Really cute sweater. I wore it with a tank top underneath because I didn't want my bra strap to show (and strapless bras are the worst) but also because it was a little itchy and the tank top helped with that. Great fit. Made for a fun and easy outfit for a casual work day. Got quite a few compliments!

Loved this sweater so much I decided to keep it! My boyfriend loved it just as much as I do. We even snapped a pic during our vacation to Mackinaw Island.

Super cute, definitely size down if you don't want it very oversized. I usually wear a medium and the small was perfect if just slightly snug around the soldiers. Didn't find the fabric itchy!

I wore this sweater on a daytrip into Boston, its flirty fun and sophisticated. Arm mobility and no fuss!

This oversized sweater is so comfortable and cute! I wore this to a golf tournament and was warm the whole time! The cowl neck is nice or can be worn with a scarf over it! It is meant to be oversized, so size down if you want a more fitted look!

While the fit made it hard to lift my arms too high, it was so comfy. I received compliments non stop. I ended up buying !

I rented this for my birthday celebration at a winery and it was perfect. I received SO many compliments and wish I could have kept it. I had been eyeing it for so long before I finally rented it and I fell in love, even more in person. The only thing I will say is the shoulders were a bit stiff in the beginning of the day and this is not a good rental, if you will be moving around a lot. However, in my case, I was just wine tasting and enjoying great company; so I couldn't have picked a better sweater. I would rent this over and over again in a heartbeat

This sweater is everything I've ever wanted in a sweater. It's so comfortable and can be worn during the day or on a date. It hangs off the shoulder which lends itself to a little sexiness during the day. I loved it so much I may buy one. The color is perfect with little black flecks and it feels good on your skin. The sleeves are a little batwingy which is perfect. Ten out of ten. Will rent this again unless I buy one for my own closet.

Cozy sweater for chilly spring evening.

I am obsessed with this sweater. It's the perfect blend of cozy and feminine with the chunky knit and off shoulder detailing. If you have broader shoulders this might be a tough fit - the top is REALLY fitted. Also, don't plan on doing too much in this sweater or layering it under things. The top restricts arm movement slightly and the top rides up if you put a coat under it.

I rented this for a fall outdoor family photo shoot. I gave birth 3 wks ago so really had to guess on the size. Pros: really loved how this looked in photos. This is what got it four stars as that was its primary purpose for me. It also had a really nice length to it. Cons: I was disappointed that this was much less comfortable than it looks. It's definitely a thick scratchy wool and wearing anything underneath ruined the off the shoulder look for me. There's a tight band at the top of sweater (hidden under the collar) that keeps the sweater off the shoulder -- not very comfortable & gives you a relatively limited range of motion. Unfortunately, the sweater still necessitated a lot of fixing into place/pulling back down over the course of the photo shoot, which was fine for its purpose but would have been annoying if at work or out for an actual event. Finally, the sizing was a little awkward- very generous in the arms and body but then the chest area was tight and almost didn't fit (currently 34DD), would have definitely been easier to wear with a smaller bust.

Loved this sweater! It was perfect for a casual night out with jeans and booties. I preferred to wear it off one shoulder vs evenly off both shoulders. It was long and loose and warm, but was a little itchy. I'd rent it again though!

Definitely felt awkward at first because it's not as slouchy as it looks, but once I figured out how to wear I liked it a lot! It doesn't allow for that much movement of your arms and you may have to readjust. Possibly size up if you want it even more slouchy and off the shoulder.

The sweater modeled in the photo looks much less frumpy than what I received. I'm only 5'3" so I usually expect things to run a little large, but I felt as though this sweater consumed me. It was also very itchy.

Would rent again!

This was a great sweater, so comfortable yes the off the should gave it a little something extra

Loved this sweater- Big, chunky sweater look, but still manages to have a slim silouhette and be flattering

I rented this for our July Alaskan cruise and I'm so glad that I did. I first wore it during the day with a pair of ripped jeans and then changed into a pair of cropped leather pants in the evening. The fit was great even with my long arms and long torso. I found myself wearing it a few different ways as some have mentioned. It felt very versatile and not super constricting. Very sexy and feminine. I received so many compliments and my husband actually wanted to buy it. I'll definitely rent again and give my husband that very opportunity!

I loved this sweater. So cozy and comfortable but still looked really cute and stylish. Almost sexy even for a baggy type sweater due to the off shoulder look. It does stretch out a little, but probably because i was wearing it like every day.

This was a super cute slouchy sweater but didn't look too baggy or unflattering. The neckline is really cute and you can adjust the way that you wear it to show more or less shoulder so it was appropriate for work but also was cute to wear out after work. I wore this with black jeans and black booties and it was so cute. Will admit I also wore it with leggings hanging around the house and it was super comfortable

This is a fantastic sweater! At first I wasn't sure how to wear the off the shoulder style, but once I played with it a little, it felt just right. I felt cozy but trendy at the same time. Lots of compliments! I wore this with leather leggings and booties for a night out, and again with skinny jeans and boots for brunch. I loved both looks!

It is an oversized sweater, so expect a little room. The dolman sleeve was a great touch. The off the shoulder look is good in theory, but I made the extra fabric into a cowl neck, and it was still very stylish with jeans and booties. Would definitely recommend.

I just rented this for a second time so that speaks for itself. I hope you don't plan on dancing or reaching for anything on the second shelf though. Raising your arms isn't really an option if you want your come hither shoulder to stay in sight.

The top can be folded over to allow for both or one shoulder, or even none if wanted. The material is thick and doesn't lose it's shape when pulled over. Great top, wish I could buy it!

I loved this sweater and ended up wearing it multiple times during my rental period. It is perfect for crisp fall weather. I liked it so much, I'm actually considering purchasing it!

Super comfy, great color. This sweater runs true to size, but definitely is meant to have that oversized look to it. With plenty of room in the bust, waist, and arms it's a great layering piece. It can be worn as a cold shoulder look or with the collar draped over the neckline. At 5'7" it hit just at my fingertips when my arms were straight. Perfect for a cool fall day.

LOVE LOVE LOVE this! I rented this using my unlimited subscription and it still had the tags on it! I actually just saw this sweater in the Joie store the other day. It is gorgeous and makes me feel gorgeous! It's long and slightly oversized. Looks great with skinny jeans and some booties! Perfect for a fall day.

This is a really comfortable sweater, but didn't fit on me like the photo shows: not as long as it looks and not as comfortable off the shoulder. It was shorter at the waist and the neck was more comfortable to wear as a cowl-neck (slouchy neck), not off-the-shoulder.

Loved this sweater! I am usually a medium and have a full chest so the sweater was a little tight but still looked good. Would rent again as a medium

Like any off the shoulder sweater, I had to readjust it often as it would gather in awkward places. Could feel a little straight-jackety at times.

this was really cute on, oversized and comfy but stylish with off the shoulder.

This sweater is super cute, comfy but also something that you can easily dress up with the right jewelry or leggings. I like the "peek" of shoulder on the top. This runs very large. I usually wear a 2 and the small was much too big.

Super cute sweater. But it was impossible to wear with a jacket due to the arms - so, sadly, didn't get to wear it out.

Little big, tight on the shoulders. Left a red mark on both shoulders because it's tight there to keep it from staying down. But, worth it. I am considering buying this!

Rented to wear for work. Sweater was cute and comfortable but when you move your arms or are driving it will move around a bit on the shoulders if you have it rolled down. Not a big deal and I thought that was to be expected. Goes with any color jeans perfect!

The sweater itself is true to size but the shoulders are small. I had trouble wearing it as an off-the-shoulder piece as the sides would not stay down. I liked it nonetheless and it was great for a rainy, cold spring day.

Cozy and comfortable!

I wore this for a night out to dinner and drinks with my girlfriends. I love the off the shoulder look and this did not disappoint. It was a little difficult to keep the sleeves down at all times, but you can also adjust and wear as more of a cowl neck sweater, which still looks great. I received compliments from all of my friends!

This was an adorable sweater. I originally wanted to wear it with nothing underneath, but it was way too itchy and I had to wear a camisole. Changed the look a bit, but still glad I rented it.

It's best to go a size smaller on this one, off the shoulder silhouette is very difficult to achieve but regardless it's a cute sweater