Product Reviews
Fun and versatile
Very fun skirt with lots of options. I dressed it down for a casual day, but could have easily tucked in a blouse, paired with heels and worn to work. It hugged my hips a bit more than I felt comfortable with though so wore a t-shirt over top.
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 8
Size 8
5' 7"
138 lbs
Athletic
36C
38 yrs
Fun and comfortable
So many compliments on this skirt. All the colors in this skirt make it very versatile. You could style it for any occasion. In the fall, I'd love to pair this with tights, ankle boots, and a sweater. True to size. Forgiving across the hips.
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 4
Size 4
5' 5"
140 lbs
Hourglass
32D
25 yrs
I call it the carnival skirt
Fun piece! It is slightly fitted through the hips and lined until just above the knee. Medium weight/all season except for the hottest of days. Could do black top and shoes to make this elegant or sneakers and a T.
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 6
Size 6
5' 9"
160 lbs
Full Bust
34DD
43 yrs
Fun skirt but not great for petites!
I absolutely love J. Crew (the majority of my closet is J. Crew) so I was surprised when I had to size up on this. I'm generally a 0/XS but had to get a S. Unfortunately this meant the skirt would be even longer on me. Easy solution was to roll the waist a few times and cover it with my shirt. It was such a fun skirt to wear and got lots of compliments. Wish the length was more flattering on me or I would totally buy the skirt.
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 0
Size 0
5' 4"
110 lbs
Petite
34B
31 yrs
Wanted to love it
Beautiful fabric and print but soooo stretched out in the waist. Literally larger at the waist than hips. Not wearable.
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: NONE
Usual Size: 2
Size 2
5' 5"
130 lbs
Pear
34B
34 yrs
Casual Yet Stunning!
The viscose/nylon fabric keeps the skirt bouncy and flouncy from knee-length down which I absolutely love with this pattern and the white slip lining gives the skirt a comfy fit and a flattering form, so it was perfect for my breezy yet sunny winter morning of work meetings and errand running! I got lots of compliments from passersby! 10/10 would rent again.
Size Worn: XS
Usual Size: 2
Size 2
5' 7"
110 lbs
Petite
28B
26 yrs
Cute cute cute!
Happy little skirt that moved well when I walked, didn't wrinkle when seated and overall great. It was slightly tight from hip bone to hip bone in the front. Would rent again.
Size Worn: XS
Usual Size: 0
Size 0
5' 5"
105 lbs
Athletic
34D
35 yrs
Great skirt
Great skirt! It's kind of a flouncy knit skirt, but it works so well! I expected it to run large bc JCrew normally does but it didn't! Order what size you'd normally wear.
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 6
Size 6
5' 4"
140 lbs
Hourglass
34B
22 yrs
Favorite skirt rental EVER!!
This skirt brightened up my Monday. I loved wearing it and will definitely rent again. Comfortable and true to size!
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 4
Size 4
5' 7"
145 lbs
Hourglass
34C
34 yrs
Fun unique midi!
This is a super fun skirt, the midi length hits at a good place and it has a lot of movement. The fabric is unique, like a stretchy-lacy feel and the lining is super comfortable and doesn't move around. The waist was a little tighter than I would've liked and I have a smaller waist for the rest of my size- if you have a bigger midsection, it may not hurt to think about sizing up.
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 8
Size 8
5' 7"
150 lbs
Athletic
34B
32 yrs
Great rental!
Felt very cute! Received buncha compliments and was true to size. Super comfy and warm.
Size Worn: XS
Usual Size: 4
Size 4
5' 6"
140 lbs
Straight & narrow
34A
25 yrs
Received so many compliments
Love love love this skirt! Fun and playful, the perfect length (I'm 5"7), and super flattering. Comfy and got so many compliments!
Size Worn: L
Usual Size: 14
Size 14
5' 7"
180 lbs
Full Bust
36G
25 yrs
Good quality, comfortable and colorful skirt!
Loved the fit of the skirt and how it flows. The colors make it very versatile but I kept it simple with a black top.
Size Worn: XS
Usual Size: 4
Size 4
5' 4"
125 lbs
Full Bust
34C
45 yrs
Fun rainbow skirt!
Loved the ribbed knit fabric of this skirt. It made it super comfortable and helped hide any lumps and bumps! Definitely will lift your mood! Super cute.
Size Worn: XS
Usual Size: 4
Size 4
5' 4"
130 lbs
Athletic
34C
26 yrs
I guess I just love JCrew
This is such a gorgeous, well-made and versatile piece. I buy a lot of JCrew during good clearance sales. It's nice to try an in-season piece I wouldn't shell out full price for so if it gets marked down, I know I love it and I know my size. This is a staple piece I would wear for years and hold onto for when my Daughter is grown.
Size Worn: XXL
Usual Size: 18
Size 18
5' 10"
240 lbs
Pear
42DD
33 yrs
Pretty and snug summer skirt
Such a pretty summer skirt. Paired with the matching top (tho wore XS on top. Would be good for many body shapes and heights. I'm 5'3" so I expected it to hit mid calf. It get slightly snug around my hips. Mine came with a little extra thread in the front but couldn't exchange as this item is in high demand and no other sizes were left. Recommend this piece!
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 2
Size 2
5' 3"
117 lbs
Hourglass
32B
42 yrs
My new favorite skirt!
I'm 4 months postpartum and wanted to find something cute and flattering to wear for a weekday event. This skirt was the PERFECT choice.
Size Worn: L
Usual Size: 12
Size 12
5' 8"
Full Bust
36DD
28 yrs
FUN and fabulous!
Rented this and happened to be in NYC during World Pride, and it was perfect! Got tons of compliments. It looked great dressed down with a tank and jean jacket and up with a nicer top and heels. Loved this and almost kept it. Very versatile and seasonless.
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 4
Size 4
5' 9"
130 lbs
Straight & narrow
32D
36 yrs
The most fun outfit you'll wear this summer!
I got this and the matching top from the Chicago store as part of unlimited. I wasn't sure about it and even when I tried it on I wasn't sure I could pull it off, but I decided to try it (you can always return!) and am so glad I did- super out of my comfort zone and one of my favorite outfits I've ever worn!! If you're worried about the stretch- it's lined with an equally stretchy sweater type material so you feel like you have support but it's also flexible for whatever your shape is. I did wear it with light spans type undies to suck everything together, but probably would have been fine without. I only wore this in combo with the top, but it would be adorable with a cute graphic T or tank.
Size Worn: XL
Usual Size: 16
Size 16
5' 6"
220 lbs
Hourglass
40DD
28 yrs
F U N
I borrowed this with the matching tank top and wore it with and without it. Can't beat the colors and how fun it is! Downside is that it runs a touch small.
Size Worn: XS
Usual Size: 0
Size 0
5' 3"
115 lbs
Petite
32A
37 yrs
Wore for Thanksgiving.
Im only 4'11 but the length looked good. The skirt is very comfortable and the colors are fun. I would definitely rent again when I'm not in quarantine.
Size Worn: XS
Usual Size: 0
Size 0
4' 11"
100 lbs
Petite
32B
36 yrs
Unique and special.
This was really different and fun - I rented it with the matching top and enjoyed this outfit so much. The fabric is delicate yet substantial. I found it to be a tad small in the stomach/waist area.
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 2
Size 2
5' 1"
110 lbs
Petite
46 yrs
Fun and Comfy
runs a bit small making it a little hard to find the best spot to wear on your waist. Comfortable and a real showstopper
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: L
Usual Size: 14
Size 14
5' 8"
200 lbs
Athletic
38DDD/E
34 yrs
kfjls
sjfkls
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 4
Size 4
5' 3"
115 lbs
Petite
32DD
48 yrs
Very cute.
The fabric is a little scratchy but no complaints otherwise
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 6
Size 6
5' 1"
130 lbs
Hourglass
36C
42 yrs
Wonderful skirt but not if you have hips
I love everything about this skirt except for it's slim fit. Even the XXL was narrow.
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: NONE
Usual Size: 18
Size 18
5' 3"
Pear
44C
70 yrs
Fun!
This was the perfect skirt to brighten up my work-day. It fit true to size and didn't make my hips looks wider due to the vertical stripes. There are many options for tops that you could pair with the skirt too which is great and could transition from work to dinner in a flash. The lining under did get bunched up a few times because I was up and down at my desk but nothing too bad. I would rent again.
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: XL
Usual Size: 14
Size 14
5' 9"
185 lbs
Pear
36C
28 yrs
na
na
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 4
Size 4
5' 8"
150 lbs
Apple
37 yrs
not great for big hips
i expected this skirt to flare from the waist, but it's actually fitted through the hips and then flares farther down, which was not particularly flattering on me. i'm somewhere between and hourglass and a pear, and the skirt i got was stretched out in the waist so it was too big there but too tight in the hips & butt. i wanted to love it but it just wasn't quite right for me.
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 4
Size 4
5' 7"
145 lbs
Pear
34B
31 yrs
Too heavy foe warm weather
Cute skirt. Didn't realize it was basically a sweater. Will rent again when the weather cools down.
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 10
Size 10
5' 6"
Full Bust
36DDD/E
34 yrs
Not my fave...unflattering along your tummy area and somewhat tighter than expected.
On the hanger, this skirt looks like it would be cute. You slip it on and realize it is tighter than I expected. It almost hugs you in like Spanx, but at the same time, shows all your tummy region pretty well. I also thought I could pair it with something black on top to tone down the rainbow, but it is navy. It would honestly look cute with a chambray shirt tied at the waist and sneakers, but I wore it to work and it was meh.
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 4
Size 4
5' 9"
140 lbs
Straight & narrow
34A
40 yrs
Super cute and loved colors BUT was tighter than I thought...just not flattering in belly area.
Bright and fun - just not flattering in belly area for me. Too tight.
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: None
Usual Size: 6
Size 6
5' 0"
155 lbs
Hourglass
34D
37 yrs
Meh
Just like the matching top, this skirt was just meh. Was surprisingly more form fitting than expected and had a knee length liner on the inside that hugged your hips tightly. Ran small for J Crew (which I consider true to size for most other brands). Didn't wear this because it was little too snug and just not what I was hoping for.
Size Worn: NONE
Usual Size: 2
Size 2
5' 4"
125 lbs
Hourglass
32D
26 yrs
Thought this skirt would be cute. It is, but it is not flattering.
This skirt would show off a baby bump beautifully.
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 12
Size 12
5' 7"
160 lbs
Hourglass
38DD
39 yrs
Comfy and cute
It's high waisted and stretchy and cute.
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 6
Size 6
5' 7"
145 lbs
Athletic
32C
38 yrs
super fun skirt - fits well and colors are true to photo!
Loved it - would definitely rent again
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: XS
Usual Size: 0
Size 0
5' 0"
115 lbs
Petite
49 yrs
Colorful sweater skirt, surprisingly flattering
The fit of this was excellent and flattering. So many sweater skirts bunch at the waist and create the appearance of a little lower stomach bulge. This one is cut to be nice and trim under the waistband so there is no bulge there. While it is knit, it is a fine, lacier weight rather than sweater weight so this is good in any weather. Also the strips have just about every color you can think of so it's extremely versatile.
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 4
Size 4
5' 6"
135 lbs
Athletic
32C
44 yrs
This skirt is everything
If you are thinking of grabbing this piece, let me say-You need this skirt! It is so good on and wears really really well.. comfy band and material you can wear all day. I wore mine with a bodysuit and heels. So so good!
Size Worn: L
Usual Size: 12
Size 12
5' 7"
185 lbs
Full Bust
36DDD/E
8 yrs
Comfortable and fun
Comfortable and fun
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 6
Size 6
5' 2"
127 lbs
Athletic
34B
47 yrs
Causal and Cute
Cute for a hot day
Member Fit Notes
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 8
Size 8
5' 4"
138 lbs
Hourglass
36C
41 yrs
1 - 40 of 51 reviews
