I have rented this multiple times! Great sweater that can be tucked in or left out. Cute with everything! Arms fit really nice which is a bonus for me!

This sweater looks great with high wasted jeans. I'm 5'9" and the arms were a little short on me. I would consider renting it again in the next size up.

I liked this sweater, but I should have listened to the reviews. Size up! I’d consider renting again in a size large. But it also felt a bit stiff. Not my fave.

The material feels like hay and it runs small. I don't recommend this

Very chic, simple sweater. It fits well but the sleeves were a tad short. I usually wear an xs but I got the small to be cozy and it fits more like I’d expect an xs to fit. Overall great sweater!

I needed another neutral sweater - so I bought it!

Absolutely love this sweater. It’s high quality and the ruffles are stunning. Got so many complements.

Runs small

A short sweater that is very flattering.

I would rent again! This totally gave me fall vibes in the winter. I did wear on multiple occasions - Thank you, RTR Unlimited. PROS -Love the detail of the collar. -I loved the color. - I love these sleeves. -Breathable and works well with busty girls. CONS -I wish the front passed the tummy/belly area, but I still loved this item.

I love this sweater, but found it very short in the sleeves and body.

Has a structured feeling. Very cute sweater. Fit wasn't as comfy as I imagined, would rent again.

Nice thick sweater but arms are a little short on me and I felt like the neck was giving collar vibes.

not a long sweater, hit me more of a crop top

Loved the look of the sweater, but the neckline fit weird on me. Wish it had fit better because the sleeve details were so cute.

Super cute sweater but it runs super small. The sleeves and the length were way too short. I'm usually a S in tops so it is definitely not TTS. Couldn't wear it.

Ran small but otherwise cute

This fitted a lot shorter than expected. It is lasso extremely warm but itchy. Wished it worked out.

Super cropped! I should have sized up Bc it's a very cute sweater.

cute but did not wear

I love how this looks and I'm sure it would be confy on a bigger size. Arms and total length runs short so if you a long limbed person like me order a size up.

This runs so small I couldn’t wear it. Super cute, wish the sizing wasn’t off

I was planning on wearing this on a trip to somewhere a little colder, but I never got to wear it. It was WAY too small for me. It was extremely cropped and was not flattering. The sleeves were also too short. I would suggest going up a size or two if you are wanting it to fit like a normal sweater. If you are wanting that cropped look then it would be better to get your actual size.

Too small, very cropped!!

Way too short in length for my comfort.

This didn’t fit at all. Too small to cover my chest and ended up as a crop sweater. Didn’t wear

So so small - stiff and shrunk. Could not wear

Let me start on a positive note - Madewell jeans are *chefs kiss* BUT their tops just never hit for me. I run either XL or XXL for tops and this was laughable. It's crazy how 99.9% of XXL tops from other brands either fit me like a glove or give me just enough extra room...yeah, not Madewell. So short and cropped. So cute on the hanger and true potential but it's a no for me, sis. I don't even have a big chest area and this was saddening. Madewell, do better for the plus sized gals.

The ruffles added a nice girly touch to an otherwise neutral sweater. I'm usually an XS but this S fit like an XS. So it runs a little small, but nothing crazy, I think a S or XS would've fit about the same

The collar and sleeves are the perfect embellishments for this sweater! The color is perfect for a subtle, cozy look, and it is slightly oversized depending on how big you want it on you.Classy and chic, holding onto this one for a while!

Loved this sweater! Very cute and comfy every day sweater that you can dress up or down.

Love the details, this is a great sweater and is the perfect weight. It definitely runs a little bit small. I'm on the M/L line and am glad that I got a L!

Really liked this sweater, the sleeves and neck make it unique in an understated way. Wish it hadn't been so cropped, then it would have been perfect!

very cute sweater, a little short for my long torso but high waisted jeans fixed that!

Great sweater for everyday, date night or weekend wear. Has a romantic/pirate like vibe with the ruffle cuffs and collar. Soft but a little itchy. Not too heavy but warm. Would rent again.

This is a super cute and unique sweater but the photo doesn't show just how "cropped" it really is. Madewell usually runs true to size to large for me usually but the XL was so small it could have been labeled a small/medium and been believable. I'm not sure if it was shrunk at some point and it was just the sweater I received or if this reflects the design as a whole.