Enjoyed wearing this piece and would consider purchasing! Double zipper gives versatility and the material is soft. Appreciate the collar for a more "put together" look.

This top is so versatile!!! I'm honestly regretting not buying it (prob gonna rent again & buy tbh!!). I wore it to work zipped up, but unzip it a little and you've got a super sexy top for a night out or date night! You can also dress this top up or down. Seriously a must rent.

Love this one. Great staple piece, super easy to style and the double zipper detail adds an optional sexy element. Considered keeping!

Can be dressed up or down! I got a lot of use out of this!

I’m 5’2 and it’s a perfect fit. It you like to wear styles like Rachel Greene from friends then this is up that alley. Really comfortable and form fitting!

Good neutral. Easy to throw on and wear. Goes with just about any bottoms. The way it fit was flattering.

This was a cute piece, but I swapped it for something else because I didn’t wear it a ton. Would be perfect for an everyday office look, or a weekend fit. I liked that the zipper placement could change the look, and the cropped length is flattering.

Loved so much I bought it. Really versatile as a top or sweater

Very comfy and warmish. Easy to wear

Loved this piece to elevate a casual look.

any way you slice it, this simple sweater is a winner. dual zippers for maximum flexibility. neutral color and mid-weight to literally work with anything, anytime.

Ordered a size S instead of my usual XS hoping that it would look a bit more work-friendly but it was pretty wide in the tummy area. I still wore it but not really the ideal look imo

I thought this might be a little stretchier but it's not. It's cute but I would size down if I rented again for a more fitted look.

This fit pretty well! I'd say it's slightly short if you have a long torso. This was a perfect layering piece for traveling, and the color went with everything! The zipper is a little tough to bring together, but I really love that there's a top and bottom zipper.

Súper comfy! Wish it was more of a cropped fit. Great for fall with jeans

I have a short torso and this felt short to me - but if sized up not sure if it would look baggy or if it would be longer (wish it had another 2 inches to the length). Nothing special but good to rent if looking for a neutral versatile item

It was a little weird to style but it was comfortable

I loved this, it was well made and looked nice on. I’m normally a small or medium and went with medium here which was a little bit loose in the belly area but still super cute! It can be dressed up or down and is pretty warm and comfy. Would recommend!

This fit well, and did not stretch which I really liked. It zips from bottom or top, which is fun. I wore it for a ladies Christmas light boat show, with jeans and a tank top. Fun, easy, would be a nice staple to any wardrobe

I really liked the idea of this top and Madewell’s sizing is always weird on me with a bigger bust and butt. I usually have to size up one or two sizes, so I did and this time it was way too big. I also think it would look a little better on someone who is taller or at least has a taller torso

After I'm done writing this review, I might go back and buy this. Like yes it's simple, but it is the absolute definition of an elevated basic. I love how you can make it sassy with the bottom zip. I wore it with cream linen pants and a white tank top and white flip-flops and I felt like an extra from Succession. Effortless cool.

Fitted but flattering. Great simple casual sweater. Runs true to size

This is great for a pulled together casual look! Comfortable with just enough stretch to not be fussy. I wish the zipper was gold - otherwise this is a great top!

Sizing was good and the shirt isn't too crop. It's a great shape item and goes with a lot

wore nearly eveyday. it comfortable, love the double zipper, and it just easyyy to wear. allllllmost bought it

This was perfect for everyday wear. It's not too heavy at all. Zipped or unzipped I loved the crop and the collar for creating an elevated everyday sweater!

I wore this a few times and got compliments on it! I wore to work, brunch and on a date! Super versatile. Only thing is the zippers can get a bit wonky so I had to adjust them a few times. I did consider almost buying this though! Flattering and cute

Able to wear on its own or with another shirt/tank underneath

Easy to dress up or down and got compliments every time I wore it. Great neutral color.

Cropped but still covered with high waist pants.

Fit just right across the chest with not much extra room but loved it and was very comfy

I usually wear a small in madewell but have a long torso and larger arms so I went with a medium and I think it fit perfectly.

Fun to wear - versatile

This is a great light weight knit top. Would be great in the early spring. I recommend if you want something cozy but still keep a sleek shape. I would have bought but it was priced too high for the quality.

Perfect way to go from day to dangerous by just zipping it up (or down). It's a simple top on the thinner side (It's not very warm) but great to go from a more conservative smart casual to a little more low cut and peak of skin.

Soft, goes with everything

Great fitted sweater second time renting and I loved it might size down for the next one :)