Rented this jacket for a cold, windy, rainy end of March stay in Chicago. Tested it down to low 40s with rain. I was definitely warm and the rain did not penetrate the shell. Cons: you look like a giant sleeping bag walking down the street - NOT fashionable in the least! Attached hood does not stay on top of your head. I brought an umbrella so I did not need to pull up the hood constantly. Buttons up/down - A zipper would be easier to deal with and would have made the jacket warmer.

This coat is amazing, I love it. Wish there was colder weather to wear it during, but as a raincoat it has been very useful

This is the perfect coat for outdoor sporting events when the weather is terrible. I couldn't even tell it was raining or cold. It felt like I was in a giant sleeping bag. Not fashion but sure is function!!

This coat is so warm but it fits WEIRD. My arms are thin and with chunky sweaters I feel like Ralphie from A Christmas Story. The chest and waist fit fine though. I really prefer a zipper too.

It took me a minute to figure out the buttons (and quite frankly, I'm not sure I got them exactly right as the bottom two did not button) but it was a very warm coat and I loved the look.

I wanted this to work so bad, even though the reviews weren't great. Unfortunately the coat was very awkward -- tight on the arms and very big on the body. It was like a sleeping bag.

Way too big and way too Kung mom 5'8 and I was drowning in it immediately went back in bag to ups :(

Light weight like feathers and the warmest thing you've ever put on- friends say I'm wearing a sleeping bag but it's the warmest sleeping bag ever - it's bulky but warm - and it has no shape but did I mention it's warm - loved it

This coat is the best thing I've ever worn. It feels like bringing a down comforter everywhere with me. It's freezing where I live and I stay so warm. I want to buy it but it's much less to just buy it from the brand website so i think I'll do that

I was pleasantly surprised how light this jacket was for the size. Super cozy and comfy. I don't get to test it in super cold temps.

Must be made for yoginis before and after yoga class. I'm thin and fit but I had trouble putting this on over normal winter clothing. Maybe you're not supposed to wear it with sleeveless tops. Otherwise style is cute.