I wore it over a body suit while exploring San Francisco and it was perfect. The inside is lined with a slick material that is on the inside of nicer coats, so it was better quality than i was expecting! Thicker material than a shaket, felt more like a light coat. Definitely oversized but i thought it was perfect!

I am obsessed with this jacket, so much that I kept it for an extra month. It's really warm, great for a New England fall, comfortable, and adorable. I've received so many compliments on it!

Wore this to a birthday party! So cute and comfortable! Oversized but perfectly oversized. I’m short so sometimes oversized things just look way to big on me.

Thick, quality shacket. Got lots of compliments for STPattys day!

You’ll wear it a hundred times.

I would buy but want to have different plaid options. So many to choose from in RTR. Definitely adds some style to your plain outfit. Very comfortable and light weight. Not for a cold day

I wore this so many times but it was just too expensive to purchase

This was a perfect layer for my Thanksgiving trip. I dressed it up and wore it out and wore it at home just to be comfy. Went well with very feminine blouses and toned them down.

Warm and casual jacket. Paired with a lot of different outfits. Great pockets! Definitely oversized so keep that in mind! I really should have sized down one. In some photos it looks like it is swallowing me! Really wanted to buy this

I loved this jacket SO much. I sent it back this week and I already miss it! It's roomy but I loved that. I was calling it "lumberjack chic," and I got compliments every time I wore it!

If you’re looking for the perfect oversized jacket that’s on the slightly warmer side, this is for you! It isn’t the most flattering, but it’s comfy, has large pockets and was perfect for the 60-70 degree temps in the Rockies!

Wore this coat / jacket to an outdoor concert. Kept me warm enough throughout the entire show where temps dropped from mid 50s when sun was out to low 40s when sun went down. Think it's light enough to work for the weird in-between temps of early spring and probably fall too, but not heavy enough for winter and not light enough for late spring. Runs a bit large but I think it's meant to be worn as oversized so I didn't mind that. Overall, I liked it and would rent again.

I know these shackets are supposed to run big but this was wayyyy too big and made me look very very large. Warm and cute but size down 2 sizes.

Great colors and so comfy but too big to wear outside of the house.

Pairs well with everything and is very comfortable. Seriously considering purchasing since I've worn it almost every day since I received it.

Wore this many times to football games and just for everyday errands. Love it!

Cute for a cooler day! Loved. Fit great

Super comfy and great for cold weather days

This was a little big for me, definitely should have gotten a small.

It was perfect for freezing mornings. It’s purposefully oversized and super cute!

Love this with leggings and boots

I wore this over everything. I ditched my coat even on a 29 degree night. LOVED IT.

Great oversized look, very warm.

This runs on the larger side but it really doesn't matter. The inside is some soft silky material and it's so warm. Would have kept it if it weren't still full price.

Wore this so many times I lost count. Cute casual and well made. Luxurious silk lining, super cozy and warm. Lots of compliments.

Perfectly oversized without having to size up. I found it a little overwhelming compared to last year's version but still loved it for dog walks and just hanging outside. Overall another great Madewell jacket.

So soft and warm, lumberjack vibes

Would buy if it were less expensive!

Great overall cozy sweater.

I wish I had gotten even bigger-so cute

Nice transitional layering piece

Grabbed this shacket as final cold blasts coming through during Spring. Easy to throw on casually, perfect for cold nights and mornings. Sleeves were way too short on me. Meant to be oversized and it was. Overall, functional but just okay for me, nothing to write home about and don't plan on renting again.

I suppose that it was nice to have a beater jacket to throw on for the baseball field. But that's where my compliments end. If you want an amazing shacket, get that red and blue No. 21 on RHR instead. The quality comparison is night and day. The fleece was kind of matted, and I wasn't sure if that was the syle or from wear. But even without that, the colors were muted, and blah. It will not get you compliments and will make you look like a broke trucker.