Very cute and very warm! I am between xs and small, I got the small but I think the xs would have been perfect.

This sweater is fun and cozy. I love the script writing on it too.

This is a cute sweater and I got good feedback on it. It is a little thick, but overall I liked it.

Yes, I loved this sweater. It was warm, thick and cute, BUT the sweater loses shape. I did wear the sweater two or three times, so it may have been that. Overall, great rent. I wouldn't buy.

This is an ordinary sweater from Jcrew, nothing really unique about it. Fit is as expected, was nice and warm.

It's a cute enough sweater. But I found myself not wanting to grab it because it really wasn't that comfy. It's a little scratchy

I went down a size. Cute sweater! Very warm!

Nice thick sweater, interesting design, versatile and comfy!

The "yes" "no" pattern is woven, not printed, which can read as fuzzy up close. But I got comments on this all day--it's got so much personality. Stretchy fit, thick material.

This J. Crew sweater is so, so, so, cute. It is good quality, heavy and warm, but still quite soft for a wool sweater. If I lived in a cold climate, I'd be hard pressed not to wear it everyday! It would be perfect for lounging by the fire with a good book on a snowy day. Enjoy!

Love this sweater...wore for vacation and it was just the amount of warmth I needed. It is 60% merino wool and adorable. I just may need to buy this because I am having a hard time thinking about sending it back!

The title says it all. I literally got stopped in the street, grocery, bank and got tons of compliments from guys and gals. I thought it was cute but didn't expect it to stop traffic. Lol. I really did love it just wish it wasn't wool. Hard to wear wool in the south. If you're looking for real warmth and a conversation piece, this is it!

My husband was slightly obsessed with the fun look of this sweater. It paired perfectly with business pants for a business casual look. Loved it!

It is a pretty thick sweater so it's great for colder weather. Just plan accordingly if you want to wear a fitted jacket over it. It is definitely on the thicker side.

I am usually a medium but ended up renting a small in this sweater as i wanted it to be a snug fit. The sweater was really warm and comfortable. Received a lot of compliments once people found out what it said. Great for everyday wear.

Love everything about this sweater. Such a great pattern+the back is a nice surprise. Everyone loved it. Wore a check shirt w/it to mix patterns. It also looked great with this chair!

The script on this is adorable and I loved the heavy weight of this. Would be fun to play up with a leather skirt and some hose.

Such a fun sweater! My husband thought the yes and no design was stupid but I thought it was so cute and fun. Very thick and warm. Fit as expected.

Fit as expected based on prior reviews/pictures. Not oversized like model picture. More fitted and hits at waist. Very warm. Wore outside all morning mid-40s weather without a jacket. I enjoyed wearing this sweater.

FORGIVE THE ROOM (we just moved in! :D)The sweater was definitely eye catching and i loved the "yes, no" print...fit my mood perfectly for a Friday :) It's a little boxy and a tiny bit short - I'm pretty tall so i wore something underneath. I am a lover of bigger cozy sweaters and this wasn't really that. Either way it was cute.

Cute sweater, worked out on a weekend running errands and casual dinner with a friend. Super thick and warm.

I rented this for everyday wear and ended up wearing it 3 times in the month of February. This sweater is a very thick warm knit and great for cold weather wear. People were very entertained by the Yes/No print and I received multiple compliments when wearing. This was a fun sweater to cheer up the winter cold.

Rented this for everyday and wore to dinner once. The pattern is cute but it's a thick wool and a little itchy, I probably should have worn a M, instead of the small. I was just kinda "meh" about it.... wouldn't rent again, but fun for the night.

very very thick sweater and very very warm. I wore this while in Michigan with 16 degree weather and it was perfect underneath a ski coat, etc. When I wore earlier in the day in the airplane did get a tad hot. Also, the neckline is a bit itchy as I only had on a tank top underneath. Due to itchiness you must have something on underneath. It was a fun sweater that I enjoyed wearing one time.

Cute sweater that can be dressed up or down.

Sorry for the restroom selfie! Fit a little small but loved the graphic writing

Really warm. A bit boxy on the boobs, but I imagine that's because it's so thick. Cute casual Friday look.

This sweater is super warm and great for the polar vortex. Nicely made and thick without too much bulk. Just an okay look, though. I will not rent again just because it feels kinda "blah".

I love the style, but the ''yes'' and ''no'' aren't as clear as the picture. It kind of just looks like a design in person, not words. Also, I usually wear a medium but the 4-6 size for j. Crew is a small, and it is actually a little snug. I like the baggy sweater look, but this was definitely more fitted. If I had sized up it might have been better. Cute, but not my favorite.

Fit well, very warm.

TTS but if you're looking for a loose fit, this won't be for you. Perfectly warm, if a tiny bit itchy on the inside.

Beautiful detailing; sweater was thicker then expected so very warm.

I should have received the XL. RTR said the L was the right fit but I should not have accepted the recommendation.

Wore this on Election Day for good vibes! It's warm and fun.

This was a fun sweater to wear the day before our wedding. It's made of a thick, warm material and best for cold winter days. The wool can be a bit itchy and recommend wearing a cami or shirt underneath.

Cute sweater. Wear it skiing or out in the cold. It's too warm to wear inside all day!

I ordered a size small because that's the size I normally wear with Jcrew, and this felt pretty tight. It was also a bit scratch as others have mentioned. Was wanting just a new sweater to wear around the house but didn't find this cozy or comfy, just stiff and tight. Wouldn't recommend.

Print is awesome, but to be honest the base color is a little dingy in person. It may be something about the navy words on the cream, but it's not quite as crisp looking as I'd expected. That said, it's very comfy, not super itchy for a wool sweater, and very fun. An XL fit true to size in my opinion.

I wore this once to work and received a ton of compliments, but everyone agreed they didn't "get it". It's definitely a good conversation starter! The sweater is thick and fit like I was expecting it to.