This pair of jeans is very comfy and oversized. Even at size 26 it was maybe a little to baggy. Going to try 25 and see if thats a happy compromise

They run big so size down. Barrel is subtle which I prefer. Probably going to buy

I took this pair on my international flight and throughout my holiday. It was comfortable and versatile for all the ways I wore it. It was a tad big for my waist but nothing a belt won’t fix.

Loved these so much I bought them!

My size was never available so I rented the next size up and yep too big and gets bigger as the day goes on... but I loved them!!

I wore it a couple of times for different errands or events. Could be dressed up or down. It rose up the center a little at times and gave me a weird bulge so I had to stay cognizant of where they sat on my body. I’d likely rent again though

I never wear a 26…like never. Not even in hs was I a size 2 but these jeans are meant to be worn loose in addition to the fact that MW jeans run big. I’ve rented these in a 27 as well and think I actually prefer that size for comfort. But I don’t look great in real baggy denim so I went with the 26. Length is a perfect crop on me at 5’7” and rise is just at the navel. Barrel leg is subtle and imo perfect.

Really cute oversized jean! They were a smidge large, needed a belt, but very doable. Would rent again!

At 5’10, I wish they were a little longer…but they were OK for running around. I like the seam details.

I loved these and would rent again in a smaller size but they were gigantic. I am normally a 30 or at smallest a 29 if a Jean runs large, but I swear I could maybe wear a 28 in these. I had like 2 extra inches in my waist! The actual jeans, style, color and fit were super cute so I’m def going to add to a future rental in a 28 or 29 to try again.

Runs late and stretches out with wearing. Baggy jean. Comfortable for wearing around the house. Only wore out once, not the most flattering.

These jeans unfortunately gave me a camel toe. They fit correctly in the waist but for whatever reason they have an odd seam that results in camel toe and a weird seem up the butt as you can tell in the picture.

I ended up buying them new from another store I loved them so much. If you are my size you could almost size down to a 26. The 27 was a tiny bit big but I like them that way.

Honestly I will probably end up buying these jeans because I loved them so much. Really comfy - fit a little big in the waist (I'm normally a 26 and the 25 fit well and got a tad baggy)

wore many times

These jeans were so cute - I got a lot of compliments, and they were so comfortable! Unsure if these jeans were cut because they're frayed at the bottom, but in the picture, they are not? Either way, I loved the overall fit and the length was perfect, which are two things that are so hard to come by being midsize and ultra short.

Love these jeans, maybe size down one

I was obsessed with these!!! Normally I am a size 12 and these were large. I'd order a size down next time. I would have loved to own these!

I loved these so much I'm going to buy my own pair. Very comfortable take on the barrel jean trend

So tempted to keep these, I go between a 27 and 26 at Madewell. I sized down the 26 here and am glad I did. They were snug during the first wear, loosened up in the waist as I wore them

i wore these so many times: to a yankee game, to church, to dinner, to work. i love the leg detailing and shape. the only reason i didn't buy is because the waist ran big. i had to use a belt or strategically layer a longer shirt over the waist.

Great fit but think I could have gone down a size. I am usually a 27 but have been in between lately. Could have gone with a 27 for sure

Flattering. Comfortable. I rented again

I sized up and wished I hadn't, but I still wore them a ton. Really comfortable,

Perfect comfy fit without looking sloppy

perfect fit

Loved these so much I bought them. They’re so comfy and fit great

these were a perfect light wash and a great fit slightly cropped and a little bit low rise, but the button fly keeps things tight

Big in the waist

Loved how these fit. Loose but flattering cut

Extremely comfortable, mid-rise, great length for 5'4" with sneakers. The barrel dart gave it some shape, so it wasn't too casual.

Wasn’t confident about how I would like the barrel shape but I loved them. They are extremely comfortable jeans that I will consider renting again/buying.

I wanted to try the barrel jean trend but wasn't ready to commit but these jeans were my favorite. They're really comfortable and fit loosely on my waist. I am only 5'3" so regular jeans are usually too long but with platform sandals, I thought they were a good length.

these are great barrel jeans, not too wide! I accidentally ordered wrong size but these are meant to be a little baggy so no problem. Normally wear a 27 so true to size I would say.

I will say they run large. I sized down based on other reviews but I wish I would have sized down 2 sizes. very loose in the hips but the fit was still cute so I wore them for a casual friday night out. I honestly think I might buy these directly from madewell in my correct size.

They were too big in a 31 and the smaller size not available at the time but would order again

Wasn't sure of this new trend. That's why RTR is so great! I actually love these jeans on me. I could have sized down, but they are very forgiving either way. So comfortable.

Loved the fit and style. Very comfortable. Wore it everywhere. So glad I got this.