I really enjoyed wearing these. So comfortable to take a walk in or just every day wear. Love just pulling on and off! Cute fit and style. Petite friendly. Would rent again.

I've worn these jeans 6 times during my rental period, they are so fun to style! These are not your moms skinny jeans. They are meant to be oversized and I love the stretchy waistband. Goodbye to tight high-waisted jeans that pinch when you sit down. Because of the loose fit, try pairing with a crop top or something tighter on top.

These jeans are so comfy and super on trend. I am a bigger gal and wasn't sure if the baggy boyfriend look would be flattering for me, but I loved these. They do run big because that's the style, but I'm considering buying these a size down.

Tempered to buy because they are so comfortable but they are not flattering in the least and the knees stretch out and look sloppy

I rented these madewell pants to mimic the outfit the model has, bc I love a causal look and why not try comfy pants. These fit well and are so soft, but I. Didn't like the way they looked on me. I couldn't pass for tall and long.

I am a regular customer of Madewell and I was excited to see a pull on pant. Got them in my regular size and they were way too big! Wait was too loose. Very baggy, might still wear for the loose jean look

First, these are made of seriously comfortable denim fabric. So soft and stretchy. I want to like them just bc they are so comfy. But they are really not flattering. Maybe bc I sized down? I am typically a 31 in madewell and got a medium based on other reviews. But when I was taking this picture, I thought dang! These are not good looking on me.

Loved the super soft texture and baggy style, but couldn't wear without the pants falling down. The waistline IS stretchy (no button), and I thought that meant it would run small. It does not. Although my dress size runs 2/4, my pant size is typically a 4/6, and I am a strong proponent of sizing up so that I don't ever feel smothered in "comfy" pants, but these were absurdly large.

These are baggy and feel like sweatpants. Super soft and comfortable.

These jeans are really soft and comfortable. They are loose fitting in the waist and everywhere else, which I like.

Stretchy and soft (hard to believe with denim). Great for travel- wore on a few long plane trips. The waist gets a little loose- but it's the sort of thing that'll go back when washed. Loved these pants so much I bought them. I rented the Small (and that's what I bought).

The best word to describe how I felt about these jeans is OBSESSED. i loved them so much that I rented them, wore them a million times, returned them because they definitely would use a wash, and rented them AGAIN. They are extremely comfortable and such a soft material. As someone who rarely wears jeans anymore, they were the perfect way to fake it. I definitely recommend renting these and going with your typical size.

This does indeed run very large - size down! I typically wear a medium, ordered a small, and plan to buy it in a XS. So cute and comfy!

I sized down on these based on reviews and I'm glad I did, and I still had a bunch of room when I wore them but it wasn't overwhelming at all. I really loved these and will probably purchase them!

I absolutely ADORED these jeans! They are very forgiving in the tummy area because of the elastic/stretch waist yet perfectly on trend for everyday style! I have diastasis recti (abdominal muscle separation) after two complicated surgeries, so my mid section is a little thicker than the rest of my body. This was very comfortable and didn’t pull on my scars, which can be sensitive. I honestly didn’t want to send them back. I think I’m going to buy them!

Love these! I think I am probably in between sizes so they were a little large but not enough to stop me. I rolled the waist band and was in heaven each time I wore these jeans. Love them, you will too!

Love these jeans. I will probably buy them. They look great and feel even better.

Would definitely buy. Really easy to wear.

As others have mentioned, these aren’t super flattering but are very comfortable. I’m a 14/32 in jeans and the Large fit me perfectly.

Super cute but definitely size down!

Super cute, may order again in a smaller size!

Pretty good fit, especially after first wear. Don't care for button-up. Don't care for shorter pants.

These jeans were super comfy and cute to wear during the day. They run very big so size down. I rolled the top and was able to make it work. They're wide leg style and fit big. Overall I would rent again in a smaller size.

So comfortable, more of a cotton feel than a denim - super breathable and provided a ton of movement. I'm a true medium and these were falling off if me (ended up rolling the waist a la 2004) but would definitely buy in a small! Cute with sneakers or even rolled up a little with booties. I'm 5'2" and these ended right at my foot.

These jeans definitely run very relaxed and are not meant to be form-fitting. Very comfortable and a nice way to try out another non-skinny jean option. I would say that while trendy, these aren't the most flattering jean out there. But great and easy to wear working from home or hanging around the city on casual days.

Very comfy and cute but the waist band kept slipping too low for me to wear in public comfortably.

Very cute pants. Runs extremely large. Unable to wear.

Comfy, on trend, the ideal pant for eating way too many hashbrowns at brunch. Not super flattering, but that's the point. Material is a bit on the thicker side, so these can get too warm on a hotter day. I liked them, but I didn't like then as much as I thought I was going to.

For low/mid rise jeans they're very cute. I hate that this is a trend though, I definitely felt self conscious bending and sitting with these. They're big so size down.

I like baggy jeans, but these were way too big. Couldn’t wear them out because just couldn’t make them fit. They are soft and super casual so I’d try them just size down

I’m a 6-8 consistently and like my pants on the looser side but the mediums fell off! Adorable style though.

Comfy & cute but I needed to size down.

These jeans are cozy & flattering but run very large. I am going to rent again smaller.

Really, really big. These might look good if you size down but they were so big they looked like clown pants. The fabric was super soft though, which I liked.

runs large! definitely size down