Nothing bad to say! The fit was nice and kept me warm on vacation. It’s pretty versatile so it would work well in a variety of situations.

I liked the colors on this sweater, and it was fun and very cute. Easy for every day. A classic sweater, easy to style.

I wore this for Thanksgiving day and absolutely loved this sweater! It's just oversized enough to have that cute casual look. The material is super soft. The length hits at a perfect length too (and I have a longer torso so that's a huge win for me). I got so many compliments all day on this sweater and honestly am contemplating purchasing it. It's a HUGE hit! Another fantastic Madewell find!

Slightly oversized fit, cool pattern, not itchy!

Wore this to work and thought it would be too cropped for the office but with high waisted pants it was great! Got a lot of compliments. sometimes the sleeves felt hard to eat with but it was worth it

I really liked this sweater, and wore it several times! Really soft, large/wide sleeves. It was a little large, but I think that may just be the style.

This was a nice winter staple to have in my closet. Could dress up with a skirt or dress down with leggings. It was not super long, so I thought it looked best with high waisted pants. It was a little itchy, but not unbearable.

This was an easy sweater to throw on. Not the warmest, so I did have another layer on underneath!

It's a very cozy sweater and felt roomy. My only complaint was that the neckline was slightly too big to wear anything more than a tank top underneath without peaking through. Which could be great if you're going for a look with a collar.

I liked that this sweater was a bit cropped, it showed off my jeans and belt well.

Great fit, wide sleeves and slight crop.

Really cute!

I got so many compliments when I wore this sweater. its super cute and was thick enough to keep me warm.

great for work and weekends!

great fit, true to size, perfect length

got lots of compliments using this for everyday use and keeping me warm in the office.

Really liked this for casual wear, but pilled easily

Wouldn't rent again, pattern wasn't my style - looks better in the photos

Super cozy but it grows as you wear it. The sleeves were very long I had to roll them up

Love the sweater but I did have to cuff the sleeves which wasn’t a great look

Definitely happy I rented it, but not sure I would rent again. It appears more green online but it’s definitely brown.

This sweater has a cozy vibe but was relatively lightweight.

Super cute design and cut. Somehow manages to look oversized and tailored at the same time. The only reason I'm not keeping it longer is it has got more of a fall vibe (and it's currently springtime) and it's slightly itchy, even though very soft.

This fits TTS, I'm usually a 10 and the L was the perfect amount of oversized. It is WARM!

Fit good. Looks more green in photo than it really is

It was very cute but a little oversized and not very flattering

Loved the pattern, but was very itchy

It was a little itchy. The material hung really weird on me. Didnt love.

N./a

Sleeves are way too long!