My only issue was I should have sized up (they were a little tight in the waist), but otherwise loved these. I'd only wear these with heels since I'm not tall.

These are so cute and on trend for spring!! I love wearing them with sneakers during the day and strapping heels for dinner! So cute and comfortable! Definitely cropped (I'm 5'9) so be prepared to embrace that!

I was hesitant to rent this but am really glad I did. The pants are a fun staple and very comfortable

Super comfortable and soft. I received a lot of compliments. They do run a little large, so I got a size down for sure. Will rent again (if I don't end up buying!)

I figured these were going to be too big , but wanted to try anyways. Definitely size down atleAst one size. I'm usually a 28. I could wear them for about an hour but then they stretched out and were too loose.

Love these jeans - they got a little baggy throughout the day as most jeans do. They're also thick, but I was comfortable wearing them in the summer. Just something to keep in mind!

I normally wear 26/27 but 24 fit snug & stretched well enough to be comfortable sitting

Wore these 3 times on vacation, Madewell really knows how to make jeans! Does run long on a 5’2 woman. I wanted them to hit above the ankle so I rolled them up twice (about 2inches). I usually wear a size 12 and ordered a 32R.

These pants are awesome! I accidentally ordered a 25 (usually a 24 at madewell) so I belted them and left my shirt untucked. Very cool wide leg jeans. Will rent again in the right size!

Love the fabric and slightly worn wash. Perfect length for my height. Adorable and versatile.

Fun play on black denim. I have to wear mostly black to work and these were trendy and flattering while also being comfortable. The high waisted buttons hold you in and give a nice shape. Will rent again.

Nothing special comfortable though

Fit around thighs/hips/butt but horribly big at waist which made my stomach look huge. Didn't wear anything tucked and muddled through the month wearing these a few times.

I just love how MADEWELL jeans fit. Specially the Wide legged ones! The color was so nice too. Easy to pair with anything and SUPER comfortable. Probably not the best in a very cold winter day but otherwise just perfect!

My daughter selected these for me telling me they are on trend. They fit great and are very comfortable. I wore this pair a few times, but just didn't vibe with my style as they made me feel frumpy.

I read the reviews on sizing before renting anything - I am petite and slim but have a booty so sizing can get complicated. I read the overall suggestion was to size down, so I did it...well once I was able to try them on they were just too tight on the hips. Couldn't wear them at all. Style is nice though but unfortunately could not wear them :(

buttons fit tight

My regular size wasn't available so I tried to size down - nope - couldn't get them on!

Really cute and casual - the fit is super comfortable and goes with everything!

sturdy material but stretchy so it's forgiving. true to size.

I wore them twice...once with a patterned short sleeved sweater and winter jacket and again with lightweight yellow v necked sweater and a black jean blazer. Got compliments.

I wear a 28 in madewell jeans and these are no different. They fit perfectly! As the other reviewers have said, they are a heavier fabric, but don't make you sweaty. So so so many compliments!

Great fit, comfy, can dress up or down

I love these jeans so much! I have dressed them up & dressed them down and they looked amazing. They fit true to size and being someone on the shorter end the length was perfect. My only comment would be they do get a bit stretched out as you wear them through the day but they are GREAT!

Really like the cut and color. Fabric was very soft but had enough hold.

Great jeans that instantly give you that cool factor, but still are stretchy and comfortable. I did not wear often because they were a bit too cropped for me at 5'10" but will be going to Madewell to purchase them in their tall inseam length.

So flattering, so comfortable. Perfect for summer when it's too hot for traditional skinny jeans but you don't feel like putting on "real clothes." I actually flew in these and they were still super comfy. Didn't want to send them back!

So flattering but wash wasn't my favorite. Super high waisted, nice crop, makes your butt look incredible.

These pants are amazing!! They are soft and comfortable, flattering, and stylish. I will say that once they are on, they stretch out throughout the day, almost a full size up. As such, I would go one size down next time for my perfect fit. I love them so much I already bought them.

These fit well but the crop was quite short, so I couldn't wear them in the NYC cold. Would rent again in the spring though.

Loved the flare and button up fly. Would love if they were a little more high waisted

Legs are wider than expected... but super comfy and cute. High waist. Perfect to pair with a basic (white) tee.

These were fun! Stylish, good fit. The leg is more exaggerated than other cropped pants, and I like that the waist is high.

I typically wear a size 27 in jeans, but can go down to 26 in some brands (J Crew). I ordered the 25 because that was all that was available, and it was a risk. I was able to wear these, but they were tight. They loosened throughout the day thou. I loved the style and could see myself getting a lot of wear out of them. I would size down one size.

These fit well, super comfortable! Would have loved if they were 2-3" longer on me.

A great classic, comfortable jean. My husband said it looked like I was preparing for a flood but I didn't care. A very cool pair of jeans.

I normally wear a size 33/34, but tried the 32 since it's the largest size available and other renters said it runs large. While I could button them, these jeans gave me major cameltoe. I love the style and look, but wish RTR carried larger sizes in Madewell since I know the stores carry 33+

Very flare but on trend

I love these jeans- perfect for work if you work in an environment that allows denim. They're super stretchy and high waisted, i probably could have sized down from my 27 to a 26.

Stretchy and runs large, I'd go down at least one size, maybe 2.