Initially I wished I would have sized down, but then I embraced the baggy tomboy vibes and ended up really liking the extra space. Wore these on a road trip and they were perfect.

Well made and good quality jeans. They run a little on the short side so if you are tall these may not be for you.

Barrel without too much volume. Loved these!

I am 28/29 in jeans and wanted these to be a little baggy so went with the 29. Way too big in waist. Could pull them off without unbuttoning! Reordered in the 28. But could have also done the 27.

Cute jeans. As a middle aged woman, I liked how they were trendy without being crazy big barrel legged. Run loose, so safe to size down if on the fence- a 26 probably would have also worked for me (as I also find Madewell runs big in general).

Loved them fits TTS

Really great jeans but they do run a little big

Go down one size

Size down. So cute

These pants were very baggy and I would size down.

Loved the look and they were the perfect look fof 5 ft but I thought they ran bigger than other Madewell jeans

Loved these jeans, just ran really big. Good length for my petite frame.

I already sized down once and I borderline could have twice. Good for petites though!

I would rent again but would size down.

Tight in weird places and not the most flattering. Wouldn’t rent again probably

Too large but still comfy

The waist runs large but everything else fit so that’s frustrating. Not for girlies with hips and smaller waists

I hate button fly jeans and these are in fact, button fly. Also, this was my first and last try of a barrel jeans. Not my thing, Jeans run large.