This is a great heavy cardigan. Very structured, fits great and is warm enough to wear as a coat.

Got my usual L. It is slightly oversize (supposed to be) and drapes SO well. I look super thin in it. It's also very warm - could be worn as a coat! If you're someone that is always hot, do not rent unless it's for a sweater coat. If you're always cold (like me), get it!!! I wore it several times.

Great fit! A nice layering piece and easy to style with other items.

Cozy and cute. Great basic!

Stylish and cozy, I wore this and felt warm all day!

goes with everything.

Loved this sweater! It is rather bulky so I waited for a day that it was ok to wear it instead of a coat, but nice and cozy. This may sound silly, but since it is a pretty substantial sweater I kept getting surprised that it doesn't have pockets!

Super cute and comfy but warm!

Great oversized sweater to wear with a pair of leggings or jeans! Perfect for a frigid friday in NYC.

This sweater coat is cozy, comfortable and stylish. I rented using my unlimited and have already worn this almost everyday. I have received so many compliments an definitely thinking I may need to buy it!

I kept this for over a week and wore numerous times. Really warm and pretty extra layer. Will rent again! I could have gotten the xs but s was fine.

Love this Joie cardigan - I wore it as an everyday Unlimited rental and loved the quality, color and texture of this knit. It pairs really well with many different kinds of fall layering pieces - and I tried mixing it's subtle pattern with other patterned shirts - and it looked great. Great length - just mid-thigh. Much prettier in person than the model's photo.

Material was a little (okay, a lot) scratchy, but the details are gorgeous - nice heavy fit for a cold Minneapolis day. Great layering piece. Would rent again.

It is a nice thick material, beautifully pattered, and warm. I am wearing it as I write this review.

I read the reviews that others mentioned this was itchy. I decided to get it anyone but they were definitely right. The sweater is for sure warm and runs big. I'm consistently a size 12 and could have managed in the small.

Warm but friends described it looking like a rug on me. The pattern shown in photos was super warm down because of the fuzz and low contrast of the yarn colors. Maybe I got a super worn in piece. If it was discounted more maybe I'd buy it but I don't think it's worth it.

Very warm sweater with a subtle pattern. Cozy, comfortable, on mild fall days can be work without a jacket. One major drawback is that it does not have pockets.

Full cut, very warm sweater.

cozy and comfy. sleeker than expected cut which makes the overall fit very complimentary

very comfy sweater, easy to wear, but runs a little small...I like my sweaters roomy!

I wouldn't say it runs big because it's supposed to be big, but it's great for layering. It's a little itchy, so wear a long sleeve turtleneck under it if you can. Great with that and leggings

it's itchy and short and I'm 5'3

Pretty average looking chunky sweater. I really wasn't impressed by the look or the fit. I wouldn't recommend.

This was unfortunately too oversized and not as flattering as I would have liked.

Cute sweater, I loved the length, but it the material was not soft at all - super scratchy. I have to wear with thick shirt underneath, I can't touch your skin.

Oversized/ fits well. Very warm. But really nothing special. The contrast between the light and dark gray is not as pronounced as it appears in the picture. Honestly, it "looks" like something you could buy at Target or Old Navy. Although the quality (very warm, wool-like) is better.

I wanted to love this cardigan but it just wasnt in the cards. I loved the pattern and texture, but that's where things ended. The meduim was much longer than I typically wear my caridgans and hit in a spot that was longer than a boyfriend style but not as long as a maxi cardigan. The medium was also a smidge too big and the sleeves were too long. On top of all of that, whoa was it WARM. I almost felt silly wearing it all day @ work bc i was so toasty. I had several co-workers (after complimenting me) ask why I was wearing my coat inside. Maybe this weave in a different cut & weight would be better for a cardigan.

This is a lovely design and flowy fit, but the sweater is not naturally soft (it is made of synthetic fibers that feel odd to my fingertips). If this doesn't bother you, it would be a great pick!

I didn't end up wearing this sweater. It is pretty, but very oversized and itchy. I tried to wear in with long sleeves underneath, but the neck was still very uncomfortable. Will not rent again.

Great look to this sweater, but super scratchy material.

Rather blah, there's not much more to say than that. And it's itchy!! Wore once and could not bring myself to put up with the itchiness again

Fits very large and dwarfed my small frame - but very comfy to wear over leggings around on the weekend.

The sweater was nice and looked attractive however the material was so itchy. I wore it to work and had to take it off midway through the morning because I was so uncomfortable. Would not rent again.

This is a very thick sweater. Its made of a scratchy material so you have to wear something longsleeeved under it. Its very bulky with no real shape. Very casual