I ordered a 29 based on reviews and glad I did becaus a 30 would have been to large. They fit really nicely I will probably buy a pair after I try out a few other styles.

This is the first thing I have ever bought on RTR. Absolutely loved these jeans! Fit great and super comfy!! I'll definitely wear them often!

I bought these jeans.

Oh how I love these, let me count the ways. Soft, comfy and so super cute. I got several compliments on these and felt great in them all day long. I paired them with the Rebecca Minkoff crop top and it was a great duo! A little loose in the crotch area, so I may size down next time, but I'm definitely buying these after I explore my size options!

These are a good staple item for the closet and loved the higher rise on these. Be prepared for a small bit of gaping around the buttons. I used a small piece of fabric tape to take care of that.

As another reviewer said the buttons pull making it look like the jeans are too small even though they were actually a bit big, had at least an inch of give at the waist and hip. This might be due to overwashing but the fabric also felt a lot thinner than my other madewell jeans and might have contributed to the fit issues. Cute in theory and wanted to like them but only wore once and wouldn't rent again

Great deal on a perfect fitting pair of jeans.

Best skinny jeans I have ever worn, so I bought them. Love the button fly. Followed reviewers and sized down to 27, which is a perfect fit. Keep their shape nicely for quite awhile before needing a wash!

Pair it with short sweaters, long hoodies…the choice is yours. So comfy and perfect in size. Stretchy really.

I see some reviews complaining about fit (particularly around the waist) but these were extremely flattering on me with the right amount of stretch. I'm also short, and the length felt great. Measurements: waist = 31, hips =36.

These were super flattering, comfortable and got better with each wear. I wore them all month long. They are the perfect everyday jean, stylish yet simple

Love the material and fit. I gave birth 2 months ago and didnt want to invest in new jeans yet but these convinced me! I am wearing a 6/29 right now in other jeans so these definitely run large.

I liked the style but they seem to run very large. Couldn't wear...

Great recovery but if you want the stretch they run big

Very comfortable, soft but not too thin. Loved the button fly & got compliments. Only con was that this pair ran large - I usually wear a true 12/14 and need a 31 or 32. Rented a 32 but could have gone down to a 30.

Pros: very comfy! Cons: Due to the thinness of the material and stretchiness—ergo the very things that make it so comfy—the buttons at the top DO gap a bit. Enough to detract from the look, even though the pants aren’t a bit tight—I normally wear a 27 in Madewell, 27-28 in anything else, and the 26 fit perfectly. I’d still wear these due to the comfort, but not when I’m trying to look put together. Under a big baggy sweatshirt would be perfect :D

Runs large and stretches out throughout the day

I love Madewell jeans and have several pairs. So I was excited to see these and try them on. However, they are a little on the stretchy side. I prefer a little more structure to my denim these days. After 1 day of wear, they felt too big. I wore them a few times just around the house.

Glad I read the reviews and ordered two sizes smaller than my normal waist size! Not a ton of stretch in these jeans.

I'm normally a 29-30inch waist but even the 27 was gaping at the waist. I probably would have fit a 25. These were brand new with the tag. They stretch a lot after the first wear.

I rented the 28 a while back and they were a bit tight. Not awful, but I thought the 29 might be perfect. No, they are HUGE and I have to wear them with my belt on the tightest setting. Crazy difference only being 1 size up