This fit true to size for J. Crew - I ordered my usual 0. That said, I just didn't find this especially flattering on my petite frame. I wore this to work from home, and it was comfortable, but I just wasn't impressed by it and wouldn't have worn it out. The length overwhelmed me, since I'm short, but the knit itself is very pretty.

I sized down because I wanted a more fitted look. Sweater was warm and basic in style. I wish it was softer. Arms were a little short and tight.

Rented it for a trip to NYC and it was perfect. I ended up keeping it and rewearing it a couple more times once I got home. Cozy, not itchy and had a nice fit. It's not tight fitting, but hugged in the right places and had a little give in the waist. Highly recommend! #winter #sweater #knits

This is a comfy and not itchy sweater. It is on the longer side which I loved and is perfect to wear with leggings. It's very warm. I plan to rent it again.

I wore it probably 4-5 times throughout the month!! Almost bought it! Will definitely rent again! I wore with jeans for casual & wore with black leather pants & statement necklace to dress it up. Very great sweater! Received a ton of compliments!

I went on vacay to Seattle and needed something warm but cute! This was such an awesome sweater and I felt so good in it! Super warm paired with this Kate Spade jacket!

Super cozy, not itchy, classic

It was a really flattering fit for being 8 months pregnant. Very comfortable!

I liked the sweater. It was warm and comfortable but I wouldn't say it wowed me on any level.

Paired it with Sanctuary plaid leggings. A little bit itchy

I rented this in white and pink and while I'm not a big pink wearer, I found I like the pink better the White was just kind of blah. Still a very comfy and cozy sweater

This sweater is very classy and very warm. It was perfect for a winter day. It's a little baggy so it's not the most flattering fit

Roomy enough but not too big that it looks messy. Long enough to wear with leggings!

I wore this on the weekend with leggings and to work with nicer slim pants. It's cute and comfy and I love the longer length. It was a bit itchy when I wore only a tank underneath, so the other times I wore it with a thin long sleeve "tissue tee" underneath, and that was perfect.

Comfy and cute

Comfy for everyday, nothing special that I would rent again but got the job done.

Very stiff fabric, not breathable - perhaps would have looked better if I sized up

It felt scratchy at first but didn't bother me for the rest of the night.

Fits large, slightly itchy so would be better to wear a long sleeve underneath

I think this sweater is more meant for wintertime than spring time. I found it to be too heavy, and a bit itchy. It was pretty though and I could wear it over leggings easily.

This is a great piece to rent for a casual day at work or for out and about. The sweater was a little itchy when I first put it on but I got used to it by the time I got to work. I have rented this sweater in pink and didn't have the issue so that's the reasoning for four stars. This is a heavy sweater but not doesn't feel heavy when wearing. I would rent again!

Fit was fine, a smidge tighter than expected. I suspect it was washed in a way that shrunk it a little. I needed to take a sweater shaver to it to help with pilling. Because it’s itchy, I rarely wear it unless it’s cold enough to need long sleeves under it.

over all could be great

Nothing special, but it is warm

I didn't end up wearing this. It was itchy and not very stretchy so it was tough to get on and off.

I tried this expecting it to be a little boxy but it felt pretty snug. I probably should have gotten the large. I also would've liked it to be a little bit longer. In the end I didn't end up wearing this out anywhere.

Itchy , I simply couldn't wear it

I typically love this brand, but I don't recommend this too for pear shaped. It hits at all the wrong places!

Fit well with leggings for a cold day.

Very flattering on an hourglass figure and such great quality

This sweater is the perfect length and weight. It was long enough I could wear it with leggings but it also looked great with jeans. I was concerned about it being too warm when I rented it, but it worked out just fine. Rent it!!

Sweater is big and comfy. A little itchy due to the wool but was a great piece to throw over some black leggings and bar with OTK boots

Comfortable! I'm a medium petite but ordered a small and this was the perfect amount of oversized. The sleeves were slightly long on me but looked great as is over my palm just a bit or even folded when I preferred out of the way.

This sweater had an oversized fit which was exactly what I was looking for. The neck wasn't constricting and it was easy to wear over leggings or skinny jeans for a semi-pulled together look when I didn't feel like making an effort!

I wore this a lot. ITCHY, but I adjusted. At 5'6" and 20 weeks pregnant I still was fine in an XS, so I think it runs big. The arms were exactly right but lots of room in the body.

Cute everyday sweater not super soft but doesn't make me look Pregnant. Would rent again

I love this sweater! Fitted my arms nice and snug but not too tight, and the body fit a little bit loosely. Looks cute with leggings or tight jeans. Very warm!

This was great for the cold snaps. It went from paired with leggings cuddled up on the couch to paired with boots and jeans for a trip to the local bar. It's the perfect warm basic.

I'm short so this is more of a tunic for me. Wore it over leggings, jeans, etc. It is pretty heavy, so more for when it's actually cold out then when it's just your office air conditioner!