Obsessed! Took this on my honeymoon to Italy in October and it was perfect! I would buy this!! Wearing this on the plane made me feel chic even jet lagged!

I love this jacket! The Quality and fit are amazing. I've been wearing it nonstop since it came

Chic, Warm and Cool.

This cost is huge! It's great for layering. I'm pretty tall, so I can handle the length and oversized look, but would size down if I rented this item again.

Wore this coat for a couple weeks mid-February and got a reputation around the office for having noteworthy style. My boss called it "very soul train" and I got compliments in the elevator from other tenants in the building who work at architecture and design firms. Turns heads in soho!! I wish I could afford to keep it.

This coat is beautifully made but definitely oversized. I chose my true size despite the comments because i really wanted to try this coat but should really have sized two down. Was fun for the weekend!

I've had this coat for over a month now. It adds the perfect pop of color to my wardrobe in the cold months. It's been great for 40/50 degree weather but i think I'll need something warmer for Dec-Feb in New York. It is also cut low so i often need a scarf to cover my chest--i wish the cut was higher.

Read reviews stating that coat ran huge, so sized down a size. This made it a bit smaller, but still large. Sleeves, however, were too short with arms bent at smaller size, but barely long enough with arms straight. Aside from that, coat was stylish, warm and well made.

Was so excited on seeing this. Thought it would be my winter coat from unlimited. Only size was 42. I could tell it would run big but decided to take a chance w it since it was the only one. It was so huge I couldn't even wear it just for a weekend - it was laughably large. I would def need two sizes smaller. So size down! It is so cool but also on a 5'3 frame might be too long- it has some gorgeous pleat details in the back that even if I sized down don't know if they would fall in the right place. It was such a shame to send this back even though it was new with tags but it was just gigantic. Hope someone else can enjoy this coat, probably need to be 5'5 or taller and order two sizes down!

I loved this coat. It wasn’t cold enough to wear it where I live, but I wore it anyway. May rent again for the holidays.

For la escuelita, the opera, dinner, long walks.

Nice coat and easy to layer underneath

This coat is very fun, stylish, and pretty. Probably best on very tall people ...? I enjoyed wearing it but only wore it once because it is really voluminous. Not sure whether a smaller size would have helped.

Gorgeous coat - nice quality and cool cut and style. Very oversized and big though- I could not wear! It is nice though and I wish I got two sizes down.

I wish so badly this coat worked for me! I've never been able to pull off that way-oversized coat look, and this piece was way too large, even in the smallest size avail. So sad, I did wear it a few times just because it is an absolutely amazing, very heavy coat. Got tons of compliments when I did wear it - one woman commented on what a statement it was, but I never felt comfortable in it. If they fix the sizing, I'd rent again for sure. Such a bummer.

HILARIOUSLY OVERSIZED but the sleeves are too short

I probably ordered a size or even two larger than I needed because I was confused by the reviews. A coat that is a bit large is usually no problem but this was ridiculous. The sleeves came to my wrists as in the model photo but the shoulders dropped somewhere approaching my elbows. The coat is long for a petite person but that is not unattractive. The plaid is beautiful.

This coat probably looks amazing if you get the right size. However, the listed conversions are not helpful. I knew this (I'm usually a US 2, typically wear Fr 34), but assumed RTR had adjusted based on typical fit etc. I was wrong. The smallest size available is equivalent to a US 4 (based on the Maryling website). So if you are smaller than a US 4, the smallest size will not fit. Size down. Bummed this apparently doesn't come in smaller sizes, I can tell I'd have loved it if I got in my typical 0/2 range.

I. Am. Obsessed. I got a 40 and it was a little oversized but still looked great. It’s great for in between weather and gives any outfit a pop

Warm and stood out in a sea of black winter coats. Kept this one a while!

BEAUTIFUL coat! Heavy and kept me warm. I love oversized coats so this was a perfect choice for me. I received compliments everyday I wore it. Excellent quality!

liked it just for everyday with jeans and a T. wore it a couple times and felt pretty cool with it on, tartan is one of my favorite prints! I just didn't love the open neckline when it was buttoned up, thought it was much nicer to leave open.

I was looking forward to this coat and even sized down by 2 sizes. I'm normally 40/size 4 and it was still humongous. The arm sleeve lengths are also short - not sure if it's because I sized down by 2 or what? I'm sending this right back. Nice heavy material though but the buttons don't button all the way either so you'd definitely need a scarf.

As other commenters noted, the fit is oversized and boxy, with shorter sleeves. Note that the chest is quite open and it's *long* Otherwise warm, comfortable and catches people's eye. I felt it was a little too bulky and out there for work, but a great cool-weather item.

Very oversized

2-3 sizes too big - i read the reviews and thought it could be a little roomy, but had no idea it was going to fit the same as a sleeping bag. Definitely go at least 2 sizes down, if not 3. I wasn't a fan of the neck cut anyways, so will not be ordering in my size.

Beautiful fabric but very large fit which was odd with not-quite-3/4 length sleeves. If sized down - and if you don't mind shorter sleeves - the fabric and tailoring are of very high quality.

The fabric is beautiful, and the teal/blue color pops really nicely (better than pictured). That said, its HUGE! I'd order 2 sizes down, and expect an A-line fit still. But the silhouette works with a slightly exaggerated collar and waist level buttons (allowing it more movement while you walk).

Had to send back unworn. It was so big, it didn't look flattering at all.

This was GIANT on me! And I consistently fit into a size small or 6. I was so confused. The coat is absolutely beautiful though.

I love oversized coats, but this one was ridiculous. I read all the reviews so I sized down. I'm a size 12, rented size 8. I returned and checked to see if they had sizes 2 or 4 available, no luck passing on this one.

Gorgeous coat, but way too large. Slightly oversized would have been fine, but I was drowning in this coat (and I typically enjoy oversize/boxy styles)

The fabric is beautiful, but the cut is very slumpy. I like structured looks for work (trial lawyer) and this just looked sloppy.

Downsize by two to three sizes.