So cute and kept me warm and fashionable, comfortable and trendy for a girls lunch date

Great quality. Runs a little small and cropped. It is lined like a vest on the inside. More for cooler months.

So cute, fit great. I sized up one so it wouldn't be super short and it was perfect!

Loved this! Thick, cozy sweater that wasn't too cropped.

Loved this!! It fit great, but I would also have loved it a bit more oversized.

TTS, cropped but not too short

The zippers are so fun! I nearly met them in the middle for a little sex appeal that worked well with the wide leg pants.

Perfect sweater for running errands. It is warm and fashionable without being too heavy.

Cozy, nice quality, easy zip up. Came in great shape and TTS or size one down. Love this!

So cute!!! Really good thick material but still nice and soft. Definitely kind of cropped, I could’ve done a size bigger but this fit well. Would totally buy it! I love the double zippers!

Warm and such a cute color and style

This gives a polished look and is so easy to just throw on. I wore it to my daughter’s formal pictures. Glad I didn't go for the XS as the S was perfect.

I love Madewell and this top doesn’t disappoint. Fits true to size. Can we worn to work, dates or just to bop around. Make even buy!

It fit great and was just the right cropped length.

I live in Florida and wore this on one of our coldest days this winter. Its really cute and comfortable. For me, the cropped style didn't work when it was zippered so I left it open and it looked great.

This is a quality piece and very warm. As other reviewed mentioned it is quite short.

The length is shorter than I would usually pick if it is zipped up. I like the length of the sleeves and the fit otherwise.

Runs mostly true to size but the waist feels a full size smaller. If you have a longer torso, please note it is very cropped. Fabric is thick and warm. Overall very flattering and was a great rental.

Very warm sweater. More of a light jacket honestly. Very cute and casual for every day.

This jacket is more cropped than I was hoping for and it hit above where most of my high-waisted jeans ended. The color combo and striping is cute so I rented it for the holidays but the wide collar and cropped length stopped me from wearing it more often. For the cold girlies, this jacket is pretty warm since it's double-lined. A bit too warm for me but still a solid quality piece!

Cute but cropped. Wore shirt underneath.

It was a tiny bit more cropped that I expected it to be, but I loved it! I've never worn an item more that I've rented.

Comfortable and true to size! Wore on repeat! Only wish was that there were pockets. But other than that, great jacket for casual everyday wear!

Fit well- it is thick and warm

A bit short. I'm only 5'2" so was ok for me but I feel it would have been too short if I were any taller! Fabric was nice and cosy.

Excellent jacket, it's more structured than pictured and nips at the waist.

Loved this! Was hoping it'd fit a little more oversized but it's actually pretty tight throughout. Glad I sized up to medium!

I am a big fan of Madewell. Wore this as an everyday top and loved it. Best with jeans. Comfortable and warm. Highly recommend!

Comfy, cozy, warm, and looked good!

I didn’t want this to be cropped so I sized up to a L and it was perfect. I’m normally an XS for reference.

Wore this many times and loved it, super cozy and cute with jeans.

This was a great fit for a shorter, cropped style sweater. It also came new with tags! Cozy. I especially liked the style of the sleeves. Ballooned out a little.

This was a fun easy sweater. Lots of compliments

Nothing to write home about in my opinion. It's is warm and very comfortable though.

True to size

Great! True to size!

Comfy slouchy. Love the double ended zipper.