Really loved these pants! I wore them more than once but they were big in the waist and I kept having to pull them up. I would love to rent them again in a size down and hopefully purchase them! They were so cute and stylish and I got multiple compliments.

Very stretchy! Classic madewell fit.

I am a size 8 and the 30R fit me well. Slimming with the button fly. The faded black color and the ragged edge make these a very casual-looking pair of jeans.

Gave these 4 stars because they have so much stretch that they run a little big. Without a belt they would sag and I had to constantly pull them back up- it also led to fabric bunching in the crotch. Will have to size down with these next time

Runs big but is super cute and comfy

Nice pair of jeans but too long for me (5"2)

Cute a comfy. They definitely run large, I sized down and probably could have gone down one more, but they still worked. Versatile and I will rent again!

Even though they were one size too big I still wore them, they only started to look sloppy toward the end of the day after I was already home. They were a bit long, so they looked best with a pair of heeled booties. Because they are frayed at the bottom I didn't want to roll them to wear with flats.

Jeans have nice stretch, but buttons still gapped a little bit. I enjoyed the wash of these jeans; a nice change from traditional black denim. The raw hem made the jeans fun and unique.

These fit baggy in the crotch and are actually a lighter grey wash (not black as shown). As always, the inseam is short so not ideal for us tall girls. I didn't wear them.

Too big in the waist and tight on my thighs and calves? It was odd. I am normally 28-29, but even if I sized down I don't think my legs would fit.

Fits perfectly

Oh my God these are my new favorite jeans. Super stretchy and super comfortable and flattering high waist. I'm 5-2 and these hit right at ankle.

These jeans were so good. Loved the buttons in front and high waist. Can dress up or down. Is a more faded black than dark black but super comfy and LOVED the fringe on the ankle. Cheaper at Nordstrom's so i purchased through them. A keeper!

I liked the high waist, but the size 29, which was recommended for me, was huge. I typically wear 27-28 so I should have ordered a 27 in these