I liked this dress a lot! It had lots of give so I wasn’t too confined. I wore it while breastfeeding so I was BUSTY and the XL fit me well and wasn’t too tight across.

I was surprised that I actually liked the stress as much as I did thought it would be cheap because of the price point, but it was very comfortable and perfect for a celebration of life Service. Has a great fit and I like the sheer arms. Fits perfectly and does have stretch

I styled it with cowboy boots and wore to a holiday work party. Comfortable and flattering.

This maxi dress is effortlessly chic and flows beautifully with every step. The lightweight fabric makes it perfect for those crisp, fall-like days in a warmer climate. I wore this in Galveston Texas to a holiday party and it was perfect for 70 degree weather. It does run a bit roomy, but nothing a stylish belt can’t fix. Comfortable, flattering, and easy to dress up or down—definitely a go-to piece. You could pair it with boots or a heel like I did.

Wore the recommended size, incredibly comfortable, loads of compliments

Love the cinching on the sides, great for the figure. Extremely comfy. Ttl. I will likely buy for my permanent collection once Madewell has a sale.

This dress has a deep red and navy pattern that feels elegant and seasonally perfect. The sheer sleeves add a nice touch of softness, and the length gives it a polished look. The fit is comfortable, but the fabric does cling a bit around the midsection, so it works best with shapewear or in a size that allows a little extra room. Overall, it’s a lovely dress that can be dressed up or down.

Great fit. Lightweight fabric perfect for transition to fall.

Don’t love the color combo either; not sure I’ll wear it!

Wore this to work — super comfortable and easy to move in. I got a few compliments, but overall thought it was just okay. Nice for a polished office look but not a standout piece.

Rented this as a back up for a cocktail party. It’s nice, but not amazing. Good for thin ladies- not particularly forgiving if you have a little extra around the middle!

It's hard to tell from the photo but it's just a little big. So I am going to order it in a medium which is what was recommended for me but I was nervous the chest would be tight. So good job RTR on the rec! I'm excited to try this in the medium!

I liked the print and shape of this dress along, but found it ran a little big and a little long

Nothing really special about this dress. It was cute but I wouldn’t rent it again.

Very stretchy. Size down if you want it to be tighter in your middle section.

Flattering & fun, perfect for winter date night!

This is fitted all over with ruching on belly. I can see it bunching wrong if you seek it to blend the area.

I've rented this dress in two different patterns before, and each time, I get compliments

Got so many compliments on this dress. So flattering and a good length for a petite gal.

Loved this. Just ordered the same style in another color. Shoe pairing was a challenge for me with the colors, but otherwise loved.

Wore it for a date. Absolutely loved it. Very flattering and photographs well. Very comfortable as well.

this was a flattering classic dress- perfect for hosting thanksgiving

Fit like a glove

I think this dress was my most-worn item of 2025. I wore it to lunch, out to dinner, to a friend's gathering, to a memorial service, to church, to a meeting, to a happy hour, and more. I reached for it almost every time I needed something to wear. Loved it and the fit was great with some ruching that was flattering. Also, it doesn't wrinkle, so I could put it in a bag and take it with me to change elsewhere when needed. Somehow, I only have partial or group photos in the dress, though!

Fit perfectly, very comfortable

Great fit and comfortable

Wore this a bunch. Really loved it. Received many compliments. Nice to wear a dress that feels like lounge wear but presents as much more.

Wonderful fit! Took pounds off! Wore to bridal shower and lived long sleeves, but think fabric.

I wore this to a wedding and it was perfect. The color and sleeves say "autumn" but it is so light and breezy that I stayed cool on the dance floor.

Comfortable fit, maybe could have sized down

I wore this on a date night with my husband 38 weeks pregnant and I loved it. So comfortable and flattering.

So perfect. But a little loose in the stomach

Fits right and so soft. I wore it to church. This one will be on the roster for sure.

Comfortable but looks fancy

Comfy and photographs well!