I loved these, despite the bad reviews. They were really cute and flattering, and by far the most comfortable jeans I've worn in awhile. If I'd tried them on in store, I'd have bought them. I'm glad I got to see how they stretched first though. If this had a zipper front instead of buttons, I might have bought anyway, but with the buttons, once it started to stretch out, it just looked like I was trying to squeeze into a too-small size (even though I kept having to pull them up).

Love the button fly. This cut is perfect for curves. Forgiving material

I wore them with the Madewell yellow blazer and a white t and floral sneaks, wore them with a yellow and white striped t, I had to buy them. I wear them 2-3 times a week!!

As a short girl, these jeans were the perfect length and fit! The wash was great, and can tell they are high quality. I love Madewell jeans and these were perfect. Debated buying them!

Super soft jeans with a nice amount of stretch. I usually do not like how jeans feel or fit. I would up buying them!

Softest most comfortable pair of jeans ever!!

Absolutely in love with this brand

These are really stretchy which is great except I should’ve sized down.

These sre jeggings, but the buttons are functional. And just like everyone else, they have a weird wavy pulled look despite the jeans fitting perfect and in no way being too tight or pulling. That is seriously a bummer, because otherwise i love these! Rise is perfect - right at my bellybutton. Fit is amazing and comfortable. And best of all, despite being really stretchy they do NOT stretch out or get the annoying saggy knees. I've probably worn them 6 times before today's picture. If it wasn't for the buttons issue, I'd absolutely buy them. Or if they were cheaper. But i just can't make myself pay $75 for jeans that look like the buttons are about to pop off, even if they're not really.

I am normally a 29 but have a tough time finding jeans that fit properly so I ordered the 31. They are super soft and super stretchy, I will be ordering in my proper size !

They hit right in all the right places for a short person, but the jeans definitely run large AND they are very stretchy.

These jeans fit perfect with a soft feel fabric.

These leggings were so comfy. They do run big, I went down one size from my normal Madewell size. I wish the ankle was a little tighter like a skinny jean, but I loved the extra stretch. I'm an apple shape so the jegging style was flattering on my legs and butt without the pinch around my stomach.

I love Madewell but find them very pricey so I was glad to see they were up for rent on the app. I love a good Jegging too so I was super excited about these. Although they were stretchy and comfy I found they did stretch slightly too much and definitely cause them to run big. I got my item new with tags so after a few different rentals I can't imagine how big they'd become. Definitely size down. Also I'm 5'6 and they were above ankle length on me.

These jeans are super soft and comfortable. However the way the button fly closes it has a stretched look which was unflattering, only wore with a longer shirt. Also for anyone shorter like myself, a little too long for the cut

runs large and not the most flattering fit