Loved these and have worn numerous times! I am usually a size 26 but I sized down based on reviews and they fit perfect. They have great stretch without being baggie and are the perfect high rise

I am absolutely in love with these jeans! I may rent or buy again! I wore them multiple times and a ton of stretch, so I would size down!

I wear these all day in total comfort. Went to Madewell and considered buying a new pair, but decided to just keep the RTR ones I had. I'm a 25 in most jeans, so these must run large, but I think that is typical for this brand.

Perfect fit. Slightly cropped if you're taller will show your socks. Very flattering can dress up or down

Want to try these in about 2 sizes smaller

I generally love Madewell jeans and these are extra great. They have a nice stretch that makes them comfy for all day wear. They are TTS. I'm barely 5'4" and they were the perfect length. I dressed them up and down. Perfect for errands with my kids, travel, and casual office wear.

I loved these! Also worn to a Blackhawks game and work as well as a fall party at a friends house. Almost bought them too if it weren't for going on vacation shortly

Good fit, I wore these a lot

I liked the fit, color, and style of these jeans but they were just too short for my liking! I'm 5'6 and as you can see in the photo I need at least 2 more inches to make these look decent. I also noticed they were a bit baggy in the knees and loose around my waist- probably could go a size down and they would stretch over time. I'd consider purchasing in a "tall" size!

The rise listed in the description did not seem to match reality. It seemed to be a couple inches longer than stated and that didn't work for me. Up higher the waist then was too large and the fabric is soft and loose anyway. I made it work with a belt but wouldn't rent this again.

Title says it all!

More loaded black-grey but fit so well and super comfy

These were stretchy and comfy...conceals my belly and doesn't feel constricted. Perfect ankle length for 5'4".

I enjoyed these jeans very much, they’re soft and comfortable. I felt that they ran a little big in the waist but they’re short/cropped so I couldn’t have gone smaller. Still, they fit well enough that they were part of my weekly rotation and I liked them so much I think I will buy a pair.

The most comfortable black jeans! I sometimes feel like darker jeans run tight and are almost restrictive but these had the perfect amount of stretch and the wash was just right between black and grey.

Bought them! I fluctuate between a 25 and 26 in most brands but I love the way these size 27s fit - they give me some extra room around the waist but still fit nicely everywhere else. I’m short and these fall right above my ankles - perfect length.

I can't take these off. I wear them around the house, to work, out. Everywhere. Already considering buying them...

these jeans are perfect

Loved the rise. Loved the wash. I’m a sucker for madewell denim.

These are the absolute perfect jeans! I wore them probably at least 8 times during the rental. They fit flawlessly and go with literally everything.

Loved these and fit just as expected

High waisted comfortable and fun for work or weekends. I might buy these! Size runs true to fit

These are easy to wear, very comfortable, and stretchy. I am usually a 29/30 and the 27 was a perfect fit

Great pair to have as an every day black jean.

Love this is fit. Maybe a little loose in the waist, but not terribly. I felt so cool in these! So comfy and stretchy. I ended up buying them!

great fit, slightly big around the waist, so might consider sizing down or wearing a belt since these are made w/stretchy material and have a tendency to slide down.

Loved these jeans!! So flattering, wish I had bought them. The material was stretchy and comfortable.

Loved these jeans, they run large and are very high waisted but being 2 months post partum I appreciated that! Was sad to send them back

Fit perfect and they are really comfortable. They were lighter than I was expecting, but I still like them.

Can never go wrong with madewell jeans but sometimes their sizing is different for them

Great pants for everyday, but be sure to size down. I'm typically a 6-8 but a 28 in these pants was perfect.

These were super comfortable. Madewell can have strange sizing on some jeans, but these fit like my other 28's. Considered keeping!

These jeans have a lot of stretch but yet don't stretch out when wearing. Very happy with this rental

I wore these jeans more than I wore my leggings even after gaining a bunch of weight. These are the most comfortable jeans on the planet. I wish I could afford to keep them.

I love all things Madewell and these are no exception. Perfect rise and fit through the leg. So comfy. I would buy them, I might still buy them. :)

I liked the jeans but recommending to size down