I love my new 100% merino wool pullover that I got at such a great price. The material is very sturdy and such a cute piece to wear in the fall. This became my everyday pullover that I wear on work calls and around the house too. Also great to wear on fall hikes and under ski clothes.

This sweater is so cute for a vacation to the mountains! It's warm, thick and oversized to put layers underneath. It's soft *enough to wear by itself... but it was also scratchy enough that so wore a long sleeve underneath. Highly recommend!

I had rented a Madewell jacket similar to this in the past, so I knew I would love this! The color is so pretty, I wore it multiple times and didn't want to return! The fabric is a tiny bit itchy but definitely bearable and I will usually not wear itchy things!

I loved it.

I think I might end up buying this… it’s THE best! I wore it with Spanx leather leggings, blue jeans, leggings… can be dressed up & dressed down. I wore it to brunch at my bachelorette party paired with a cute pearl bow. It’s HEAVY, so I recommend wearing something under in case you get hot. So flattering because of the cut up on the hips, and as someone with hips, it makes me look slimmer.

Wore twice with leather leggings & a black dress. True to size, but could have gone a larger size with leggings

Really love this. Super cute and on trend. I felt like it was true to size, although it's an oversized fit. I felt like the small was perfect for my height. Little itchy in the neck area but otherwise very comfortable.

I got so many compliments wearing this and it was such a great addition to any casual outfit! I usually wear an XS but ordered an XXS and still got a great oversized fit.

Very comfortable and not itchy. The length was good, and the color is beautiful, but the sleeves were a too short.

This was so great for a weekend in the mountains, I wore it under my jacket skiing and I was warm all day long in negative windchill and never felt cold once. My only con was that it didn't smell great after the day, kinda like musty wool, so I couldn't wear it again like I hoped to. It probably could be washed but I was afraid of damaging it or not being able to return it.

I wanted to love this, but I just didn’t. It was a little boxy and the sleeves were short. The sleeves didn’t bother me too much, just styled them rolled up. Wore with leggings. Felt cute, but just didn’t love it like I thought I would.

As other reviewers mentioned, the sleeves and front of this sweater were much shorter than they appeared in the photo and almost appeared to have been shrunk in the laundering process. I also felt like it was not particularly flattering on my chest. The size was correct, but would be more appropriate for a shorter person.

Was so excited about this for my trip out west. It would have been PERFECT, but pretty positive after looking at other people's pictures and the item pictures that the sleeves shrank. They hit above my wrist and my long sleeve shirt underneath would show. Would be 5 stars if sleeves weren't shrunk.

Fabric is a thick felt. Loved it, but there's no drape--so it fits smaller than other fabrics would at these measurements.

Such a fun and versatile jacket. Also warm! I received a lot of compliments and I would rent it again!

Perfect for the wintertime everyday wear

Didn’t get to wear this one as it ran small.

Basic cover up for a chilly day with jeans. I sized up so i could layer but i would recommended to wear your regular size so that it's not super baggy in the shoulder area.

Great for transitional fall days. Color is gray/blue. Could wear all the time

This is perfect for fall. Very oversized. I would have been happy with even smaller than the XS that’s how oversized it is. I would rent it again.

I wanted this from Madewell when they were selling it but tried waiting it out for a sale and ended up missing out on it. Excited when I saw I could rent it in my subscription. I really liked it! Makes me wish I had bought it even more!

A bit long in the sleeves for my petitness

i loved this jacket! it was very cute and warm but not too heavy. it wasn't as oversized as i thought it would be, so if that's what you're looking for maybe size up! i would rent again

Comfortably oversized fit. Warmer than expected, nice heavy knit. Works more as a true jacket than layering piece.

Good fall pullover, a little stiff and boxy so not sure it was the most flattering, but I enjoyed wearing. Usual Madewell sizing.

Loose and comfortable fit!

Loved this sweater! It was VERY warm and ran big so it was extra cozy. I almost bought it but would've preferred to size down.

super comfortable, slight stretch, very soft... wanted to buy, but was still full price.

Runs big, I am usually and xxl and and xl would have fit. Nice quality, cozy not itchy at all. Looks great with jeans.

Super soft ( a tiny bit itchy). Wore for a weekend away in Montana and was a great alternative to a coat in the evening. Will rent again when the weather gets colder at home.

Everyday cozy casual sweater.

Kinda itchy

I don't know why all the reviews say this is huge! I was hoping for an oversized look but the small on me is fitted and the sleeves are kind of short... I'm usually a small in Madewell too. Way more fitted than I anticipated, but I'll still wear it, it's cute!

cute piece! it wasn't as thick/warm as i expected, but still was a great pullover and layering piece.

Great colors and oversized fit. Only issue with this piece is that it's a wool(ish) fabric that pills easily. Rent soon otherwise may be heavily worn when you get it.