple top.

I don't know what kind of magic this shirt has, but I wore it a ton and it looked clean and fresh every time. I spilled coffee on it and no stain appeared. I left it in my gym bag overnight by mistake and it emerged unwrinkled. It looked beautiful on and fit perfectly. Definitely rent!

It’s classic Madewell which I think the shirts tend to be little on the boxy side. It’s very thin and I wore a tank top under to keep warm in the office. Pattern is muted and not eye catching.

it fit well and was nicely fitted in terms of sleeves, neck line and not too short. didn't ride up at all. ended up buying it.

Fits true to size.

Cute, but nothing special. Nice for casual wear, just didn’t love the way it looked on me.

Needs to be paired with something high highwaisted.

This was my favorite item in my shipment. Very cute top. It runs a little short so if you lift your arms, your stomach may show. I have fuller arms and the sleeves fit great. Overall, true to size.

some gapping if you have a large bust

Silky and fun but rises up.

fits TTS

Wore this to dinner on the.

Cute print but proportions were off, cinched waist didn't hit at the right spot and made for a baggier bust.

More cropped than expected.

This is a cute / summery crop top. I wore it with high waisted jeans & got lots of compliments!