The fit for this was amazing. I just love it. Buying one for my daughter too because she wants one too.

This sweater fit perfectly on me, the sleeves were just the right length and everything. I was a little concerned they would be long, but luckily no problems! I would definitely rent this again, it was really cute!!

No itch , nice weight sweater.

It's a cheerful color with subtle speckles of other spring color threads woven throughout. It is a bit oversized in the arms, with a dolman style sleeve. Great for a comfy, causal, chilly spring day.

Not flattering at all. Its far to bulky and doesn't fit quite right. The sleeve arm pits are sagging down to you waist line. I hated it and never wore it.

I love this sweater! Great quality and fit.

Great pink color. Received compliments. Armpit part of the sweater is kind of weird...it's a bit low. I just kept my arms down for the most part and it didn't really bother me.

Rented this for work and loved it! Very cozy and I didn't get too warm in it, even with temperatures in the mid 50s here. I knocked a star off because the XL I wore was big all over, but especially in the sleeves. Even though I normally wear an XL, I think a large would've fit better. Still a great rental all the same! Maybe I'll try it in a size large next time

I ordered a large but needed a medium. a bit too big for me. Gorgeous pink

Far too large. I sized down one size and would recommend sizing down two.

Very comfortable sweater in a beautiful pink with some colorful knit threads. Great for everyday and office. Love the neckline, its very flattering! It does cuff a bit at the end of the sweater. I don't always want to rent J.Crew on RTR amongst other designers, but this was a great find and great sweater!

Soft yarn. I have long arms, and the sleeves were a little short. It looked a bit hanger worn. The sleeves were generously cut in the underarm area. Not quite roomy enough for a dolman sleeve, but a bit big for regular sleeves. Glad I got to use my birthday Pro perk on this.

Very warm. The sleeves are extra large at the armpit which isn't the most flattering. I wouldn't wear it again, although the color was very flattering.

Pros: Soft material Cons: Neck was just too wide, it looks like it was stretched versus designed that way. Therefore, did not wear.

I chose this sweater for its bright Pepto Bismol color, and it did not disappoint on that score. A nice early March pop for my wardrobe. But it was too bulky for me, and the sleeves were too long. So not very flattering, I'm afraid.

Maybe it would look better in an oversized fit?

I've worn this a few times and will send it back as soon as my next item comes. The color is more of a pepto bismol pink than I had anticipated but with heathered bits of red, blue and yellow. The knit is pretty soft but oddly itchy given the fiber composition. I would not rent again but it was all right for a couple of wears.