Wore it during the daytime on my birthday in NYC. I layered it with a great peacoat, some tights, low boots. I wasn’t sure with my dimensions how it would fit but it was comfortable and I felt great in it.

This was a really nice quality sweater dress, perfect for a baby shower! I am 5’2 and thought personally the length was a little awkward for me, but I went ahead and wore the dress with a heeled boot and tights and felt a bit better. Overall, not a huge difference for me between the Small and Medium.

A little itchy, warm but not hot for in doors

I wore this at 36 weeks pregnant for my baby shower. I was a little larger than expected but that was only noticeable in the sleeve length. The overall length was sexy enough to pair with my knee high boots but provided plenty of coverage for my bigger behind, especially when sitting down. The material was made for winter and kept me warm and comfortable for the snowy weather.

I rented this for my brother's outdoor wedding rehearsal and rehearsal dinner. The rehearsal was a bit more casual than ones I've been to before, so I opted for this sweater dress, that was casual yet still allowed me to feel cute! I was worried it would be too baggy and shapeless, but it had just the right amount of room to be comfortable yet still flattering. The only reason I'm giving it 4 stars instead of 5, is because the turtleneck was a bit itchy, so I was messing with it all night.

Obsessed with this sweater dress. It's a beautiful salmon pink color and runs true to size. I loved how it wasn't too baggy or too fitted. I wore it with taupe/nude OTK boots and felt chic and comfy all day!

Great loose fit for a long day but excellent transition piece for an evening event. Neck is a little worn and has to be folded under.

This was great for a rainy spring day at work.

I loved how soft and comfortable this sweater dress was! I did not get any of the itchiness mentioned in other reviews. I wore it for a casual girls night out and then again for work one day. I did belt it to give it a little more shape since it does run a little big. And paired it with thigh high boots for going out. Looked super cute and the color was a far stretch from my usual grey scale outfits!

I rented this for work for Valentine’s Day. It was the perfect color, however I didn’t love the fabric. While it was warm, it felt like it was too staticky and would stick rather than being free flowing. I would still recommend it.

Love the color and it was really comfortable & cozy. The only con is that it doesn't have much shape so it's not overly flattering. It looks really nice with a jacket on over it.

A little big which was good for every day wear. Comfortable and a little more dusty pink than the photos.

So nice and not too itchy overall EXCEPT THE NECK. I can't stop messing w it but I don't really have another option til the day is over! The fit is fairly loose - in medium on me it wasn't body con or anything. At 5'3 it's a professional length for work - around my knees so perfect over black tights. If I had thigh high boots I'd love to wear with this. But OMG THE NECK - it's way tight compared to loose fit of the body of dress and I guess bc it's tight the itchiness is driving me nuts. It's weird bc I don't feel itchy in the arms and I only have a bra and tights under this, but the neck is killing me.

Pretty good quality, cozy and warm winter sweater dress I wore with tan riding boots. It's intended to be a bit of a looser fit which isn't as flattering on a curvy girl like me. I would have loved it to be a bit smaller and longer. It was several inches above the knee which didn't look good on me in this style. Lovely color and very comfy.

I rented this for a crazy cold day in nyc and it did the trick. It's very comfortable and warm. I felt like I was wearing a blanket! I paired it with over the knee boots. There is no shape to this sweater dress. I think you could belt it but I didn't have any belts that worked well.

I think the color of this flattered my skin tone, which is hard to do with light pink and fair skin. I also liked that while it was form-fitting, it didn’t over emphasize areas on my body that weren’t super smooth. It is a little sheer, you will want skin color underwear for sure.

Compliments galore! Cute cut, pretty color, perfect for early fall!

Very simple and soft blush dress. I usually wear a L or XL or smaller items but I wanted it to be oversized. It was perfect because I wore it to a baby shower and the XXL gave more oversized feel and more length.

I thought I was an XS but I guess not anymore in J Crew. This was too big and too unflattering to even try to belt or wear anyway.

You really should rent this if your only smaller chested

Great fit - sweater dress without being too baggy. I wore to work with tights and short boots and after work to a show. So cute I bought it. Color is unique

Runs large in a good way. Super cute and very comfortable

Comfy and good for a rainy day or casual work day with leggings. A little itchy but I could just be sensitive to the feel of the wool.

Dress is really nice, but runs big.

This was cute, nothing super special, but it was comfy and warm. not scratchy which is always a win

Loved the color. Fit was a little large, but being 22 weeks pregnant, that worked out fine for me. Would rent again next winter.

This was perfect for my very hungover work day. I paired it with leggings and high boots and barely brushed hair. I wouldn't say that it's flattering or unflattering, it's just a basic oversized sweater. The color is good, and the length is a little too short for me to call it a "dress" but with leggings it was fun!

It's a great dress, my hips are just a little too wide. So it's great for straight, athletic figures but not so great for fuller figures

The dress was slightly shorter on me, than on the model shown and would ride up when walking. It was, however, super comfortable and a really beautiful blush pink color.

It's a little shapeless but the fit overall was great and it was so cozy and soft

Some reviews say the fabric was quite itchy, but I didn't find that. I wore this dress with jeans and high leather boots because the XS was just too short for me to wear to work. Other than that, the blush color is adorable and I received a lot of compliments at work.

Looks long on the model but my medium was rather short especially in be back. It has a staggered length. If it's short for someone like me that's only 5'4" I can't imagine for others what it'd be like.

There is nothing particularly wrong with this dress, I just am not a fan. I ordered a small because other reviews said it ran big, but since I'm tall the dress ended up being a little too short, especially with the rises on the side. The color made me look ill since I have fair skin, and the fabric was very scratchy but I have pretty sensitive skin.

Very cute sweater dress! Fits true to size and classic in that JCrew way! I tried it on and liked it. It's peachy pink but it wasn't cold enough to wear it yet.

Not for work but would be great for a trip to the mountains

Didn't wear this as it looked like I was drowning in it. Not to mention, it's incredibly itchy and I only had it on for 5 minutes.