4.5
140 Reviews

Includes written reviews and customer fit feedback.

Most members say this item
Runs True to Size
Fit Summary
Runs Small (11)
True to Size (57)
Runs Large (5)
Member Photos (0)

Flattering and fun

Dress fit great, I'm broad on top and so find it difficult to zip things across the back, the structure of the dress is really fitting and flattering. Loved the length and I'm 5'1 so most dresses run a little too long. This one worked great.

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 2R

Usual Size: 2


EileenTop Contributor

Size 2

5' 1"

128 lbs

Petite

34C

34 yrs

Browse Eileen's reviews (7)

Cut in all the right places!

This dress is fantastic! It looks so much better on than online. If you have curves then this it is for you! I would definitely be renting again!

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 14R

Usual Size: 12


VictoriaTop Contributor

Size 12

5' 4"

178 lbs

Hourglass

34H

28 yrs

Browse Victoria's reviews (5)

Love Jay Godfrey dresses - silky smooth and comfortable

I am between a 4/6 and wore the 4. It fit really nicely. Like a glove on the waist line slightly loose on hips and chest but looked really pretty. The looseness allowed for my extra vacation weight, material is smooth and you couldn't see undies but maybe if it was tighter like someone else mentioned you could? I did not wear a bra and the chest area had room for more cleavage than my 34b/c chest but I love the cut of the chest i feel like it had support also in it. More at @sherentstherunway

Size Worn: 4R

Usual Size: 4


EmilyTop Contributor

Size 4

5' 4"

135 lbs

Athletic

34C

39 yrs

Browse Emily's reviews (206)

Loved the fit.

I loved this dress! It fit perfect. I'm between a 12/14. I got so many compliments and felt great in it.

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 14R

Usual Size: 14


RTR MemberTop Contributor

Size 14

5' 5"

200 lbs

Hourglass

38D

48 yrs

Browse RTR Member's reviews (3)

True to size, sexy but not too revealing

Wore to a friend's wedding, fit was perfect. I had to use shape-wear and the adhesive strapless bra, but even with that, it was so comfortable and I got lots of compliments on it. Especially liked the way the bust fit: even though I'm a D cup, it wasn't too much.

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 14R


RTR MemberTop Contributor
Browse RTR Member's reviews (1)

Wore to a wedding and got tons of compliments

Great dress with just the right amount of sexy. Fit was true to size. Picture is from the initial try on, I wore spanx for the event which I recommend as it is a stretchy material.

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 6R

Usual Size: 6


RachelTop Contributor

Size 6

5' 6"

136 lbs

Hourglass

34D

36 yrs

Browse Rachel's reviews (213)

Loved this rental!

This was a stunner. Absolutely loved it! I probably could have worn a 2 as the 4 was a little loose in the chest but was happy with the fit. Wore to an outdoor wedding and it was really hot. The dress didn't show sweat. Would definitely rent again!

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 4R

Usual Size: 2


Staley Top Contributor

Size 2

5' 2"

125 lbs

Athletic

32D

32 yrs

Browse Staley 's reviews (12)

My favorite dress!

I absolutely love this dress and would rent again! I chose it to wear to a corporate holiday cocktail party in a theater. The cut made me feel sexy but not too revealing, and the length was perfect despite being on the shorter side. The material was flattering (aka didn't show every lump) and comfy. The only con is there's not too much stretch to the fabric. It's a little tighter in the hips if you have wide ones like me, but still zipped easily enough!

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 6R

Usual Size: 6


HaileyTop Contributor

Size 6

5' 2"

140 lbs

Pear

34C

23 yrs

Browse Hailey's reviews (17)

So flattering. Show stopper!

A form fitting dress that hugs every curve. Obsessed!

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 10R

Usual Size: 10


AllieTop Contributor

Size 10

5' 9"

Pear

34 yrs

Browse Allie's reviews (19)

Perfect wedding guest dress!

Loved the fit of this dress! So comfortable to dance in all night. Would rent again!

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 6R

Usual Size: 6


AliTop Contributor

Size 6

5' 3"

130 lbs

Full Bust

32DDD/E

30 yrs

Browse Ali's reviews (118)

Stunning!

I loved that this dress was sexy in a not too revealing sort of way! The slit in the chest area is very tasteful and flattering. My husband loved it and I felt so confident in it! Wore it to a wedding and felt like I was in a James Bond movie next to my husband, haha! Would totally rent it again!

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 2R

Usual Size: 2


JordanTop Contributor

Size 2

5' 7"

125 lbs

Hourglass

32DD

27 yrs

Browse Jordan's reviews (25)

Loved the cut and fabric! Would definitely wear again. I'm 5'10" and 180 pounds for reference.

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 14R

Usual Size: 14


JackieTop Contributor

Size 14

5' 10"

180 lbs

Athletic

36C

28 yrs

Browse Jackie's reviews (4)

Beautiful

Love the fit of this dress. Made me feel sexy and beautiful! Tight fit so you can see some seems. Definitely will Rent Again

Size Worn: 4R

Usual Size: 5


RTR MemberTop Contributor

Size 5

5' 3"

136 lbs

Athletic

Browse RTR Member's reviews (1)

Gorgeous dress

Rented for a wedding, received tons of compliments! Very sexy, especially for a large bust, but not overwhelming, high quality fabric, the color is a little more berry than true red.

Size Worn: 12R

Usual Size: 10


KatherineTop Contributor

Size 10

5' 3"

175 lbs

Hourglass

34D

31 yrs

Browse Katherine's reviews (3)

Gorgeous dress!

This dress was awesome! I received so many compliments all night. I could've probably worn the 2, but that size wasn't available. It def runs true to size. Thicker material that hides all the extra lumps.

Size Worn: 4R

Usual Size: 4


BrittanyTop Contributor

Size 4

5' 7"

130 lbs

Full Bust

34D

27 yrs

Browse Brittany's reviews (10)

Perfect dress to dress up for formal wedding or dress down for less formal

The dress fits like a glove but because the lining/fabric is thicker, I felt supported and "held in." The dress does show lines (underwear, shape wear, bra, etc..). The color of the dress is between red and pink. I received many compliments and would absolutely rent again.

Size Worn: 6R

Usual Size: 4


HannahTop Contributor

Size 4

5' 6"

140 lbs

Athletic

30 yrs

Browse Hannah's reviews (2)

Classy but fun!

Great fit and color. Loads of compliments.

Size Worn: 4R

Usual Size: 4


GraceTop Contributor

Size 4

6' 0"

135 lbs

Straight & narrow

32D

26 yrs

Browse Grace's reviews (1)

Felt Beautiful All Night!

I got so many compliments on this dress and felt so good wearing it. Beautiful color, more of a pink red, but I loved it. Fit was perfect, in the bodice. The chest area was a little loose and the straps a little long but I could get away with it. Gave it 4 stars because of that. 5'2", 135 lbs, athletic build. 34B/C chest.

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 6R

Usual Size: 4


RTR MemberTop Contributor

Size 4

5' 2"

Athletic

34B

44 yrs

Browse RTR Member's reviews (4)

Form fitting & easy to dance in

Fits true to size. Very difficult to get wrinkles out of and fabric is on thinner side (definitely wear a bra if you get cold like me haha). Felt comfortable all night long in this dress. Easy to dance in, the straps are not adjustable though which was annoying, they kept falling down.

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 10R

Usual Size: 10


RTR MemberTop Contributor

Size 10

5' 4"

150 lbs

Hourglass

34DD

23 yrs

Browse RTR Member's reviews (2)

Great dress!

Loved the color and cut of this dress. It's a good red. Wore it with layered gold jewelry and heels for a formal dinner. I think I could have sized down to a 0 but it wasn't available. The 2 fit my butt and shoulders great -- but it was a little big (or maybe stretched out ?) in the stomach area. Allowed me to indulge at dinner without worrying so wasn't the end of the world ;)

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 2R

Usual Size: 0


LindsayTop Contributor

Size 0

5' 5"

115 lbs

Athletic

34B

34 yrs

Browse Lindsay's reviews (9)

Love this designer!

This is the second dress by Jay Godfrey i have rented, and I have loved both! The stretch in the fabric is amazing, super comfortable to wear all night! I'm a true 6, I would of liked this dress in a petite but with the length it looks like a midi on me which was fine. The color is a true raspberry.

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 6R

Usual Size: 6


KTop Contributor

Size 6

5' 2"

135 lbs

Hourglass

34B

29 yrs

Browse K's reviews (4)

Beautiful but ran too small for me to wear it.

Member Fit Notes

Runs Small

Size Worn: NONE

Usual Size: 10


ErinTop Contributor

Size 10

5' 3"

170 lbs

Full Bust

38DD

26 yrs

Browse Erin's reviews (2)

A great little red dress!

Fit was true to size and luckily the fabric was stretchy so it didn't feel like I was going to rip when sitting or dancing. Very comfortable and loved the color, received a lot of compliments.

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 2R

Usual Size: 4


NatalieTop Contributor

Size 4

5' 8"

140 lbs

Athletic

32A

27 yrs

Browse Natalie's reviews (3)

Love the color and the fit

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 8R

Usual Size: 8


KaraTop Contributor

Size 8

5' 4"

150 lbs

Pear

34D

28 yrs

Browse Kara's reviews (3)

Nice dress but it was loose on the chest. It's definitely for larger breasts.

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 0R

Usual Size: 0


PaulaTop Contributor

Size 0

5' 4"

105 lbs

Petite

32B

36 yrs

Browse Paula's reviews (1)

Got so many compliments!

The dress was gorgeous. It doesn't have a lot of stretch to it so dancing was kind of difficult. I wore spanx under but didn't need to wear a bra. Overall, I'm pretty happy with it. It looks red in pictures but in person it's more of a pink color.

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 6R

Usual Size: 6


JoannaTop Contributor

Size 6

5' 2"

138 lbs

Hourglass

33 yrs

Browse Joanna's reviews (1)

Looked more expensive than it felt

I ordered in an 8 & 10. I've got hips & boobs. The 8 fit good for the chest - but terrible in the hips. Wore the 10. I felt like I had to pull the V in the front up a lot because of this. Still snug in the hips though. The fabric is super stretchy so that helps. The seems can get all wonky though and you to just put and twist until it falls correctly. With the stretchy material it was a little more fitted that I had originally anticipated. It was a cute dress & I got a lot of compliments.

Size Worn: 10R

Usual Size: 8


Hannah Top Contributor

Size 8

5' 8"

165 lbs

Full Bust

32DD

28 yrs

Browse Hannah 's reviews (13)

Is it red or pink?

Depending on the way the photo flashed, my dress would look red or pink. It was a backup dress for Valentine's Day and it did the job. The lining was tight around my hips but not so badly enough I couldn't wear it. I wasn't in love with it but I didn't hate it.

Size Worn: 12R

Usual Size: 10


CourtneyTop Contributor

Size 10

5' 9"

175 lbs

Pear

36C

30 yrs

Browse Courtney's reviews (32)

So many compliments

Great comfortable fabric. Danced the night away without incident.

Size Worn: 6R

Usual Size: 6


RTR MemberTop Contributor

Size 6

5' 7"

135 lbs

Pear

32C

50 yrs

Browse RTR Member's reviews (2)

Loved this dress!

Tight fit but flattering!

Size Worn: 0R

Usual Size: 2


Alysse Top Contributor

Size 2

5' 7"

125 lbs

Full Bust

34C

30 yrs

Browse Alysse 's reviews (1)

Loved this dress!

I loved this dress so much. I'm short and had to pin the straps to make them tighter/shorter, but other than that it fit great! Got so many compliments.

Size Worn: 10R

Usual Size: 8


JennaTop Contributor

Size 8

5' 0"

Hourglass

36DD

25 yrs

Browse Jenna's reviews (1)

I'm obsessed.

This dress was beautiful. Comfortable material. Easy to move in. I was worried the length would be weird since I'm tall, but it was the perfect length. The neck line was flattering without being too revealing. Perfect for a wedding.

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: 8R

Usual Size: 6


RTR MemberTop Contributor

Size 6

5' 8"

130 lbs

Straight & narrow

32D

26 yrs

Browse RTR Member's reviews (2)

Perfect little red dress!

Size Worn: 8R

Usual Size: 6


ShannonTop Contributor

Size 6

5' 2"

135 lbs

Full Bust

34DD

34 yrs

Browse Shannon's reviews (16)

Perfect dress for a cocktail event

I absolutely LOVED this dress. The material is stretchy and light and hugs your curves in all the right places. It is professional yet sexy.

Size Worn: 2R

Usual Size: 4


RTR MemberTop Contributor

Size 4

5' 6"

125 lbs

Hourglass

34B

32 yrs

Browse RTR Member's reviews (7)

Great color!

This was a beautiful dress! Received multiple compliments. I'm 5'2" and 115 lbs and the dress was a little long on me so I shortened it with fabric-safe tape. Otherwise it was perfect!

Size Worn: 2R

Usual Size: 2


AyukoTop Contributor

Size 2

5' 2"

118 lbs

Petite

34C

27 yrs

Browse Ayuko's reviews (4)

The perfect red dress

Jay Godfrey has all my love. I was a little nervous that this would be "too aggressive" for a family friend's wedding, but it was perfect. I felt confident and comfortable.

Size Worn: 0R

Usual Size: 0


LindsayTop Contributor

Size 0

5' 2"

110 lbs

Petite

34AA

29 yrs

Browse Lindsay's reviews (168)

Showstopper red dress for special date!

Loved this dress! It was form fitted and the slit was higher than I expected but it was perfect for my height and frame. Super comfortable and can be dressed up.

Size Worn: 2R

Usual Size: 2


PaigeTop Contributor

Size 2

5' 3"

125 lbs

Petite

34B

21 yrs

Browse Paige's reviews (2)

Great fit and fabric

I loved the fabric of this dress - thick but still easy to move around in! The color was a little more raspberry than cherry in person but still a gorgeous color. I would absolutely rent this dress again.

Size Worn: 8R

Usual Size: 6


KelseyTop Contributor

Size 6

5' 9"

150 lbs

Hourglass

34D

27 yrs

Browse Kelsey's reviews (6)

Obsessed

I felt like thicc Michelle Pfeiffer. It was tight and hugged my curves and was flattering.

Size Worn: 14R

Usual Size: 12


LauraTop Contributor

Size 12

5' 5"

Hourglass

38C

29 yrs

Browse Laura's reviews (8)

Perfect dress to impress!

Fits good for DD

Size Worn: 4R

Usual Size: 6


ShaniTop Contributor

Size 6

5' 4"

120 lbs

Hourglass

32DD

31 yrs

Browse Shani's reviews (1)

1 - 40 of 140 reviews

Here to brighten up your inbox.

Emails are the fastest way to learn about new styles, sales, and more.

By clicking submit, you agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.