I rented this combo two separate times to wear for casual weekend gatherings. The ruffled collar doesn’t stand upright very well but I still liked the detail. The sleeves are LONG and get longer as you size up. I wore this in both a medium and a small and I honestly don’t remember a huge difference in fit. Note: this sweater is WARM…I’m getting pretty toasty sitting in my office as I type this!

Such a cute sweater - can dress up or down. The collar sticks up but great color. Slight itch to it.

I think this piece has just seen its day. It was missing a certain something, that little oomph a new sweater has. The collar did tend to flop, but overall it was comfy and it was cute and I wore it several times.

I thought the collar was going to stand up but instead it folded over into this floppy flowery looking collar which looked very unattractive

A little itchy/warm, but loved this piece. The arms were a little long, but I also could've worn a smaller size. The neckline is so cute. Got lots of compliments.

This was chunkier than I was expecting, making it perfect for a freezing day in Jan! It's very cozy and the neck is nice and loose but adds a cute detail!

I LOVED the color of this piece and it was so comfortable to wear. it went really great with a jean mini skirt that was sitting in my closet waiting to be worn. The collar on the sweater was a bit weird, it fell down and didn't stay up as on the picture. I sent it back to soon could have worn again with another outfit.

True to size, great length for highwaisted pants. Fun to dress up or down. The higher neck and the ruffle adds a sweet detail. Good basic, neutral color. Wore multiple times before returning

I loved the details on this sweater but it was slightly itchy and the fit wasn't flattering on my body type. Still liked it enough that I l wore it twice - just dressed it down

Nothing too special about this sweater. The neck was cute but I found the length to be short making me look very boxy. The ruffle around the neck also kept rolling down. Had to wear a tee under this one because it was itchy! Overall just an OK top -not worth the rental.

This looked like it had so much potential based on other reviews and the photos I saw in RTR - but I was bummed to find out that the collar sagged quite a bit and ended up looking very strange around my neck. The fit through the body wasn't great either - overall I was disappointed and returned without wearing

Was expecting a cute turtleneck with scallop edge. Instead the neck was completely stretched out and floppy, looked as if it had been stretched over the hanger 100 times. Also the fit was weird- short body but long in the sleeves. Avoid.

Wore this to work and it’s was easy to wear and got some compliments

The fabric isn't the best/softest, but this is a cute everyday staple for cooler weather. The ruffle around the neck doesn't stand up so can be a bit awkward, but I like the slouchy look overall and got a few good wears out of it.

Good Basic but it's itchy

This is such a cute sweater but it was too tight for comfort and also a little scratchy. Returning without wearing.

Collar doesn't stay up as it's shown in picture. Just ok overall. Nothing special.

Everything that makes this sweater appealing in the picture doesn't come out in real life. The little flare out at the bottom does not exist and the funnel neck is floppy not stiff as shown. Nothing special about this.

The reviews on this are correct. Runs a bit small. I only wore once on a day I just didn’t care.

This sweater quickly became a staple for me the past month. The perfect weight and easy to dress up or down depending on the occasion making it perfect for the holidays.

I usually wear a size small but the xs was a perfect fit!!

I rented this for work and got some compliments on it. It doesn't fit that loosely in the waist as it does on the model. I kept this for about two weeks because it was so comfortable and went with everything!

Did not like at first, but gave it another chance. Loved it! Wore for afternoon watching college football, and then family brunch on Sunday

Cozy sweater got many compliments

The collar was slightly less structured than I would prefer, but despite this I still loved it enough to purchase it! The detailing in the sleeve was beautiful and it was so comfortable and cozy. I wore this piece multiple times during the rental period. So many compliments!

The little ruffly collar makes a plain fisherman's wool sweater really cute. Vet flatterring. Bittom line: iI bought it.

Loved this sweater. Wore it bunch, only complaint is that it's a little itchy. Great cut though and fun collar detail got some complements

Loved the slightly shorter in front length. The ruffled mock neck adds personality without being too sweet.

Many winter sweaters with a turtleneck are super itchy, this was not! It was very comfortable and made this never-ending cold sweater weather more fun!

Fit as expected. The details made this a nice change from a standard sweater.

Wore to work and on the weekend. Loved it

A really cute sweater for everyday or work. Wore with jeans but also with slacks to the office.

I loved having this, and I wore it multiple times before returning. I would just throw it on with jeans and boots with no thought at all, and I received TONS of compliments. I wouldn't call it itchy, and I wouldn't call it soft. Will definitely rent again.

Nice neckline that isn't tight at all but frames the face.

Would rent again!

Loved this!

I wore this to work and just for every day errands. It was really comfy - not itchy at all. It was a tad big in the arms, but I preferred the roomiest. Will definitely be on the lookout to buy if it gets cheaper!

Cozy, adorable neckline and love the flecks of black. I loved it - would have kept it if it wasnt so pricey!