I understand now why reviewers were saying this sweater is really thick. No matter your expectations, nothing prepares you for how thick this sweater is. Definitely size up! I had a hard time getting in and out of the sweater because it's so tight. On the plus side, this sweater is SO warm that if it's a little cool outside, you can do with a light jacket on top or not at all. On the other hand, I was unable to wear a specific coat with this sweater, because the sweater was so thick that I couldn't get the coat on over it. Fun sweater though, and would consider renting again in the cool fall weather.

I loved the contrasting navy and bring orange yarn. Fit was great, loose enough to be comfortable without making me look boxy or shapeless. I wore this almost every day for the time i had it with my unlimited membership.

Rented this sweater to wear Christmas Day. I loved it. Fit perfectly and was very warm and comfortable. It is very thick! A lot thicker (and stiffer) than it appears in the picture. But, I preferred it that way so I was very satisfied. Definitely wish I owned this one!

Perfect versatile sweater! This sweater has a stiffer feel to it and feels as if it is more closely knitted together than other sweaters I've worn, giving it more of a structured, heavier feel. I recommend sizing up if you want something that has a more loose fit, but I love the idea of this in my true size over a classic collared shirt and trousers for work. Love!

It was a little small, but did stretch out. The weave is so interesting. I got a compliment at the grocery store. It is very thick and not for warm days. However, it's cold here and it was nice to run to the mailbox without putting on a coat.

Great sweater medium weight sweater. You can wear it with a heavy coat and stay cozy, or work it solo on a spring day like I did. The fit is boxy but it's still pretty fun. The colors are red and NAVY (not black like the photos).

I wore this sweater just to hang out in over the weekend for a football game and Sunday brunch. The knit job looks so much cuter in person up close. The knit is a blue/red orange weave that pictures just don't do it justice. The sweater really stretches out after about an hour of use and still looks cute but looses its shape.

Cute sweater but knitting is super tight making it relatively uncomfortable to do anything. Even pulling sleeves up to wash hands were quite the challenge. It was also pretty short, so unless you are brave to bear your mid drift mid winter, you will need to layer with a tank. Made small!

I ordered the medium because I was afraid of the body being too short and I don't like that. The material is super thick and I wasn't a fan at all. The arm length was too long and I had to roll it up and then couldn't push the sleeves up to wash dishes. The color is between and orange and a red. Not my favorite rental.

Not very movable but the material is definitely sturdy

This sweater is runs a tiny bit long in the arms but is super cute and chunky.

In the short time I wore this sweater, I received numerous compliments, some even from strangers! It can be dressed down with a pair of jeans and flats for a comfy-casual look or dressed up for the workplace with a skirt and cute booties (which is how I wore it). I do want to mention that the arms are LONG! I'm 5'4" and the arms reached my fingertips. So beware if you have shorter arms than me! I was able to bunch the material in an unnoticeable way so that the sleeves were not quite that long. Also, this material is THICK. It almost felt like armor padding knights used to wear. However, it is warm! Once on, I adjusted easily to the material. Overall, I am in love with this piece! I recommend it to any looking for a versatile sweater.

Love the color, fitted silhouette and very long sleeves. I didn't find the sweater so stiff, as others have noted. It is definitely short, but I am short-waisted (and long limbed) so this was perfect. Definitely will remain on my list to rent again someday.

Fit well, short and very heavy material!

Great sweater - easy to wear. Arms were a bit too long for me, but it was not cumbersome. Also, the knit is heavy so it wears a bit stiff. I'd definitely rent again though. I wore it with dark blue jeans and it looked great.

Hits perfectly at the hip. Chunky knit but close-fitting so you don't lose your curves :) Beathes well. Great colors - bright navy blue and a subtle tangerine orange woven together. Flattering and super-easy to wear. A great daily wear choice.

Everyday wear. Thick and warm without being sweaty.

I liked this although it is red and blue, it really looks red and black in the picture. Could just be my computer but the fit and quality are great.

I like the way this sweater looked, but it wasn't that comfortable. The fabric doesn't have much give.

Very thick, red and blue, didn't need a coat for a fall day. Tight but loose where you want it to be.

I wore this sweater to work. I ordered a size up to wear it as a cozy sweater, yet this sweater was very small still and stiff. I was not impressed by this piece. Got compliments but it was not comfortable like a sweater should be.

Very tight and stuff fabric. Did not wear

Of course it's a chunky sweater so it isn't form fitting but with skinnys and pumps or boots its perfect. I woun't recommend for someone taller as it is a little short.

I liked it but ran a little small. It's also a very heavy material.

The sweater is really cute and a great material but it is short and runs small (pretty tight). I would rent again but go one size up.

The fabric is much heavier and thicker than I thought based on the photo. It's a thick and heavy non-yarn fabric woven together, both red and dark blue. Very short sweater that would need a layering shirt underneath if you are not wearing it in a more of a slightly crop-top kind of way, but there's no room in the sweater's sleeves for layering shirts. I'm usually a size 4 and I wore a medium and it was still too short and tight. Overall, it felt like I was wearing a loom-woven potholder that had shrunk a bit in the dryer. Note the neck is a bit wide, almost boat-neck-like. Pros: soft fabric that is not itchy at all, and the fabric is very substantial considering the price of the piece.

The sweater wasn't soft like I expected and was made with more of a tough knit. It's not a horrible top, but the ribbing on the bottom creates a muffin top effect - and I say this as someone who's a size 2. I was going to wear this to work but don't think I'd feel good enough in it. Feels slubbish and unflattering