Fit TTS I wanted a baggy fit, so I chose a size up from my normal Jean size. Probably going to regret not purchasing but I wanted something a little longer for a permanent spot in my closet.

Relaxed fit, went with everything! It does loosen up after a wear or 2 but that doesn't bother me. Loved the fresh cut

I got 1 size above my regular size. I should've gotten my regular size. Overall I love the shape and comfort.

Fit amazing. Didn't want to return! Highly recommend

Just fine if you’re looking for a casual comfy slouchy pair of pants. I wore them to run errands and it was fine. Wouldn’t purchase or rent them again but they were good enough to wear for an afternoon

Love this style. A little short for my 5’10 frame but wore with trainers and I loved the look!

a little big on me bc I'm petite but I got compliments on them so well take it

I know to size down with this brand. For whatever reason the waist always runs a size big for me. I'm pretty consistently a 28/6 but went down to a 27 and feel like I could have gone down to a 26 comfortably. Which is crazy bc in no world have I ever been a size 2 not even like high school days. Even still, I loved these and wore them a ton. Considered buying because they really are so comfy and fairly flattering

They ran a little big but I sort of preferred that. Length was great for me, I'm short 5'0

They fit so perfect the first wear. Unfortunately they got quite loose and baggy and weren't so flattering the 2nd time I wore them.

But I wore them anyway! These were a little too short and the waist was a little big, so I wore them slung lower on the hip and with higher shaft boots. I felt like a cool girl. I wouldn't buy them, but I'm confident enough now to try other barrel leg options, and I think they are worth renting if you are shorter than me!

Agree with the other reviewer about the huge gap at the waist. Had to wear a belt. Hips felt roomy enough. Length was definitely wearable for petites with or without heels. However, I’ve found the barrel leg style often looks better a wee bit shorter than this on me. The curve in the legs hit a little low and bubbled when I was walking. Arrived NWT and stretched out a bit when wearing.

My hand is in a fish lengthwise behind in between my back and the waistline for reference. Waist runs large in these because i have never worn smaller than a 24 in my wildest dreams. Size down if you are a true 0 I would skip ⏭️ these because the waistline will be too big for you. Will wear w a sweatshirt

Technically these are a bit large on me but I normally wear a 26 in Madewell, so they fit how I expected them to. I was worried they would be too long for my height, but the length is actually ok (I’m 5’-2”). I like the overall look, I’m just not sure how flattering these are for my body (curvy with a butt).

Baggy but not overly so. Right amount of comfort

I don't have long legs and these were short on me! I'm 5'7"

This trend is easy to wear and flattering for my body when I can't fit back into pre-pregnancy jeans yet. The cut is loose and forgiving but not frumpy.

These jeans are SO comfortable! However they do run big so I would go down in size!

I loved the somewhat different fit of these jeans

I'm short and have the hardest time finding jeans that fit right especially when I'm renting them. These jeans were perfect and are meant for shorter girls. They don't really have the barrel look that I was hoping for though

Loved these so much I kept for two months. Comfortable and on trend.

The fit was great. I sized up but could have gotten my original size.

So cute but sized down and I'm glad I did.

I loved these, i almost bought them but my only thing is that i wish they had a zipper instead of button up.

Wore these over and over, great barrel jean if ylu are scared of the barrel

I was pretty wary about horseshoe jeans, thinking they might make me look huge and ridiculous. These weren't like that at all. I got my regular Madewell 28 and the waist was pretty loose, but I loved the way these jeans fit and felt. They were comfy all day.

I normally where a 6-8, I got a 6 bc it said it runs small. I wish I had gotten a 4! Lots of compliments though!

Sized 1 up and it fit perfect!

This shape is very flattering on me presently (more round through the midsection). The slight curve in the legs really balances the body well. Love the high waist, that they are easy through the hips, super comfortable. Overall Love these!

I have big thighs and these worked perfectly

They have a subtle barrel and I may buy them because they are a great length and just really cute jeans

I normally wear a 27 or 28 lately in madewell jeans, but the waist on this cut runs big, so I liked the 26 best for waist & the 27 best for length

They run a little bit big and stretch out

I found them to fit a bit big in the waist. Next time will definitely rent the 28. But loved wearing them. Several times!

I sized down 1 size, but wish I had sized down 2 sizes. They are so comfortable and cute! Want to buy these in the right size.

They are a little baggy but I'm glad I didn't size down.

I rented these twice and once I sized down a few sizes, they fit well and were super comfortable/easy to wear.

I thought they were baggy where they almost felt like a mid-low rise but super comfy and cute! Trying in a size down and might buy. Really liked them.