Don't second guess. If you want a pair of faded black jeans with a high waist... look no further. These jeans are insanely soft and comfortable! I do wish I would have sized down to a 28 instead of my normal 29, they stretch a bit after a couple of wears. These literally go with anything. Can dress them up or down but I tend to think of these as less dressy because of the fade. Will definitely be renting again.

These were the most comfortable jeans I'd ever worn; I ended up buying a few pairs from Madewell. I should have gone with the 29. The 30 fit but gaped at the waist a little.

TTS, stretchy fabric, more of a faded black, high waisted slimming

Fits true to size, and has a nice stretch. Love these.

I rented a size up (normally a 29) and they were a tad big. However they were really comfortable!

Absolutely loved these jeans. Fit me perfectly and were very comfortable. The color wash is on point too.

Loved these so much I ordered them from Madewell. Got them on sale. So excited to have these in the rotation. I ended up sizing down, they were a tad big since they are so stretchy.

At first I thought these we're going to be too tight but they stretched out perfectly and didn't get baggy

Really liked these. Purchased. Very comfortable

I bought them.

they fit fine, but did not support like other Madewell jeans

Pros were the color/wash and they are nice feeling. Unfortunately too tight in legs for me.

Most Madewell jeans stretch out or run big but these guys were super tight. Going to size up and try again because they are so soft!

Fit great when I first put them on but they stretched quite a bit pretty quickly. Only wore them once.