4.5
65 Reviews

Includes written reviews and customer fit feedback.

Most members say this item
Runs Large
Fit Summary
Runs Small (0)
True to Size (14)
Runs Large (16)
Member Photos (0)

Great for Maternity

I wore this to work and out to eat while. 8 months pregnant. It was comfortable and perfect.

Size Worn: M-L

Usual Size: 8


KaterinaTop Contributor

Size 8

5' 5"

140 lbs

Hourglass

34C

32 yrs

Browse Katerina's reviews (103)

Oversized & comfy

Definitely oversized but doesn't look too big to wear. Almost dress length on me, so paired perfectly with leggings

Size Worn: P-S

Usual Size: 0


MaryTop Contributor

Size 0

5' 3"

115 lbs

Petite

34B

25 yrs

Browse Mary's reviews (8)

Beautiful sweater that you can dress up or down.

Warm sweater that has a beautiful cowl collar.

Size Worn: M-L

Usual Size: 6


AnneTop Contributor

Size 6

5' 5"

130 lbs

Athletic

41 yrs

Browse Anne's reviews (5)

Super comfy.

Great winter choice. I found paired best with 3/4 inch black shirt underneath. Easy to dress up or down. Wore to work and for Thanksgiving dinner!

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: P-S

Usual Size: 4


PaigeTop Contributor

Size 4

5' 5"

135 lbs

Pear

32DD

33 yrs

Browse Paige's reviews (12)

Cute for work.

Loved this. Super cute, covered my lil preggo belly. Ran large, but I should have known to size down with a poncho. Comfy. Not itchy. Warm! Sorry the photo isn't the best!

Member Fit Notes

Runs Large

Size Worn: M-L

Usual Size: 6


AlexandraTop Contributor

Size 6

5' 3"

145 lbs

Pear

32C

25 yrs

Browse Alexandra's reviews (27)

Love this poncho

I rented this through my Unlimited subscription; kept for 2 weeks and wore it about 6 or 7 times. Nice and warm.

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: P-S

Usual Size: 4


ChristinaTop Contributor

Size 4

5' 5"

130 lbs

Athletic

36C

39 yrs

Browse Christina's reviews (82)

In LOVE!

So cozy, oversized, and perfect for late November. One of my favorite rentals to date!

Size Worn: P-S

Usual Size: 4


MaddyTop Contributor

Size 4

5' 3"

128 lbs

Hourglass

34B

31 yrs

Browse Maddy's reviews (32)

Loved it!

I kept this one longer than most of the pieces I've rented because it's so comfortable. I read the reviews and decided to go with the Petite/Small size since other reviewers said it ran large. This being my first poncho and not liking things to be too loose, I decided to go with the smaller size and I'm glad I did. I wore out on a date, to a board game party at a friend's house, to church, and a book club. It worked well for all those outings and kept me warm. Would rent again!

Member Fit Notes

Runs Large

Size Worn: P-S

Usual Size: 6


CorrinneTop Contributor

Size 6

6' 0"

145 lbs

Hourglass

34B

39 yrs

Browse Corrinne's reviews (14)

I love this sweater!

I really had fun wearing this sweater to work. It is large and oversized, but it's supposed to be that way. I felt very stylish in it. I wish I owned this sweater! Super comfortable too.

Size Worn: M-L

Usual Size: 6


AdrienTop Contributor

Size 6

5' 8"

146 lbs

Hourglass

34D

34 yrs

Browse Adrien's reviews (4)

Cute

This is cute and comfortable. Not scratchy around the neck at all, which is a big plus. It fits big, but doesn't look sloppy.

Member Fit Notes

Runs Large

Size Worn: P-S

Usual Size: 4


CTop Contributor

Size 4

5' 5"

140 lbs

Athletic

34B

40 yrs

Browse C's reviews (18)

Chic Winter Wear

The weather warmed up to the mid-50s this weekend so I switched out my winter coat for this warm sweater. I was able to comfortably wear it over my outfit and received a lot of compliments! The length of the sweater covered my butt, so I paired it with leather shorts and tights at night and black pants during the day.

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: P-S

Usual Size: 4


AliyeaTop Contributor

Size 4

5' 8"

135 lbs

Pear

24 yrs

Browse Aliyea's reviews (7)

Warm, comfortable, cute, perfect

Love this poncho! It's comfortable and cute without being overly baggy. It is also super warm. I wore with this with a tank top underneath but on colder days you could easily wear a long sleeve or turtle neck for the extra warmth.

Size Worn: P-S

Usual Size: 2


CarinaTop Contributor

Size 2

5' 3"

110 lbs

Athletic

34B

28 yrs

Browse Carina's reviews (371)

Pleasantly Surprised

I didn't love this item at all when it arrived and had planned on sending it back; however, after trying it on with various clothing, I found what looked good and what didn't quickly. It's quite warm and the color is versatile and stylish. Overall a useful rental.

Member Fit Notes

Runs Large

Size Worn: P-S

Usual Size: 0


TinaTop Contributor

Size 0

5' 0"

105 lbs

Petite

32C

31 yrs

Browse Tina's reviews (46)

Cute and warm poncho

It's a little baggy but it worked for me and was super warm and not itchy. Rented the M/L but I definitely wouldn't suggest it for a small/medium person. You definitely need to be a true medium or large. I wore with leggings and it was long enough to cover my butt which is always a plus because I'm tall.

Size Worn: M-L

Usual Size: 8


JenniferTop Contributor

Size 8

5' 10"

Athletic

28 yrs

Browse Jennifer's reviews (27)

Did not wear as I needed to trade in for another item. It was cozy and wish it was cooler here!!!

Cozy

Size Worn: P-S

Usual Size: 2


Anne marieTop Contributor

Size 2

5' 5"

118 lbs

Athletic

30DD

46 yrs

Browse Anne marie's reviews (4)

Super cute!

I wore this over the crochet sleeve thermals from Free People with leggings and boots. Cute casual look perfect for a chilly Chicago vacay. Loved this one

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: M-L

Usual Size: 8


ElenaTop Contributor

Size 8

5' 3"

135 lbs

Apple

34DD

42 yrs

Browse Elena's reviews (8)

Meh, nothing special

Ran larger than expected so was extra boxy / shapeless. Not terrible but not for me.

Member Fit Notes

Runs Large

Size Worn: M-L

Usual Size: 8


CarolynTop Contributor

Size 8

5' 4"

155 lbs

Hourglass

34DDD/E

32 yrs

Browse Carolyn's reviews (18)

Warm, awesome poncho

Pulls an outfit together. Great rental. Will rent again.

Size Worn: P-S

Usual Size: 4


LaurieTop Contributor

Size 4

5' 4"

Athletic

34D

48 yrs

Browse Laurie's reviews (120)

Super cozy sweater, great for a long plane ride.

Felt stylish and comfortable.

Size Worn: P-S

Usual Size: 4


JessalynTop Contributor

Size 4

5' 4"

125 lbs

Hourglass

34D

63 yrs

Browse Jessalyn's reviews (15)

Very easy to wear! Fun!

Worked great with jeans and flats one day Wore with jeans and boots another So cute and so many compliments!

Size Worn: M-L

Usual Size: 6


Maegan Top Contributor

Size 6

5' 8"

Hourglass

37 yrs

Browse Maegan 's reviews (12)

Cute & fun

Warm & cozy

Size Worn: P-S

Usual Size: 6


LisaTop Contributor

Size 6

5' 4"

Athletic

30D

41 yrs

Browse Lisa's reviews (5)

Perfect poncho

I have wore it multiple times and gotten stopped on the street each time. It's the perfect fall poncho. Great weight to the fabric. Not too hot and not too thin. Just beautiful and classic.

Size Worn: M-L

Usual Size: 12


Sarah Top Contributor

Size 12

5' 6"

Hourglass

37 yrs

Browse Sarah 's reviews (48)

One of my all time favorites

It was very difficult for me to give this one back. Warm and stylish.. this poncho was my go to this winter in Chicago. I liked the oversized look/feeling of it, so the M/L was perfect for me.


VictoriaTop Contributor

Size 8

5' 5"

150 lbs

Hourglass

34D

28 yrs

Browse Victoria's reviews (43)

Cozy, warm and stylish

I actually wore this to and from the hospital for surgery and then durig recovery when I was home. It's cozy, warm and stylish. I got so many compliments.

Size Worn: M-L

Usual Size: 8


TiffanyTop Contributor

Size 8

5' 10"

150 lbs

Hourglass

34D

46 yrs

Browse Tiffany's reviews (97)

Amazing!

This was such a beautiful poncho. Luxurious, soft, and very warm. I got so many compliments. Would definitely rent it again.

Member Fit Notes

Runs Large

Size Worn: P-S

Usual Size: 0


LauraTop Contributor

Size 0

5' 3"

115 lbs

Petite

34B

39 yrs

Browse Laura's reviews (148)

Love!!!

If i didnt live in Arizona and rarely encounter weather that requires such a big sweater i would buy! Loved it!

Size Worn: M-L

Usual Size: 8


RTR MemberTop Contributor

Size 8

45 yrs

Browse RTR Member's reviews (4)

Perfect solution for every occasion!

I wore this sweater, and rented it, more than once! It was the perfect option for going to dinner, or a casual coffee date. It is VERY comfortable and soft and very warm. I still think about it!

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: M-L

Usual Size: 8


SarahTop Contributor

Size 8

5' 6"

25 yrs

Browse Sarah's reviews (2)

Comfortable, cute, warm

Love the fit (long enough baggy enough). The arm holes will get tied down every now and then (you will see what I mean) but nothing that stopped me from wearing a ton!

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: M-L

Usual Size: 6


JaynaTop Contributor

Size 6

5' 10"

150 lbs

Athletic

32D

33 yrs

Browse Jayna's reviews (55)

So Cozy. Great weekend wear and casual Friday.

Such a cute & comfy sweater! Love the fringe.

Size Worn: P-S

Usual Size: 2


Caroline Top Contributor

Size 2

5' 6"

125 lbs

Athletic

32B

31 yrs

Browse Caroline 's reviews (36)

I rented this for thanksgiving. Perfect for our mild fall and family pictures.

Im pretty impressed i was able to wear this 8.5 months pregnant. It still looked amazing! i wore the PS but could have also worn the ML. It was flattering with plenty of room. Wished i owned this. Pregnant or not, i think it is a great poncho to have!!!

Size Worn: P-S

Usual Size: 8


MeredithTop Contributor

Size 8

5' 7"

150 lbs

Pear

34D

37 yrs

Browse Meredith's reviews (15)

warm and stylish!

I loved this! It goes well with long boots. Keeps me warm and stylish! Will rent again!

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: P-S

Usual Size: 2


MichaelaTop Contributor

Size 2

5' 6"

118 lbs

Straight & narrow

32D

26 yrs

Browse Michaela's reviews (22)

Super cute!

This was really cute! The S/M was not available, so I got the M/L. It didnt make a difference. Loved this one!

Size Worn: M-L

Usual Size: 6


MelissaTop Contributor

Size 6

5' 5"

130 lbs

Hourglass

32DD

30 yrs

Browse Melissa's reviews (9)

Love It!!!

Runs large, size down for any body type. Great for cold weather, cut with skinny jeans! Love this for my son's MN hockey games.

Member Fit Notes

Runs Large

Size Worn: M-L

Usual Size: 10


ErinTop Contributor

Size 10

5' 3"

155 lbs

Pear

36C

40 yrs

Browse Erin's reviews (23)

Super pretty grey, soft and easy to wear

Looked awesome with jeans and riding boots as well as black work pants and heels.

Size Worn: P-S

Usual Size: 6


KirstenTop Contributor

Size 6

39 yrs

Browse Kirsten's reviews (17)

Too perfect for an anniversary weekend in New England.

Gorgeous wool. Perfect gray. Excellent length. I'm excited to bring this to visit my folks and to walk on the beach in southern Maine.

Size Worn: M-L

Usual Size: 8


K. annTop Contributor

Size 8

5' 7"

135 lbs

Athletic

46 yrs

Browse K. ann's reviews (121)

Wore it just like it is shown....

cream color pants and it was perfect! Loved it for the inbetween season days here in Boston

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: M-L

Usual Size: 10


ChristineTop Contributor

Size 10

5' 5"

144 lbs

Full Bust

34DD

40 yrs

Browse Christine's reviews (42)

LOVED

It was perfect, warm and stylish. Perfect for traveling.

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: P-S

Usual Size: 6


MariaTop Contributor

Size 6

5' 2"

140 lbs

Hourglass

34D

37 yrs

Browse Maria's reviews (21)

So easy to wear! I threw it on top of everything.

Not very soft, but I always wore something underneath, so it wasn't an issue. Neck collar is very flattering and sophisticated looking. I was worried I would look homeless, but not the case at all. I literally wore it with everything it was so easy to throw on.

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: M-L

Usual Size: 12


RebeccaTop Contributor

Size 12

5' 5"

160 lbs

Pear

36F

28 yrs

Browse Rebecca's reviews (2)

So comfy!

Beautiful, warm and comfortable

Size Worn: M-L

Usual Size: 8


MaeveTop Contributor

Size 8

5' 6"

150 lbs

Pear

36A

39 yrs

Browse Maeve's reviews (11)

RTR Team Review

Comfy with an oversized fit. This sweater poncho was perfect for colder weather. It's pretty thick and is best for layering. I preferred to wear it with a turtleneck because it was a bit on the itchy side. Looks amazing with cropped skinnies and heeled boots.

Member Fit Notes

Runs Large

Size Worn: P-S

Usual Size: 2


AmandaTeam RTR

Size 2

5' 7"

122 lbs

Straight & narrow

34B

26 yrs

Browse Amanda's reviews (653)

1 - 40 of 65 reviews

Here to brighten up your inbox.

Emails are the fastest way to learn about new styles, sales, and more.

By clicking submit, you agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.