Very comfortable and warm. Loved the color. The muted blue makes it easy to mix and match with other pieces.

I loved how good this coat fit and looked. I wore it on a couple of cold and snowy days and it kept me very warm. It fit me better than my other J.Crew coat of the same size. I hated when it was time to return it. Would have loved the option to purchase it.

It was so nice to have a coat that had a nice fit and did not feel like a robe. I didn't actually get to wear it because it was warmer than I expected at my destination. I wish it had been colder so I could've worn it!

LOVED this coat and wish I bought it! Rented it a second time and part of the collar was messed up but still can't get over how lovely the color is and the weight is perfect for wintertime in SF or fall most places.

Fit great, wore unbuttoned most of the time button not strong, tons of complements on this coat wore everyday, dates, and night out

I’ve been wearing this on 32 degree days and it’s warm! Sleeves are cozy and easy to get on despite layers. Only thing- button doesn’t stay closed. But if you’re just walking to your car you can hold it closed. Great work coat.

Wow this coat. I almost considered buying it but then quickly realized this probably would never see the light of day in SF. It fit perfectly and was soooo comfortable. I was hesitant with it being wool but it was surprisingly soft and provided plenty of warmth for an outdoor wedding in November.

Lovely coat, no lining but still kept me warm on a wintery rooftop.

Definitely fits on the smaller side. Ordered a few sizes up per the reviews I read and was grateful I did!

Mainly worn with jeans and a sweater, but also worn over a dress. Not super heavy - the perfect weight!

Absolutely loved the blue color! Not the warmest jacket and definitely runs big. I am a true size 10 and an 8 fit over a hoodie no problem - size down!

i loved this coat! I wore it to a winter wedding over my dress, and got so many compliments. It's super warm, so very elegant.

Perfect coat for a fall day.

The reviews made me so anxious on what size I should get. A size 6 ended up being fine - I probably could have done a size 4. Way less itchier than expected base on reviews too so that's a plus! The color wasn't quite as vivid in person but still beautiful. Wore in 50-60 degree weather

I wore this coat to an Easter brunch and really liked it! It was a lot lighter than I was expecting and the material is pretty scratchy. I usually size down in coats and I'm glad I did because it me fit well.

If you want a coat this color, I liked the Wish “Mediterranean Coat” (in almost the same color) better. This one is a warmer wool, and it’s shorter if you like that. But it also has those outside seams I’m not a big fan of. The Wish long coat wasn’t as warm but it had a cleaner classier look in my opinion.

I wore this every day on a work trip in May (it was in the 50s/60s) and loved it! It was such a cute color. It was a little on the oversized / bulky side but it really pulls an outfit together. Would totally order it again!

This jacket is light weight but has some heft. Can dress it up or pair it down with jeans for a great closet staple. Loved the unique blue color.

Fit fine but wasn't anything special.

Loved the color, it kept me pretty warm but the button hole on this particular one was a little too big so it kept coming unbuttoned

This coat is not lined, hence the 4 stars. Otherwise, it is pretty awesome. Nice color and texture. The cut is slim, not oversized. It could be dressed up or down.

What a lovely color! I love the cut of this coat, but don't absolutely love the gesture and exposed seams of the build. The color is so lovely, though, I would happily rent again for springtime! Made me feel elegant and polished and bright.

Overall cute coat but the button hole was stretched out and wouldn’t stay buttoned. Also didn’t like that she seams look sloppy on the arms- almost like it’s inside out. Overall the coat is warm and a pretty color but I didn’t wear much due it not staying buttoned.

I obsessively read the reviews that said to size down, but I'm a size 14 with big hips and a bigger chest (36I) so I ordered my usual size. It was a cute top layer but it would not stay closed on me. I could only wear extremely thin tops underneath it. The pockets pulled on my hips and I could barely close the jacket over my boobs. Ended up wearing it as an open outer layer in 50 deg weather but wasn't practical for days when I wanted a coat that closes. Curvy gals, I'd suggest going a size up!

I really loved this jacket as it looked so classic on! Very pretty blue color. The only downside is it isn't super warm. Other than that- 10/10!

I could've gone with 2 or 4. Boxy fit. Boiled wool material so very warm. The sleeve length was just right.

It fits perfectly. The color is gorgeous, and I never ever want to send it back.

I loved this coat. I got numerous complements in the color of this coat & it was so warm. It definitely runs large so size down!

I would have never bought this coat if I saw it in a store, but renting it with my unlimited subscription seemed like a great opportunity to try something new. It's simply gorgeous and the baby blue color is more muted on than you would think. The fit is perfect and unlike J.Crew's cocoon coat, this one has working pockets. I love this coat and now I'm even tempted to try it in hot pink...

Felt like a full princess in this coat. The sleeves were a full 2" short for me and the texture is not great but willing to overlook for the color and style. Can't wait to rent again!

This wool coat didn’t itch. I would have liked a size down for a more fitted look.

I wore this twice! I wore the 4 but I definitely would order a 2 next time. I got so many compliments on this coat! It's professional and lovely. It's not lined and not the warmest and it was a bit long on someone so short. But I would definitely rent again.

Nice coat for spring or fall- or mild climate winter. It fits comfortably and doesn't pull. Do NOT get this coat if you have a wool sensitivity. It is not lined and is scratchy if you aren't wearing long sleeves under it. The color is more versatile than I expected.

This is an unlined boiled wool. It's fairly warm but not heavy. Was a little snug in the tummy where it buttons but I'm apple. Sleeves were long.

Love this jacket and color. It’s perfect for in-between Winter-Spring as the coat is on the thinner side. Great quality JCrew. So many compliments.

I love everything about this coat. It’s a perfect weight wool for fall/into early winter in southern CA. This will go with tons of outfits I already own and has unusual details. The color is beautiful periwinkle blue.

Loved! Rent all winter and wore it almost every day. Good fit, where I could wear it over thicker sweaters and still feel comfortable.

Easy to wear and is good weight.

Loved this. I wanted to buy it. It was so comfortable and flattering.