Great for change of seasons... sweater is warm but length allows for flexibility with boots vs more bare.

Even on an hourglass shape it still felt a bit boxy, but found it to be super comfortable and perfect to wear with tights and boots for brunch or running errands.

Not too tight. Perfectly loose. Mid to heavier weight sweater. Thickness is good for smoothing. Early bump friendly if short. Might be too short for tall girls

Not the most exciting outfit but it's good quality, warm and comfy.

I rented this for a cabin weekend in Montana, and also wore it to work. It was really warm, and I live in a very cold climate! I wore a thin shirt underneath to prevent itching. Dress was oversized, so a small on me still was loose and comfy. Loved and would consider buying!

Definitely not long enough to wear as a dress for the tall girls but made it work with leggings. Could’ve looked cute with heeled boots. Very comfortable.

I sized up and ordered M to get extra length based on other reviews. Ended up being oversized and was still a little on the short side. Was ok with shorts underneath. Fabric is warm and not itchy. Could be a great everyday dress if you are the right height and order true to size.

I ended up putting this right back in the bag. I found the style unflattering. It looks boxy on the model, and for some reason I rented it anyway. I thought it might look cuter on. It's a very heavy knit so there isn't much drape to it. It's quite stiff. Not my style. Pretty color though.

Madewell's boxy fit is great, but this dress is o. The shorter side. At 5'8" it hits me mid-thigh.

It's short. Wore once with black leggings underneath and boots and wore another time with bare legs- hubby liked that ;)

Got this hoping to wear as an around the house comfy lazy but still cute fit - it was absolutely way too big for me at 5’2” 115 lbs. Potato sack :( skip it unless you’re tall and leggy

Great fit for third trimester, VERY warm. This is what I would wear outside with my toddler on a damp, cold day when maternity coats weren't blocking the weather well enough. I did sweat through a few Zoom meetings.

Wore it with black leggings and boots. Hit at upper thigh.

Oversized fit is cute and cozy. Length is a bit short for tall girls, but would work well with leggings and boots. Would rent again!

The sweater dress is a little baggy but still form fitting, which makes it cute. It is also a little on the short side, but I think that contributes to it being a cute dress. Could wear to brunch and other daytime activities or early evening drinks.

I wear size small typically and sized up to medium at 37 weeks pregnant. It was a nice option over leggings but would have been too short as dress on own with pregnancy bump and my height.

Comfy for postpartum with leggings

Loved this - I sized down vs. my normal per other reviews and I'm glad I did, I loved how the XS fit me to make this work great for a dinner out with friends - nothing super fancy but elevated from jeans for sure! Easy to wear.

Wore this at 36 weeks pregnant - it was comfortable and cozy. The material is fairly thick so it got warm but great if the weather is cooler/colder in your area. Also, a little bit itchy but overall - not bad!

172 lbs, 5’2” wore size xl. Fitted well and it was super comfy.

Wore this during a casual dinner out. Was super warm and comfortable on a chilly winter night! Also extremely comfortable with leggings during pregnancy (wore at 32 weeks)

Favorite outfit of the month... it looks like a slouchy sweater in the model pic, but it's actually flattering and cute irl.

Very flattering. Length and fit were great. Wore with leggings and booties on a date and to work.

I wore this on Thanksgiving and loved it! The color was beautiful, it was perfectly warm and cozy without looking sloppy!

Chic, understated, comfy. Pairs beautifully with gold jewelry. Wish I owned it.

Wore this for a casual lunch and it was a perfect fall sweater dress

This dress was so cute and comfy; definitely an oversized fit so if you're looking for something more short and fitted; size down. Otherwise, small was perfect for me and still long enough that I could've worn with a belt, or wear off shoulder. Definitely recommend

Rented with my unlimited and arrived NWT! I am 5'1" and straight figured. This was a great choice for a casual Sunday, including a fire pit outside in chilly in NY. I wore it with a black shirt underneath and black leggings - it is warm and cozy but not heavy or itchy. It looks very short on the model but on me, it was a great sweater dress length. I did size up to a small as I wanted the loose fit but an XS (my usual size) would have worked too. Highly recommend esp for petites.

This dress ran a little big but that is okay - I just wanted something warm. I wore it with leggings. I tried to belt it but it was too thick and didn't look right so I just went for the shapeless dress look. If I rent it again, I will get the medium. I am usually a size 8 on top and 10 on the bottom.

It's comfy. A little itchy if you don't have anything under your upper body. I'm normally a SMALL (size 4). Stick to your size.

This is cute and cozy and would be great if the fabric wasn’t just a little itchy. I might try renting this again when it’s colder and put a shirt under it. Runs slightly large (medium was sort of baggy on me).

This is a great oversized sweater that I paired with leggings and tights - but it got a little itchy by the end of the day.