This was cute and details were fun, but it was boxy and short. I sized up. Front detail is definitely dark blue, not black

The detail on the front of this sweater is really beautiful and unique. Note that the scalloped detail is dark navy and not black (I still wore it with black). I found the length of this sweater just slightly shorter than I expected but still very wearable.

Loved this sweater. It was not itchy at all and went well with a RTR corduroy skirt. Would highly recommend, even possibly buy.

Loved this fresh and funky sweater. The detail was so pretty. The length was more a midriff sweater, so it was a little short on my torso. But it was a fun wear for the day

I wore this down to the shore in February and it was really warm and cozy and super cute

I really liked this sweater! It's soft and only a bit scratchy around the neck. If you have a long torso/large boobs I'd size up, it seems very short. I wore with high waisted jeans and that worked out perfectly. The detailing is really cute and I got so many compliments! I would definitely wear again!

I liked this sweater. It's not itchy at all and not too heavy, with delicate details that make it stand out. The fit was a little unflattering - it's very short and wide. I probably would have bought it if it had a few extra inches.

The details are so cute, and I'd overlooked them in the photos. It may be a bit delicate for everyday wear, but I love it. May buy this one...

Loved this sweater, beautiful details! Not itchy at all and appreciated the looser turtleneck. I could have gotten away just wearing a nude bra underneath but wore a camisole bc when I lifted my arms up it exposed my belly and back.

Super cute decoration down the front. The material is soft and comfortable and kept me warm in really cold weather. It's a little short so I wore a tank top underneath. Would definitely wear again!

True to size. Very cozy and warm. Looks high end/regal.

Cute sweater with a feminine touch that is different than any other sweater I have ever worn. Really cozy, not itchy at all. Great for work or everyday.

Slightly boxy fit. FYI, ruffles are navy in the light (not black). Cotton material so not too hot which is good.

Fits just right! Really cute and girly!

A perfect choice for Valentines as the black pieces "kind of" look like hearts - but they really aren't.

Super cute sweater. You can dress up with a skirt of with black jeans.

Oversized like most sweaters but would size down because I think JCrew generally runs large. Loved the sweater I dressed it down with distressed black denim. Super cute and warm.

n/a

This is a cute sweater that it’s easy to pair with lots of options. I wore it with jeans for more casual look and then with black leather pants for a night look.

Boring - shapeless- I think this had been washed and dried at somebody's home. It was stretched out and really shapeless. I only wore it once. Definitely not worth the money to rent.

Great every day addition. Won't need to rent again - this one is a keeper.

Can wear with anything. Perfect for a fall day.

Because I have a larger chest it hung a little boxy, but I liked the way that looked with skinny jeans. The embellishments are navy, not black as I thought, but I liked that as well!

Easy to wear. Not too small. Not too big. Not too heavy.

I loved how this was a pretty casual sweater with cute details down the front! I felt like I could both dress it up and down depending on the occasion.

Comfortable, has nice openwork. Good for work with a skirt.

This sweater fit loose, but it wasn't oversized by any means. I wore it tucked into my pants and it wasn't too bulky. I loved the subtle details in the arms as well as the front.

Really loved this piece. I felt like it was a tad wide, but not wide enough to mark it as running big.

Really cute with a mini skirt tights and booties. The tassels are navy but I wore it with black and it looked fine!

This fit perfectly (I got a large so it would be a bit oversized). It was so comfortable and I got so many compliments!

This sweater is soft, light and pretty! I loved wearing it.

It was okayyy. Nothing super fancy or special. It hit a little short for me just at the waist and I like my sweaters a little longer. Cute for vaca but won't rent again.

The top has ruffles which are navy not black, figured it when I was in the sun wearing it with black trousers and shoes. The fit is slightly boxy as commented before however, the style was different. It was simple but elegant.

Casual, comfy, nice with jeans and long black boots.

Runs a little large I wear 14/16 and this felt loose. I would go down a size.

The cut is higher, right around the waist and the fit is a little boxy. It felt like a fit from the 60's. It grew on me throughout the day, but I don't think I'd rent it again.

The fit is loose. Sweater a little short. I wore it with high waisted jeans

Cute sweater, a little short, worked great over a black dress with boots.

Like sweater- but collar is very wide/ too big not a true turtle neck