This sweater is just about perfect. I Love the color (navy, not black), the knit pattern and the sleeves. I was worried the XS might be a little small for me but it was perfect (5’2”, 130 lbs). It’s cozy but not too hot, the fabric is soft, breathes well and is not at all scratchy. I have a feeling I’ll be hanging on to this for a while.

Great fit, comfortable, love the style. Would buy this!

I was able to wear this with slacks and heels to work, casual pants for the weekend, and I even wore it in family pictures. I love this sweater!

I am athletic and broad shouldered so I was concerned that the exaggerated sleeves would look bulky. However, they did they opposite and gave my straight shape a very feminine silhouette. Non-itcy tight weave that elevates the basic sweater. Will rent again!

Rent it. Very comfortable wardrobe basic, yet the sleeves elevate the look to something really stylish! I've worn this multiple times and always gotten compliments. Only "flaw" I'd note is that it really attracts hair - keep a lint roller handy.

Super cute Sweater. Fits perfectly. Wore to work and received a lot of compliments. Would get again.

So I thought the sweater was black but when I got it into the light I realize it's actually navy. I put it on with a pair of slacks that have black in it and it was then that I realized the sweater is not actually black. This is a darling sweater very flattering I would wear it to work and I would wear it out at night. Dress up or down. The puff sleeves are really cute.

Sweet navy blue sweater with added feminine interest with the shape and the sleeves. Warm and cozy with a little style. Wish it was just a touch longer in the torso.

Fits a little short but a pretty basic.

This sweater is a dark navy (as other reviews have mentioned). I loved this sweater - wore it many times, it is comfortable but stylish and elevates a casual look.

It was fancy enough to dress up and be casual.

Adorable sweater. Mid weight and fitted. It is short, so you’ll want either high waisted jeans or a tank underneath if you don’t want your belly to peek out when you raise your arms. Shoulders are a nice detail and don’t make you look broad.

The knit pattern is super flattering. Have rented twice. Will rent again.

I wasn't sure how another black sweater would look. However, the details are really beautiful and the fit very flattering. The waist is fitted with not too puffy shoulders to elbows and then fitted from the elbows to the wrist. I'd definitely consider buying this one - it's a really beautiful black sweater which you can dress up or down depending on the occasion.

great handfeel, very comfortable and great fit.

Glad I sized down, I'm typically a size s, easily wore the xs. This is a very dark navy sweater though, not black! I didn't realize it until I wore it out in the sunshine. Short but not cropped. Easy style for anyone to wear.

Beautiful fit, lovely arms. Good quality fabric.

Was soft / not itchy and still warm. Good for cold weather though not freezing. Great style yet still classic. Didn't want to return this one!

I got so many compliments on this beautiful sweater! The stitch & sleeve detail are so pretty & on trend. It was extremely comfortable & fit TTS.

Very flattering.

Fall sweater success!

great fit and look

Cropped a bit but looked good with higher waist jeans

This is a great piece with high waisted pants. It's cute but not stand out - but fits well and is classy.

PROS: The XL was the perfect fit for my size 12/14 self. The material is quality. I like solids over prints and am glad to see some options for solids. The little v design in front adds a bit of texture to what is generally a bit basic. I’m kind of basic. CONS: This certainly is in line with the bishop sleeve trend, but I did find that it was voluminous enough to make me look a bit wide. Like in another review I gave, this take might be due to my larger size and me being self-conscious about wanting to look smaller.

5'7" 130 or less pounds... worked since was at home that day working :)

cute

cropped and tight . size up

Goes with everything

Wore this sweater for a casual dinner out with family. It's an elevated style with puff shoulders and cuffed sleeves. I had to pair with high-waisted jeans though because it's definitely on the shorter side and runs slightly small. Would have purchased, but the sweater is also slightly itchy. Definitely wouldn't be able to wear for a day at work.

I loved everything about this sweater except how short waisted it is.

It’s a beautiful sweater and I love the small poof of the shoulders, but unfortunately the other reviewers were correct, it was horribly itchy when I put it on. A shame because it was a really pretty elevated black sweater that I wanted to wear. Sadly I did not.

Fits well. Warm

This was cute but a little short for my long torso and very itchy. Given the warm spell I didn't wear.