Really enjoyed this jacket and it's versatility with casual and dresser outfits on vacation. The lining made it perfect for 50 degree days in California. It's not super thick or bulky. I loved the fur on the collar!

I have this a 4 out of 5 because I wish it wasn't peplum. It didn't give me a shape like I would have liked but it did fit well and was warm.

Flares out at the bottom which makes the whole shape a little bulky. Mid weight is good for fall or mild winter days. Cute faux fur collar detail looks high end and not cheesy. Wearing it way more times than expected so that must be good!

This jacket was huge and didnt fit like i thought it would. Felt like a chef jacket. There is a waist but the peplum is so full it adds bulk. Also the pockets on the front are huge and not flattering. One nice thing is the fur is removable so you can go for different looks

I LOOOOVE this jacket and wore it almost the entire season several times a week. It's roomy enough to wear with layers. The fur collar makes it look dressy and elegant differentiating it from any black jacket. It's warm enough for cold fall weather (mid-50's to low-60's), but not too warm for cold winter weather. I would highly recommend this jacket. I'm even considering purchasing it! I got a lot of compliments when I first wore this to work.

Very cute and versatile

Great fit, super fun

perfect..fun ... easy to wear

It fit really nice, a little bigger than expected but really cute

Loved this jacket. It fits TTS and is super warm without being bulky!

I wore this almost everyday for a few weeks. Great outerwear piece!

Loved it but too small

Definitely runs large, I should have ordered down, but still love it, warm, comfortable, pretty, many compliments

It is a cotton fabric, really casual so bear that in mind. The fur collar and lining are both removable which makes it more versatile.

It was bigger in the waist than I expected.

A little loose fitting but that's the style, I think.

Fit perfectly

Fit well

Fit smaller than expected. Sleeves are short but wore as 3/4 length and it worked!

I read the other reviews saying it was very unflattering but was still determined to try it as part of my unlimited. I actually think the peplum hits me at a perfect spot on my short torso and I didn't think it added a bad amount of extra volume, so it's probably more ideal for petites. I do agree that the sleeves are very short, about half an inch shorter than I'd like for a jacket. on a person of average height / arm length they would be more like a bracelet sleeve - not ideal for cold weather.

Arms were too short or I would have bought it.

Adorable but be warned you will resemble a tent when it's zipped up, if you like a very roomy jacket it won't bother you.

This jacket was perfect for cold weather. The inside is fleece lined and the fur collar is to die for. The overall fit of the jacket is slightly bulky, and the arms were a little tight for me to wear anything thick underneath it. Overall a great night out jacket though!

Loved this jacket. The arms were short though but I wore a long sleeve under it and it was fine with jeans, etc.

Great piece. Wearing to an outdoor bonfire/bluegrass party at night. Black is starting to look a little worn at the seams probably from dry cleaning, but faux fur is in great shape. Excited to wear it.

This jacket is super cute with a cute ruffle at around the bottom but it runs big! I normally wear a small and wish I would have ordered the extra small. It took me a while to figure out how to attach the fur neck piece.

It is so cute but when you zip it up, the bottom bellows out a bit too muchy and, like others have said, its a bit awkward. Super cute if you can wear it open

Sleeves were on the short side. I layered it on top of a long sleeved tshirt and rolled the sleeves up on the jacket to make it look intentional.

I am usually a L or XL in kate spade and decided to order a size up since I wanted to layer underneath. Mistake! The coat was very large, but beautiful. The fur is detachable and has to be connected when you receive the coat. If I ordered again, I think I would size all the way down to a M.

Arm length short

Had such potential but the bottom billows out like a peplum and gives no real shape or structure to the jacket

Cute but didn't love. Runs very big.

it was very large

Huge and unflattering. Definitely avoid if you have a short torso. Quality was good and it would definitely keep you warm in 50+ degree weather. Mine did not come with the fur collar. Sad it didn't work out, just not for my body type!

the peplum bloused out too much and it was tight in the shoulders. maybe would have been better in a larger size.

Runs small when layered

Jacket fit ok, a little boxy. The ruffle puffs out some, a little like a maternity top. I didn't get to enjoy the full look because the faux fur must be removable since it wasn't included in my order.

The fit ran a little big for me wearing a medium, but the sleeves were very short. I am 5'7", so typically do not have a sleeve length issue, but while the body was large the sleeves were really short. I wore to a heated hockey rink, and it was cute, but it's a wear once and return.

The peplum-inspired ruffle isn't flattering, especially in the back. The material doesn't have any stretch to it and I found it a bit tight in the arms/shoulders. The fur collar is removable, which is a nice flexibility.

The peplum detail gave me a pregnant look, so I didn't wear it