I liked this. Thought about buying it

Loose fitting button up - red - tiny detail

This button up has a boxy shape to it but I thought it was cute. Not very long but also not cropped, was the perfect length to tuck in just the front. Easy top to pair with things.

I mean… it’s ok. Nothing special, just exists as a shirt. A bit too big, but it was ok.

Perfect for spring days spent biking in the park

There is no shape to this shirt but I kinda liked it that way. It’s very casual, I wore it to my office. It was a little wrinkly and very hard to steam out

Cute casual but short in length

Cute simple shirt, nothing overly special. Probably would not rent again, but enjoyed wearing it a couple of times.

This shirt is the perfect length for halfway between a crop top and a normal hip-length shirt.

A great pop of color and great fit!

Classic Madewell top - easy to wear for work and/or weekend fun

Great top for everyday.

Loved this super casual top

A little boxy, but great everyday shirt for the weekend or office.

Got it for bfeeding, therefore convenient. Great for humid weather.

This is exactly what I expect from a Madewell shirt: boxy, breezy, not breaking any fashion barriers but perfectly serviceable with a pair of shorts or jeans for an easy everyday fit. You won't be excited but you won't be disappointed either.

Wrinkles really easily and very boxy

I liked the style and color of this shirt, but it was way too short. I tucked it in my high waisted jeans and it kept popping out. A great everyday top if you aren't as tall!

Na

The color is a bit more muted than in the picture. The fit is a bit boxy and the front is a bit shorter which makes it hard to tuck it in.

While this top is nothing special it is a cute basic weekend top.

Tuck into jeans and call it a day. Lightweight and lovely. Good fit.

I wore this a few times for casual days and it did the trick. It wrinkled pretty easily and the front was short so it didn't always tuck into my bottoms well, but it's cute.

Boxy. Nice color/pattern. Doesn’t do much for me.

didn’t love the loose fit, color had more orange undertones than I prefer