Very nice cardigan! It's pretty heavy and thick, so it was perfect for a chilly day.

The crop fit hit me just right with high waisted jeans or shorts. I dressed it up with cream colored wide let jeans but mainly wore it casually with regular jeans. HEADS UP! Even though I wore it with shorts here, it was a VERY thick sweater material.

Warm and comfy. A little oversized.

Wore while working from home and out to dinner. Felt on trend: the pattern is fun and the fit is perfectly oversized. Fabric is heavy enough for winter, but not too heavy. Considered buying!

Renting all of the cardis to go with maxi dresses in this last trimester and this would did not disappoint. Perfect for everyday wear, got lots of compliments!

Cute cropped sweater. Wore both open as a layer (pictured) or buttoned up on its own. Looked best with high waisted pants. It was a fun one that I wore a lot. The color isn’t quite brown it has a greenish hue, what my friend calls “pond scum green”- but don’t be deterred by that name, still a great piece! Good weight to it as well, kept me warm but not too hot.

Loved the color and was super comfy. I have a short torso so liked the cropped fit as it hit right at my waist. For larger chested ladies, the buttons don’t pucker!

Loved this sweater so much, it was hard to send back! Medium weight and not scratchy.

Loved this sweater.

Loved this sweater! It’s a nice, shorter length that hit great at my jeans and pants. Quite warm. Wore it buttoned without anything under, buttoned with a white tee under, and open with a graphic tee. Not itchy at all. Sorta boxy but I liked how it fit.

Cute & versatile, but make note that the fabric is very solid/ warm. Was a bit tighter in the arms compared to the loose boxy fit otherwise. Great for fall of an easy throw on for a chilly night.

Wasn't expecting it to be cropped. Not a fan of that otherwise good. The color is kind of meh, like brownish green

Not a fan of the cropped top but I loved this pattern and just wore it with long t-shirt underneath. Very warm for cold office spaces.

cute sweater and fit true to size. Cropped and a thicker material so kept me warm

Charming print and cozy fit/feel! It wasn't my favorite rental of all time, but did the trick for fall weather and I ended up wearing it several times to work, for casual weekend-wear, etc.

Fit perfectly and was so easy to style. This is an item I would rent again because I enjoyed wearing it so much.

This sweater is so cute. Definitely more green in person.

Love it! I'm in love with the Madewell brand now. This cardigan solidified it for me.

It’s kind of boxy so I wore it open over a tank and it was perfect!

I’m typically a medium but got a large due to availability. Was cute, warm, and a nice length. Very happy w this rental.

Simple, easy and comfortable. It was a bit more muted in color than I anticipated, but still loved it.

Runs a little boxy and definitely warm. Great with jeans

Slightly short in the sleeves, but iIhave fairly long arms

Great material and warm and cozy - could be a bit short for people who are taller than me but fit perfectly for someone who is petite!

I really liked this cardigan. It's a little boxy, but I liked the way it fit me. I was able to wear both open and buttoned closed. (37 in chest). The color is more olive green in person than brown. It's a nice color and cute print.

not for the office because of how warm it is but I wore it while outside all day one weekend. To make it more flattering I wore it tucked into jeans crossed at the front

Definitely not a lightweight cardigan! Cute fit and pattern but very warm.

This sweater is super fun and great quality! It's thicker/warmer and softer than I expected. Fit was wide for an XS but it was still cute. The description says it's brown but it reads more olive in person.

got lots of compliments!

comfortable, warm, quality fabric

LOVE THIS

casual for work

Warm, cozy sweater - this sweater is perfect for falls in the Midwest. I would rent again,