A great vacation top!

Loved this! Great not so cropped crop top! TTS for a nice fit. Perfect beachy summer top!

This is so cute and runs TTS. Since I'm short, it hit at the top of my medium rise jean shorts which is fine for hanging out in the hot Southern Summer. If you have a long torso, it will be cropped. Cotton fabric wrinkles a bit but not enough to look sloppy.

Great length, very relaxed, material feels high quality

A bit shorter than I would have liked, but it was cute and comfortable!

I've got to be honest, I had no idea what to do with the side vents, so I left them as they came. I could have done a small, but it was a solid rental for everyday use.

fabric a little stiff but cute and comfortable summer top.

This one was shorter than I usually wear, but I loved it anyway. I only swapped it because I needed some fancier items for work events coming up.

Medium comes just to the top of high waisted jeans so there’s a flash of stomach but not too much. I’m 34D and it didn’t show too much cleavage.

I’ve rented this shirt twice and will probably rent again. Cute and comfy crop. The material is thick but was still comfortable at a festival on a hot day

Got this for everyday use and fit well! I am a 36 DD (can be E/F depending on the store) with smaller shoulders, and the fit was perfect. It does have a crop top look with a bigger chest, but overall fun and looked great

The fit was awesome. Usually Madewell tops like these are too tight in the breast area (I'm somewhere between a D and DD) but this flares out perfectly. The length is also nice too for my height. Tried it with pants and shorts and it has a tiny peek of your waist but completely covers your backside (high low style).

Light and swingy. The side ties make it adjustable so you can reign in the volume to your preference.

Great quality

Nothing special but nothing “wrong”

This was fun to wear. A bit more cropped than I realized but worked with high waist jeans and a cami layered underneath.

A mild crop to pair well with high waisted bottoms. Casual shirt that has cute ties on the sides

I enjoyed wearing the top with different shorts or white pants. It is a bit loose and baggy as a top.

I like this one with jeans or shorts — super easy to throw on and look cute. ties are kind of weird

Fit well, it was shorter than expected but i wore high waisted jeans and it was able to work for the occasion.

It was too short for my taste . Maybe if I didn't have a large bust, it wouldn't feel so short. Couldn't wear it.

This shirt runs pretty true to size, maybe size up? It's definitely more of a crop than I was expecting. I thought maybe I'd get away with wearing it to my casual office, and that will not be happening. Hopefully I can wear it on my trip this weekend with my family!

Versatile staple - wore w denim cut offs by day and white linen flowing culottes at night

Nothing particularly great about this - would be a good closet staple though

My tween daughter and husband loved this on me. I was a slightly uncomfortable. It's loose and moves around a lot, ie when the wind blows, more of your midriff shows. I think I could have tightened the side straps more and kept it in place, but that didn't occur to me while wearing it. I'm larger in the bust area than the model, so even with high waisted pants, it showed a flash of midriff most of the time... It was fun to wear, but I'm just old school at 50.

Love this top. Runs very short and lays more like a crop top than I was expecting. The bottom hits right at my belly button, but that's likely due to my bustiness. Thank goodness for high-waisted pants. Super comfy. Hope to purchase.

it runs big

Super soft and could be cute on a shorter person or someone who doesn’t mind cropped tops. Typical Madewell quality.

maybe with some high high jeans but it was boxy and short and just weird to me

I expected this to be sightly cropped, but it is pretty much a bra top on my longer torso. I can't imagine a scenario where I would wear this out of the house. Quality seems good though, so would be fine for people with a shorter torso or who are happy with a quite short crop top.

This was a lot shorter than expected. Looked too baggy when wearing it.

This fit snug across the bust for me. I can usually wear a medium in Madewell, but I'll order a large next time I order something Madewell. I was not a fan of the shape of this top, and I did not find it very flattering at all.

Shorter than expected. Very boxy.

Was an awkward fit on my body. Don't recommend for people with a full chest.

This shirt was laughable when I put it on. After reading the reviews, I thought I might be able to get away with a tank under it. Even with the side ties tied very tight, the shirt just hung off my boobs. It is shorter than short.

Wore on the weekend with jean shorts, cute but a little short for me