I may buy these. Super comfortable and fit like a glove!

The perfect jeans!! Soo stretchy but never stretched out, soft but still denim-y enough to hold their shape. I danced all night in these and didn’t want to send them back!

These are a great pair of high-waisted, buttonfly jeans. The fabric felt a little stiff at first, but they softened up after a couple wears. The size was just right and didn't seem to stretch out during the day. Length hit just at the bottom of my ankle. Would rent again!

I’m on the hunt for a great pair of black jeans so I gave these a try. My first time wearing Madewell jeans. So comfy, more high waisted than expected, which I love. I like the exposed button fly. Not sure I want to invest in a pair of skinny jeans but I just may because these are so easy to throw on.

LOVE these jeans. Perfect fit, comfy stretch, and they held their shape. Might keep!

This is my second time renting. Rented one size up before. Both sizes fit, with the smaller probably slightly better for weekends/more casual. Would consider buying

Loved these pants! Still debating buying them & probably will rent again. I love the high-waist and the button detail is my favorite thing about them! Try to size. Only tiny downside I would say is they're on the stiffer thicker side but were flattering!

I think these pants were great for everyday (work, brunch, business casual, etc) What I loved: Button up fly Stretchy material BUT also thick so it holds everything in What I didn't love: The pants fit weird to me (Not quite too big but didn't sit on my hips right and I have an hourglass figure) Overall 7/8.. I would rent again and potentially size down

The length was perfect but the waist runs large. I had a large gap. These are very high waisted. I found the fabric to be a little itchy but I think it's because they are new. Great jeans to dress up or down. I would have given five stars if they didn't run large

Stretchy, high waisted, perfect black jean

Shockingly these fit well on my petite height. I literally wore these every day- so versatile

Loved the fit, comfortable and stylish

Love these!

Great pair of basic black jeans. Love the button details. Fit is very comfortable. Considered buying!

Great pair of high waisted jeans. Color is super dark and the fit was spot on for me. I will rent again and consider buying.

These skinny jeans are perfect. They go well with everything. Love the button fly. Second time renting and decided just to buy it in a 27. Stretchy material, which makes them great for short girls with thick thighs like me (5'2, 144Lbs, normally a 6-8 in jeans). Only downside: if you have a dog or cat, get your lint roller ready.

These are perfect! I've never tried jeans from this brand, but these fit me really well! The stretch is minimal in comparison to other jeans I own, but I don't mind.

I ordered one size up to be safe, and they fit great!

First pair of button fly jeans in a long time. Not bad and would recommend.

These fit true to size with some stretch to them. I wore them multiple times and they did not stretch out like some jeans do. True high waisted jeans. Loved them! Will definitely rent these again!

Great recovery but if you want the stretch they run big

Wish I wore them more! Would buy

Loved the fit. Comfortable and liked the high waist. Buttons are somewhat a challenge but I'm used to zippers so that could be why. I wore these a few times and loved them! They hold their compression and looked great all day.

loved

Great jeans

Will definitely rent again so comfortable

none

Nice jeans as I expect from Madewell

Not the most flattering if self conscience about your tummy. Overall for was good!

Cute top but pretty cropped. Must wear with very high waist jeans if you don't want to show skin!

Fits perfectly in the legs and butt; too big in the waist

Madewell always fits larger than other brands. In most brands, 28 is usually ok to tight on me, but I had to keep hitching these pants up! Whether that is because of the stretch factor or the size, I dunno, maybe both. They didn't hold my lil paunch in. Also, they weren't as high rise as some sevens and citizens that I've rented. They are nice and dark and fit more like jeggings.

They are a lint magnet.

Waist was too no and for right in the legs.

I love high waisted jeans but I almost couldn’t get these up high enough so the crotch didn’t sag. They were also slightly short, hitting above my ankle. I usually live madewell, but this was a miss and I didn’t wear them.