I was afraid that the XS would be too short for my long torso, but it wasn't. The sleeves were a little restrictive, but I was still comfortable all night. The specific shirt I wore had a snap that kept popping open. Would definitely rent this one again.

Although it is elastic around the shoulders, it definitely runs small. I was a tiny bit uncomfortable with how tight it was. I highly recommend going up a size! Other than that, adorable top, easy to match, perfect for summer time!

I had a birthday coupon to use and no big event so I got this shirt to wear for my 30th birthday party. I am loving showing off the shoulders recently and this was no exception! Super cute and fun. I would not recommend it for a night out with dancing as the sleeves did ride up easily if I put my arms up, but for a casual evening, it was perfect.

I rented this for a date night with my husband and was pleasantly surprised with how flattering it was. Sometimes with boxy shirts you can loose your shape - but this one was an exception. With the buttons down the front, the stripes and the just sexy enough off the shoulder it ended up being one of my favorite RTR selections. I paired it with boyfriend jeans since it's a bit crisp here now, but I will definitely be looking to rent this again in the summer to pair it with white skinnies & shorts!

Love this top! Felt great on

The fit was great, color was awesome! I'll definitely rent again!

Rented this with my Unlimited subscription. Was a little weary about it because I thought the elastic shoulders might be a constant struggle, but this shirt was an A+! The material is great, it doesn't wrinkle as much as you'd expect. The length is perfect (I like my shirts a little on the longer side and strike out quite a bit on the top side of RTR). The best part is the shoulders stayed down for me! I went to lunch in this, walked to the restaurant, had a few beers....not once did I have to adjust the shoulders. Very impressed. A must rent!

I loved this top. I think it can be dressed up or down. I plan on wearing it several times.

This fit well, was comfortable, and easy to wear. I thought the buttons were a nice detail that other similar tips don't have.

This shirt looks great with so many different outfits, it's really comfortable (although lifting arms above your head is a no go) and looks so great - I wore for coachella and got plenty of compliments

Loving the off the shoulder look this season! This casual top by J.O.A. runs true to size, with more fit in the bust and shoulders. If you're above a C cup or have broader shoulders you may want to consider sizing up. There is no stretch to the actual fabric, but does have elastic stretch in the shoulder area. Works great with a strapless bra or nubra! Pair with skinnys and simple jewelry.

Everyone love the shirt! Wish I got an extra small instead of the small though. Runs a little big. But overall it's great.

I am usually an XS but I needed a small in this shirt. Overall okay top. I got it for free in the RTR April promo so I wasn't too worried about it.

The top ran a little large I'm normally a standard small but could have done an xs in this. Cute for day time events though and super comfortable!

Thin fabric but makes it light and airy to wear. Is not see-through and would be good for all body shapes. I paired with white jeans but you could probably do a more interesting bottom!

Cute top a little bit baggy at the bottom but my boyfriend really liked it

A true woven with zero stretch, which is why I suggest sizing up if you have a C size bust. Even with a bandeau, there was still pull. Fortunately, this blouse was designed well with a snap closure between buttons at the bust line. I loved wearing this for a casual day, received many compliments! Right on trend for the season.

Off the shoulder look was beautiful. Ran a bit big for my petite frame, but not enough to return it. Quality material, I would have preferred to wear on a cooler summer night. I was pretty hot in the 90+ degree weather. Warning: be prepared to adjust anytime you lift your arms!

This top fit pretty true to size. It kept riding up to rest more on top of my shoulders versus my like arm like a true off the shoulder, but it didn't bother me much and I enjoyed wearing it out for a night on the town on our weekend away.

Cute with jean shorts or tight jeans and heels. Would definitely rent again.

Looks great with jeans and jean shorts! So cute, I bought it!

I wore this top going out and got so many compliments. I highly recommend it!

Very original shirt. Got just to wear around on the weekends. Liked it so I ended up keeping it. I usually wear a small or medium but there was no way a small would have fit. If you are on the fence, order up, particular for the bust area.

This was a great piece that can be worn all day and it's very comfortable. I would purchase this piece if it was available.

Fits true to size. Received so many compliments while wearing this top, the vertical stripes are flattering.

This shirt is great. It has a nice relaxed fit, and is a super fun date/or day top. LOVE!!

Wore this for everyday and really likes it! I found the material to feel a little strange or "cheap" but was certainly cute and fun to wear! Great for a summery night out or a date!

The stripes were bolder than I expected but still loved it. Worn for a brunch b-day.

The top is very cute but with the buttons it makes it difficult to move your arms around a little bit. So better for just an night out than a dinner, but super cute. Tight around the chest on me personally probably because of the buttons.

The summary says it all. I thought this was perfect for summer. I've been wearing it with denim shorts and bright red lipstick. It's the perfect summer shirt.

Love, love this top! Perfect for casual days and evenings. I got tons of compliments, so much so I bought it!

Flattering, fun, easy to wear, so many compliments!

True to size

Great top, genius hidden button that clasps right over your chest so that you aren't revealing too much. The top was longer on me than the model.

Comfortable casual

I loved this shirt. I wore similar to the model in this photo with a cropped ripped jean. Could easily dress up more with heels. The elastic around the wrist was pretty worn out and a little baggy, but you couldnt notice too much.

Pros: Off the shoulder stayed in place nicely, great sturdy material Cons: Fits large (I tucked into some high waisted shorts to keep the bulky parts from being too noticeable

The fit of the shirt was great. I received a ton of compliments on it. I just didn't love how shiny the material was in person. It made seem a little cheap to me.

Fits true to size

I wore this shirt to a couple of BBQ's and absolutely loved it! The fit was perfect and goes great with jeans or shorts.