Copied the model styling and rented the matching purse and don’t regret it at all. The color was very flattering, and the cut was simple and easy to wear. Nothing particularly exciting about this top, but it looks nice on and the color makes up for that. Fabric is like a very very thick teeshirt, like a fancy sweatshirt without the terry texture on the inside.

This picture makes the shirt look like a shapeless blob, but in real life it is structured and has clean lines. I really liked it and considered purchasing

...but a really well-made, soft and comfortable top. Has stretch to it, not too tight in the neck. Wore it for work and received compliments.

Super casual. Super comfy. Looked cute tucked into pants. Sleeves are wide.

Pretty and simple gray turtleneck. Wore to work and with jeans and home for the weekend. Only complaint it arms were slightly short in me. Great basic

Still might keep it, in fact. This was like the definition of an “elevated basic” — super comfy, easy to throw on, and yet just a little extra style. Great for weekend or work. Runs small for Madewell; I’m usually a M or even a S in their pieces but the L fit nicely here.

Love love love.

Was pleasantly surprised at how cute this looked. Wore it to work and to brunch. The sleeves are not too poofy which I like and the neck also isn't too constricting which I find to be true in many tops like this. Has some stretch as well so it's comfortable. It's not too light and not too warm, great for LA winters.

Such a pretty color. Warm and nice touch with the sleeves!

nice and just ok

I'm 5'10, 165lbs, ordered a medium, and it fits just fine. Arm's length could be a little longer, but overall I loved it It is less soft than I thought

Soft, fit nicely and love the shoulder detail!

This was too small; I was surprised a Medium didn’t fit.

It’s a really cute shirt, I just don’t like high necks

Nice sweater but nothing special. Shoulders are a bit much for the busty.

Beautiful silhouette and color!

It was a bit too casual for the skirt and jacket I had in mind. Probably much better as a weekend piece. Cute, but nothing special.

Fit well, emphasized my bust which I do not prefer. But it was a nice basic thin sweater for fall.

I debated buying it but I don't need this type of item in my capsule wardrobe.

Great for everyday with a little poof on the sleeve to give it a little something