Rented this jacket for my vacation to Ecuador. It was perfect for the setting and was warm and cozy. It was fuzzier than expected and definitely has an oversized looked. Would rent again!

I really love this jacket! Super cozy and easy to wear and throw over just about any outfit. It has large pockets which is a plus. I love the detailed pattern on the collar. Runs true to size.

This was the perfect outer layer. Cozy, warm and stylish. Only con is that Sherpa material sweaters like this can easily look worn with too much use, but this was in pretty good condition when I rented it!

Thinner jacket, but worked well for layering in the winter weather.

This jacket is great for early winter.. it's warm without being too much and the fit isn't too boxy like some Sherpa jackets

Easy to wear, not too dressy yet not too casual

This is pretty cute and at the same time, a little plain, but sometimes we're not trying to stand out. It's soo warm and comfy and "well made".

I almost bought this. Amazing jacket. Perfect weight, perfect fit

Neutral color makes this jacket perfect for fall weekends. I wore it commuting and to a weekend in the mountains. Got many compliments.

I rented this for everyday and it was perfect. The fit was great, I'm glad I went with a small. It's nicely oversized and still fitting.

This jacket is exactly as it appears. It is SUPER warm and great to throw on for everyday errands. Nothing that stands out, simple and easy. Will buy directly from Madewell ($55 cheaper there for brand new) This is supposed to be oversized so I will say its true to size but you could size down if you needed to.

Loved this jacket, rented it twice Great white layering piece

Loved this jacket and have thought about buying a few times since I returned it. It felt like typical Madewell sizing (slightly large) to me. I really loved the front pocket in different fabric.

fit perfectly

This jacket is pretty cute. I wore it on Christmas since it was a little informal. I do think it was hard to pair with some items with clothing, but I still enjoyed it

Gave it a 4 because it looked brand new unlike many other items I've received recently. Unfortunately it was just too big in a very unflattering way & I didn't wear it. I'm 5'3 and it hung well below my bottom. Almost halfway to my knees. You can pull the sides in a bit but then the shoestring hangs down.

This jacket is very cozy with cute gingham detailing at the zipper and breast pocket, which adds a fun touch. I did not love the length. It was a little too short and boxy for me. The weirdest thing to me was how short the sleeves were. Not 3/4 sleeves but not nearly long enough to cover my wrists.

Easy to throw on and go out the door! The off white color did always make me think it was a little dirty but it's just the color.

It was fine, not my style.

Short arms

it was ok - not worth borrowing here unless you really need it.