This sweater is so good. Usually a cropped asymmetric hem does nothing for me but the cut of this is mysteriously flattering. And you'd think big diagonal buttons reads frumpy but the scarf is CHIC. Smooth fabric, no pilling, very warm. Biding my time before buying this.

This is such a great and unique sweater… It was perfect for a snowy day and lots of zoom meetings.

Loved wearing in this sweater. It's warm, but not bulky. And very stylish.

I rented this sweater to wear to work and it was suddenly warm in San Francisco! Rather than return it unworn (it was too cute for that) I saved it for a work trip to Chicago. As luck would have it Chicago was also unseasonably warm BUT that is still colder than SF! I loved this sweater, the scarf part didn't bother me at all and I had no issues with fit. Might come back and buy it later!

Gorgeous and Bulky, but perfect for a cool winter's Day. The long scarf is attached, so that can get annoying, but I didn't mind.

Super warm and cozy.

Based on the reviews I knew the scarf would be problematic! But I was ready! I used a safety pin to pin it to the back of the sweater so it wouldn’t keep falling down. I had zero problems with it. The sweater fits really big. Again based on the reviews I knew to size down and the sleeves were still long & roomie. My only concern with it as well as any other knit from RTR, they ALL begin to peel & knot up. For a full retail price of $800 with a possible consideration of purchasing @ $600, I want my sweater to look 100% unworn. The sweater wasn’t terrible but you could tell it had a few wears... However if you want that wow factor & to experience unique fashion, this is it! Go for it.

This sweater was bulky, but it was WARM! It was perfect for a fall night outside. As others commented, the scarf was a little annoying, and got in the way at times. Overall, it wasn't the most flattering sweater, but it was cozy and warm and just what I needed for a chilly night outside.

Wore many times. Enough interest for a video call. Soft and warm.

Loved it so much I bought it.

Awesome

Heavy, scarf is a bit awkward, but I still liked it. Runs large.

It’s a cool looking sweater but it is super heavy and not comfy sitting in a restaurant or bar with the heat on, especially with the scarf. Did not wear. I imagine it could be useful at a ski lodge or something.

I really love the idea of this sweater and wanted to try it after reading the mix of reviews. For someone curvy like me, it ended up being a miss - it was too big in some places (arms, mid chest) and too small in others (waist, length). I think it would be amazing for someone a little less busty and hippy!

It was just okay. Runs TTS

A little too baggy for my figure. In nice shape

I only wore this once over a tank top but it was extremely itchy. As soon as I got home, I rushed to change out of it. But I gave it two stars because it's very cute and I love the creativity with the integrated scarf

I didn't wear this sweater as it was huge, very unflattering and heavy material.

I'm obsessed with this sweater. Easy to wear. Wore it several times. Warm but not too warm. Nice color- darker than expected. Didn't think the scarf was heavy. Only downside was stuff stuck to it very easily.

Buttons do not actually button. Scarf is an extension of the sweater. Hit at a nice length on torso.

Soft, warm wool and cashmere in an unusual colorway with an attached scarf and button details make this sweater a really unique and luxurious piece. It has the softest hand and really distinct details. This piece is oversized, but I don't think it would work if you sized down and tried to make it tighter. It's just meant to be large and cozy. Love it.

I LOVE this warm cozy sweater. I got multiple compliments when I wore it. I know some other folks felt like the scarf collar was a bit unruly, but I found it totally manageable. It would be perfect for fall. And I wore it under my coat on a freezing NY day. And despite being thick and warm, it's not too oversized. LOVE.

Wore this in cool Northern California weather and it was perfect. Really comfortable, unique and stylish, got tons of compliments. If it wasn't so pricey and a bit worn already I would purchase!

I loved this sweater, I even considered buying it. It's very warm, with a great color and comfy, flattering fit. The scarf fell down quite a bit (especially in the wind), but it definitely added a lot of flair to the sweater. I wore it a few times, all on cool fall days with just a t-shirt underneath. It'd be difficult to wear with a jacket as it's bulky, but would do well under a cape. Lots of compliments.

The color, fabric, and fit are all very special. The attached scarf can be tricky/awkward, but it also makes the sweater special.

I got this sweater with the tags still on and have worn a few times - not sure I'll be able to send back! Unique and great with the built in scarf. Wore to an outdoor football game with 40's temps and it kept me very warm. Definitely recommend!

I initially laughed a lot when I took this out of the bag because the "scarf" just looked like a giant tube for your head or body and I didn't understand it at all. It was a little bit scratchy/itchy to wear but was otherwise comfortable and casual, yet it still looked elevated. It looks as pictured. Runs large but that is the fit.

VERY warm sweater. There's an attached scarf that's isn't very obvious in the picture that would make this sweater hard to wear under a coat and it could be too warm to wear inside but if you have an outdoor event or ski lodge type environment this sweater would be great. I really enjoyed wearing it

Fun and unique

I wore this with a skirt and boots, but also with jeans. This is very soft and cozy. You can use the attached scarf like a head wrap or a neck scarf. The detail On this piece are lovely. The buttons really unbutton, so there is a teensy flap knit along the line giving it visual depth. On the back there is a little deliberate asymmetry that adds flair. And it's a beautiful color.

Scarf bothered me a little but liked it overall.

Cool, interesting, very warm.

perfect fit, extremely warm and unique. Took it on a ski trip and got many compliments. The scarf is huge and so much fun.

Excellent fit!

Cozy

its a very nontraditional over sized warm sweater that pays in compliments!