Love perfect fit

I liked these but wasn't crazy about them. I generally wear a 30 but sized up and liked the looser fit but it is true to size. I would rent again!

Just needed some everyday cutoffs and these fit the bill. High-waisted and stiff denim so felt a little snug, so if your between sizes would size up. Also one side had a lot more fringe on the bottom than the other.

These shorts have a lot of promise unfulfilled. I love madewell everything, but these shorts were too baggy and so high waisted they felt like a diaper. I wore them a few times, but was never very excited about them.

These would have been so cute if I got the right size. I got a size 2 and they were too small for me.

Perfect fit!

These were so comfortable and looked so cute. Great fit, true to size. Madewell jeans are the best!

Love RTR because I can try things with no pressure! I haven't worn shorts in five years because I haven't found any I like or feel confident in. I rented a few from RTR, experimenting with different brands, styles, and sizes - and landed on these. Loved them so much, I bought them!

Love these, need to buy a few pairs. Everyday staple!

Shorts were a great quality and style. However, they were too big- but that was my fault. My size was not available and I chose to rent a larger size than I needed.

Not flattering

These were not proportioned well for me. The 27s fit everywhere but they were a little too high in the waist and little too short on the tush. The denim was uncomfortably stiff and thick as well. Went straight back.

They're simply too short and ride up quite a bit, especially when you sit down.

These were very short, I tried them on, but did not wear them out.