This sweater is very cute and is easy to wear. Very comfortable. The fabric is thick enough to keep you warm on a cooler day. Love the 3/4 length sleeve. Nice with jeans!

I liked it very much. Very thick and quality

I am obsessed with this sweater! I must have worn this four or five times during my rental. The materials is cozy and the pattern is cute. The mock turtleneck is warm and flatering. The sleeve are wider, bell-style so don't wear this if you're helping cook (what I did). I got so many compliments and felt very pretty every time I wore! A must-rent if you're looking for a sweater for family parties or get-togethers with friends.

Love this sweater! Turtleneck is loose enough so it's not restricting or itchy. Great length and fit! Definitely rent for everyday wear

This is a cute sweater overall. The fit is a little odd but I didn't mind it once I put it on! Sleeves were a little short and big as others have mentioned but I think it just makes it a unique piece! Runs TTS.

Nice sweater, but I'd prefer that the sleeves were normal length. They are not 3/4 either. The fit is short at the waist and boxy too. Color combination is really nice.

I rented this sweater with the intention of wearing it on Valentine's Day and now I can't get enough. It's so cute in person, the material is very comfortable and the neckline + sleeves are both super flattering! Would definitely suggest sizing up 1-2 -- I usually wear xs and rented a s, but honestly could've gone up to a m if I wanted it extra flowy.

This looked so cute with jeans and boots (not pictured). I found the sleeves to be a little short but overall it was comfy and stylish and was a classic winter piece

I wore this sweater on thanksgiving & it was perfect. It was thick, a cute pattern, and festive colors.

Love this sweater! It was a little short in the arms for me, but otherwise excellent

Loved the fit, the weight, and the design

Super cozy!! I looooove the fit of this sweater. If Madewell creates this again in different colors and solids I will rent them. Love this fit.

Beautiful sweater! Love this brand!!

I'm surprised none of the RTR info and other reviews mention how wide the sleeves are. They are double normal width even at the cuff! That looked crazy at first but I tried it on & rolled the sleeves up; decided that it's a feature, not a bug. Gives a twist to what otherwise is a very traditional looking sweater. I'm between 16-18 and ordered the XXL. If I rented again would try one or two sizes down as it is already oversized and feels like it loosens up over the course of the day.

Great oversized sweater. Wore with blue jeans and boots. The only downside was the neck was a little itchy and the sleeve are extra wide so keep this in mind when reaching over a plate full of food!

Easy for everyday wear. Definitely a cold weather item.

Very comfortable and a good length for tall girls wore this for Thanksgiving with jeans and was comfortable all day long

I loved this Madewell sweater and would consider buying it in the future. It was surprisingly warm. One thing to note is that it’s slightly cropped. It works well with high waisted jeans.

Perfect comfy sweater for Thanksgiving!

I love madewell sweaters and this one was no exception! warm but not oppressive, and not scratchy. The big sleeves added a unique flare. The pattern was not too holiday-specific but still felt festive when worn around the holidays. It was hard to let go of this one!

Fun sweater wore with high waisted jeans and fur mountain boots

Super cute, comfy, flattering fall sweater. Wore it on Thanksgiving

I loved the slightly over sized sleeves. It was such a good casual look, paired nicely with jeans/boots, and skirt/boots. Really enjoyed it. Slightly heavier than expected, but still so cozy!

fit true to size and very comfortable.

One size up from my usual size fit me best.

Great sweater for everyday. It is a bit cropped, but didn't show my stomach and is great with higher waisted jeans. Love the sleeves which are 3/4 length and just make the sweater a bit different. The small was perfect on me.

This was such a fun sweater to wear. I'm pretty petite (4'11") and the XS fit perfect. Since it was a sweater I was okay with it fitting a little bit more loose so I went with XS just to be safe. It was very comfortable and cozy, and the pattern is so fun. The cut of the sweater is very flattering and doesn't make you look baggy. I highly recommend it!

I seriously considered buying this piece as I loved it so much! Super comfy, love the pattern, and it was super warm for these cold northern winters. Great for petites, too, as it is quite short.

I loved this sweater! I could have used an XS but the S worked just fine. (120 lbs, 5'4") I loved the pattern and the style. It was nice and warm but not itchy at all.

Really cute sweater

Loved having this in my closet as a seasonal item. Would have bought it, but I have very sensitive skin and found it a bit itchy around the neck. Sleeves were also on the shorter side for me, but I didn't mind. Otherwise highly recommend!

Great sweater, and very warm. Paired with jeans and warm white jeans. Arms are not as wide as I thought they would be.

This is a boxy, short sweater but I still wore it on a ski trip. Cute but probably wouldn't rent again. It was very warm.

This is a great winter sweater with a fun pattern. A couple of caveats: I got it in xxs and the sleeves were much too short. It's also somewhat (but not too) scratchy. It looks very nice with jeans.

Cute sweater. A tad itchy but I am super sensitive. Still was able to wear with something underneath. Fit true to size but I could have sized up for a more oversized look. Nothing too special, but got a lot of use for everyday wear.

Looked strange on me!