Not itchy. Great length. You can tuck in without it being overly bulky. Love it. Bought it.

I loved this turtleneck! I'm 5'0/109 lbs, the xxs fit like a glove. I wore it a few times and received so many compliments. Such a cute pink! Some of the reviews mention that it's itchy - yes (ish) around the neck, but it really only started to bother me after wearing it 1/2 a day. Wouldn't stop me from recommending because it's just that cute. If your skin is extra sensitive, maybe pass. If not, do it!

I spent all day wrapped in warmth and comfort! Just as cozy as it looks, without making you look bulky. In other words, it's a dream sweater!

I loved this sweater. It is, like the title, super soft. It fits perfectly everywhere. The only issue I had was the tag along the neck. It was super itchy and, if I owned it, I would immediately cut it off. I'm sadly returning the sweater after only one wear because I couldn't stand the tag.

One of my favorite rentals! It's soft, comfy, warm, and cute.

Soft and cozy. Bright/cherry. Cotton candy pink. Not too bulky/tight. Must like turtlenecks. High neck. Didn't bother me but might bother some.

Rented for ski trip. Warm but not too warm. A little shorter thane I like but not cropped. Small was like a size 4.

Good basic pretty sweater. Ended up buying it.

A little scratchy around the neck, but otherwise cute!

TTS

Great sweater for everyday. A little itchy around the neck, but enough to deter.

A little but too thick, but super warm.

I received a ton of compliments on this sweater. The fit is great and the colors are beautiful. It is a true turtleneck, so if you hate things around your neck this may bother you.

Loved this sweater, but had to take it off after awhile because it is really warm!

So many compliments and so warm. I love this. Fits true to size with room for layering.

It was a little thicker than what was needed, but great wear for colder winter day. Overall fit well and a nice length, neck was a little fuller than expected.

This is a great sweater! Super soft & comfortable, perfect for Fall. I got so many compliments on it every time I wore it.

The fit was roomy and comfy not tight fitted at all!

A gentleman at a restaurant commented to me (and my husband) "that is a gorgeous sweater!" so I think that speaks for itself :) I liked it so much I purchased it from RTR.

Very warm, non itchy sweater. I've been renting sweaters every week and this is one of my favorites. It held shape after several wears. I would have bought.

Warm and cozy

Thick but not itchy

Soft and not itchy.

nice fit

Great fit and soft

Super soft and flattering sweater. I wore it skiing, casually with jeans and to a work event with nice white pants. Received compliments constantly. Would rent again.

Perfect everyday sweater for cold weather. Nice and warm

Fits well, cute colors, but nothing special.

Nothing super unique but fun colors

This is warm but not super heavy. Turtle neck part is very structured. It's true to size.

Soft enough that I didn't need an undershirt. Bottom hem hit right at the hip which made it flattering to wear untucked/tucked/French tucked. True to size for J Crew but if you aren't familiar with the brand I would size down.

I thought it would be cute; it was more matronly, oddly. I returned it quickly, as it may be someone else's fave.

I wanted to wear this but wool makes me itchy. Now I’m checking the label for wool before I rent. I love the look though!!

This made my chest very itchy

Misleading name of the sweater -- this was itchy! It also just didn't look great overall. The neck was too tall, and the fit was a little too broad-shouldered in the M. Didn't wear.