This dress was amazing. I received so many complements, between the color and the interesting shoulder straps. It was a bit on the sexy side for work, but I owned it. The length is classy and the fabric lays nicely.

Fit like a glove, comfortable and festive! Felt great for Southern California holiday party !

Rented this for my grad photos after my photo her insisted I have at least two outfits and I'm so glad I listened to her! This red was so vibrant and the dress looked amazing against my skin. It's of extremely high quality. I had to wear spanx to zip up the last inch but the fabric is heavy enough to where it's not obvious. I can't wait to get my final edits as this picture was taken on my phone.

This dress is a gorgeous fabric with enough stretch. Wanted to provide my measurements to help others, as I wish I would’ve sized up. 5ft, 126 pounds. 32DD, 28 inch waist, 39 inch hips. I was wearing shape wear in this photo, but it was a too tight for comfort in the hips.

The reviews were very helpful. The decorative sleeve was slightly restrictive.

I loved this dress, it’s different and very flattering. Lots of compliments!

I loved this dress. It was comfortable and easy to wear. I ended up wearing the 4 because the 6 was too big at the waist. And the dreaded sleeve did not prevent me from dancing all night. Would absolutely rent again.

Based on most of the reviews I read I was expecting the one shoulder detail would bother. I was able to accommodate it and it worked out nicely. The fabric has the right amount of stretch. Found this dress very comfortable to wear and would rent again. I recommend!

This dress is beautiful! It was a unique style that stood out, but not too much. The red is very rich. My only call out is that the shoulder sleeve was a tad restrictive on the dance floor.

The fit was perfect & I loved the color. It would be perfect for a formal dinner or a wedding.

Timeless and classic design! As other stated the shoulder piece is very tight so if you need to do a lot of upward motion with your right arm this will not be the dress for you.

Stunning dress, fit very well and was comfortable. Limited movement of left arm, but did not bother me during the event as there wasn't a ton of moving around.

I rented for a work holiday party so opted to wear the 8 instead of the 6, but both fit! It was very form fitting but the material was thick so it smoothed out any lumps and bumps. The color was beautiful! Other people complained about the shoulder part getting in the way of dancing. This wasn't a dancing party so I didn't have that issue but I can see what they meant (my range of motion was limited with my one arm!).

I ended up not wearing this dress, but it is beautiful and the fit was great. The drape sleeve is sassy.

Wore this for a fancy dinner date. It was gorgeous and beautifully constructed with careful lining. I'm really big on the bottom and almost everything rides up since there's almost never enough room or give for my hips to move freely. And being smaller on top it's hard to find a good fit in the bust even with the right bra. This was no exception on the bottom so it did require some tugging down here and there to keep the skirt slit in place but the rest fit nicely through the waist and up top.

I did end up wearing spanx's because it isn't the most flattering in the stomach area.

The fit was amazing! I am still getting used to my postpartum body but I felt amazing in this dress! It was snug in all the right places. The only bummer was the lack of movement in the straps.

This was my first RTR experience, and it was really great. I picked up this dress along with a backup in store. The women working their were very helpful. I ended up wearing this dress for my 30th birthday dinner. It fit really well and made me feel so elegant and sexy. The slit was perfect and there was just enough cleavage. I couldn't move my arm with the shoulder strap. But I was okay with that.

I got a million compliments on this dress! I felt like I was pulled from an old Hollywood movie set. I wore it to a cocktail party. dress code specifically said “rebel against the little black dress” and it was perfect for it! My girlfriend wore a dress in sunflower yellow and we matched perfectly.

Very nice dress, but I have big hips and it was riding up and it was wide at the waist.

I like this dress and it fit my body well but I needed a petite length. A little too long for me at 5’3” but I still felt pretty and received compliments on the dress. The strap stayed up and I didn’t have to constantly adjust it.

I knew from other reviews that I wouldn't be able to lift my right arm up, but I didn't think about using it to get in and out of an SUV, etc lol. Somewhat of a challenge. I weigh 125 pounds and the 4 was too tight in the stomach area. My back up size was a 2 so I knew that was not an option. It was very stretchy and comfortable, though. Overall a nice dress.

Beautiful dress but would recommend going up a size because it has no give. Fit true to size after removal of compression wear.

The dress looked great on and was very flattering. I will note that it is nearly impossible to get on alone and the arm feature is very restrictive. I was just at a fundraiser so not raising my arm was no big deal. Other than that, no issues. Recommend!

Loved the color and the fun shoulder, but the dress is not a very thick material and seemed to accent all the wrong parts. The lining underneath was bunching and did not lay flat.

This dress was beautiful and also very comfortable. There is not much give with the shoulder detail but overall really loved this dress.

I love Jay Godfrey dresses! The fabric is elegant and great quality. This one ran a little smaller than usual, but still flattering with the one shoulder.

Very comfortable, enough room to dance and wiggle around. While others thought the one strap hand was restricting I thought the total opposite.

Loved this dress. I went to a wedding where folks mainly wore dark or muted colors. This dress stood out due to its true red color. Caution if you're shy haha. Dress is really fitted, size up if you want a little more give. When seated the split is not too revealing.

Yes, you cant raise one arm up but who cares. You will be absolutely stunning and wow everyone who sees you. This dress is absolutely beautiful.

This red dress fits very snugly. Be prepared to bear the bod. It does not allow for a lot of movement of your right arm and cutting my food was difficult! I consider it worth it. It is a head turning fancy cocktail dress. The length was conservative, but the slit was very sexy.

This dress is gorgeous but I ended up wearing another dress for my anniversary! I will rent this dress again for another event.

Gorgeous red dress, tons of compliments! The shoulder drape does make it a little difficult if you want to raise that arm completely up over your head, but it didn't prohibit me from dancing and having a great night!

This dress is stunning! Definitely be aware that because it is red, it shows every curve. However, it was beautiful! In regards to sizing, I typically wear a size 4 bottom, but dresses are size 6 because of my top half. I wore the 6 in this dress, so my midsection was actually a little loose. However, I was comfortable all night!

This fit like an absolute glove. It was trye to size and comfortable. The color was gorgeous I was complimented all night. Only con is that the body of the dress kept shifting and the slit would move as opposed to staying on the left. Other than that, amazing dress!

Pros - the color Cons- not the best dress if you aren't really thin. You will definitely need good undergarments if you are thicker. I wore the dress to a professional function. It was a tad too revealing for the event.

Fit was amazing, a little bit bigger on the hips.

Loved this dress and received so many compliments on it, however I was very glad that I sized up!