So cute and kept me warm and fashionable, comfortable and trendy for a girls lunch date

I love Madewell and this top doesn’t disappoint. Fits true to size. Can we worn to work, dates or just to bop around. Make even buy!

The length is shorter than I would usually pick if it is zipped up. I like the length of the sleeves and the fit otherwise.

Runs mostly true to size but the waist feels a full size smaller. If you have a longer torso, please note it is very cropped. Fabric is thick and warm. Overall very flattering and was a great rental.

This jacket is more cropped than I was hoping for and it hit above where most of my high-waisted jeans ended. The color combo and striping is cute so I rented it for the holidays but the wide collar and cropped length stopped me from wearing it more often. For the cold girlies, this jacket is pretty warm since it's double-lined. A bit too warm for me but still a solid quality piece!

Wore this many times and loved it, super cozy and cute with jeans.

This was a great fit for a shorter, cropped style sweater. It also came new with tags! Cozy. I especially liked the style of the sleeves. Ballooned out a little.

This was a fun easy sweater. Lots of compliments

Nothing to write home about in my opinion. It's is warm and very comfortable though.

A little tight around the waist. Wore more as a sweater. Didn't wear as much as I expected to

Cute sweater but harder to style than I expected. Needs very high waisted jeans or pants

Not a wow but a solid basic. Runs tight, should have sized up.

I usually wear XS or XXS in Madewell tops. I found a like a little small!

Great for every day. Cropped length.

Overall true to size but cropped fit

simple, easy, work from home sweater.

Runs small and fits weird! Probably good for wfh!

Good quality, color and a good option for those who are itchy-sweater averse. It's a bit more cropped than I would have liked

This fit well and was cute but nothing to write home about. Also not very warm. It was windy when I wore it and I could feel all the cold air through it.

I didn't wear - the overall fit was cropped, boxy and lots of fabric. I couldn't get the neck/collar to sit right with the zipper. Note it's pretty cropped, I wear high waisted pants so wouldn't have been an issue

This was thick and soft and had a nice weight to it, but it was very unflattering. It was bulky through the shoulders, particularly with the collar. The waist then was too tight. Ultimately, I just ended up wearing it around the house. Nice for a cozy, at home, kind of day but nothing I would wear out and about

Sweater fit but the fit is weird and I felt uncomfortable in it all day. It’s too bad because it has a lot of potential and the item I received was brand new with tags.

The red dye bled from the jacket onto my pants. Really sad.

Very narrow waistband, very wide arms