I ordered a 0 and a 2. The 0 would have been fine, except it fit too tight in the bust. So I moved up to the size 2, which ended up fitting and looking great!

fit well, slightly stiff (so no room for give, get the bigger size for your extra

This dress fit true to size. I would mention that if you are pear shaped (like myself) and have larger hips the dress does not have a lot of give, so on your 2nd size you may have to size up. Also if you tend to have a large bust the same rule applies to the top. But, I loved the dress...it was perfect for my beach themed bridal shower. It photographs great and is super comfortable. I wore the dress with nude shoes to keep it feeling summery. I would highly recommend the dress - I got lots of compliments on it and felt great in it!

This dress was absolutely perfect! The material was heavier, so it was very flattering and forgiving of any problem areas (Hips!). It was a decent length, without being too long or scandalously short. The neckline was cute and the detailing was a nice touch. The zipper got stuck a bit, but not enough to worry about it. I would absolutely rent this dress (or the other colors) for another occasion, Perfect Lilly is always perfect! For whatever reason, it won't let me upload a photo--sorry!

Wore this dress to a preppy wedding. I couldn't be happier! The process is so much easier than going shopping with two toddlers. The dress fit well and the quality was awesome. I was able to wear a regular bra. The dress was lined so I didn't have to wear a slip. I was extremely comfortable.

I originally ordered another Lilly dress, but it was damaged in the mail. RTR notified me immediately and my personal stylist, Erica, sent me out this Lilly dress. I received it less than 24 hours after it was shipped. The dress was in good condition. You could tell that it was worn and cleaned many times before because it seems like the navy color bled and stained a little of the pink part of the dress. This was only visible if you looked really closely, though! RTR has excellent customer service. Can't wait to rent again!

Loved it.........it was great.

I rented the 2 and 4, and the 2 fit perfectly! Even though this is a shift dress, it actually has a little stretch and was very flattering. I wore it to a wedding shower in the afternoon and a wedding that night, and it was so comfortable. I received a ton of compliments! This is my favorite RTR dress so far!

I rented this dress for a bridal shower I cohosted. It was perfect for the daytime event! I ordered a 2 and a 4, unsure of which would fit best. The 2 was a little tight, but was in much better shape than the 4 so I went with it. I also wore a pink cardigan for parts of the shower to be a little more conservative. It was quite short, although I do have long legs.

This was one of the dresses I wore during our Engagement photo shoot. The dress actually ran a little big, I wore a size 2. Beautiful dress!

I'm a size 10, so this 8 was tight. BUT it looked great and I got tons of compliments. If I rented this Lilly style again, I'd would need a size 10.

All pros, no Cons! Love being able to wear a dress I wouldn't normally be able to afford. I will use RTR for every event instead of buying

I rented this dress for a homecoming tailgate and it was incredibly flattering, even 10 hours later! The fabric is of a high quality and held up without wrinkles all day, even through dancing and cheering on the football team at the game. It is a thick cotton, but I was never too warm in it, even in 80 degree weather. I ordered a 6 & an 8 because I was concerned about the top fitting (I am a 32FF), but I was able to wear the 6 with ease, and I did even feel sucked in! It was also very conservative at the top, and hit me right above the knee. I got so many compliments on this dress and I would absolutely rent it again!

Fit great. Zipped up over a bra and I didn't have to think about it for the rest of the day. Key.

This dress was the perfect choice for a bridal luncheon in St. Augustine, Florida. I only rented a size 0 and felt that it was a little snug around my hips (I'm curvy in that area) and a size 2 would have felt a little more comfortable. The colors were bright and I received lots of complements on the beautiful details. If I could I would absolutely own this dress!

Wonderful dress I wore for my birthday party. Lots of compliments even from people who are "not into fashion." I like that the dress is made of thick material, it feels sturdy and well made. I actually wore it twice, once on my actual birthday for dinner with my husband and also for a party with friends. Wore spanx for the party, not for the dinner, and thought it was better with but not too bad.

I wore this beautiful lily pulitzer to my bridal shower. I wore it all day long before and after because I love it so much. It is a very flattering cut and super cute for a daytime wedding or event. It was absolutely perfect. I should say that the size 2 fit well too, it was a little tighter on the bust, but nicer on the lower half of my body, but the 4 did not leave me swimming by any means. Runs pretty true to size - I only occasionally wear a 2.

Wore this for rehearsal dinner and received SO many compliments. It fit great, and true to size! The bust area was a little tight, but not suffocating. Would highly recommend this dress to anyone!

I ordered this dress for a small outdoor wedding. The fit was true to size. I am shorter than the model, so it hit a little closer to the knee than pictured online. The dress has a nice textured fabric which was very flattering and the color combination is georgeous!

This dress fit amazingly. I didn't want to take it off. I am a bit shorter than the model so it fell just above my knee but that wasn't a problem for me, it looked great on, and it's very comfortable. Doesn't wrinkle easily. I paired it with a pair of nude pumps and it looked hot!

The dress was a little bit awkward for my body type. I had to size up mainly for the bust area which meant the midsection was a little baggy.

So comfortable, but the material was thick enough to keep me warm after the sun went down! Loved the pink and navy together. As other people mentioned these dresses were well loved and some of the navy has run into the pink.

A very slim-fitting dress, more of a straight cut. I thought at first that the dress would look boxy and unflattering, but it was such a cute look and sooo comfy!

Cute Dress but top fits a little strange. The zipper was puffing out a bit at the top and I kept having to adjust the shoulders to try and make it look normal. I wore it for my daughter's first birthday and got lots of compliments though. Worked well for a busty/ apple type figure.

Fit very but it was a little long because I have super short legs

I really liked this dress. I rented it for a friend's nautical-themed wedding shower, and it was perfect! I'm tall at 5'9" and it was definitely a great length. However, after reading reviews everyone said it ran slightly big. The 6 fit perfectly, and was even a tad snug in the armpit area. If anything I'd say get your free 2nd dress in a bigger size, not smaller size. I went for the 4 and there's no way that would have fit! I got a lot of compliments -- a perfect bright colorful dress for Springtime!

I loved the dress, but was not sure about how it looked in pictures. Also, it was very thick. The fit was also a little bit baggy.

Its a slimming dress, and hugs all the right places. Order both the right size and maybe one bigger; my shoulders aren't that broad, but if they were any broader I would have needed a size 6. It's super comfortable, and I would definitely recommend it for a party either in the spring or fall.

I ordered this dress for my husband’s graduation and it was perfect for the occasion. I was worried the hot pink would be inappropriate with it being a military affair, however it was just the perfect balance. The fit was perfect and I received tons of compliments.

I rented this for a homecoming tailgate and sadly, the 10 came with a broken zipper. I had to wear the 12, which was too big for me in the midsection and therefore wasn't as flattering. Aside from that, it's a gorgeous dress and really pops with the pink/navy combination. I'd rent it again!

Fit well!

I got so many compliments on this dress! Loved the colors!

Fits like other Lilly dresses, form fitting through the waist, roomier in the bottom

I ordered a 0 and a 2. I wore the 0, but both fit well. A concern for me is my bust not fitting well in a 0, but it did. Length was great too. Maybe 3 inches above my knee. Very happy with this rental!

I wore thise for my husband's aunt's funeral, and it was perfect for the occasion. I paired it with a jean jacket for the chilly evening and nude pumps. It was very sophisticated and classy.

This dress fit perfectly! I am short (5'1'') and the size 0 hit a few inches above the knee. I got so many compliments -- I would definitely recommend this dress. Much prettier in person than it looks on the model.

The size 4 fit perfectly, but was very close to not being able to zip in the back because of my chest size.

Really cute dress. Slightly shorter than I expected but that was fine because I like short dresses. I got the 0 and the 2. I expected to wear the 0 but it was kind of tight in the arms/bust. I was really happy that I had the 2 because it was looser and seemed more appropriate for a day time event.

I own several Lilly Pulitzer pieces, but I seldom wear them to a key event twice. I decided to rent one, which was effortless. As always I loved the fit & length. I am large up top, so the zero is a tad snug there. However, the 2 swallowed me everywhere else, so I opted for the zero. It fit like a charm!

This was my first Lily rental as I was always nervous about my chest fitting in the traditionally smaller cut Lily dress. I recieved a million compliments and felt super cute and sexy. I ended up wearing the 6 rather than the 4 because of chest.