I wore the shirt tucked in and tucked out and loved both — a great comfortable set for vacation! The gold buttons were such a nice detail, I was sad to give this one back.

I loved this set! The top can be worn with jeans too. The gold buttons were a nice touch even if a bit hard to button

Perfect little set. The shirt is a bit big but that's the look and the shorts are just the right length.

On the surface looks like a plain black top but the details take the cake - scalloped edges, beautiful buttons, burnout looking fabric. The fabric doesn’t need a tank under it, thank goodness. Lightweight for hot weather. Great with jeans or with the shorts from the set.

Very chic and classy! Perfect for casual work outfit!

Fun scallop seams and pleated shoulders and buttons.

Quality, easy, chic. Loved it.

Love the cotton/linen blend. Runs large, would suggest sizing down at least one size. The buttons are exquisite.

A lot of compliments! It fits loose enough that I didn’t have to worry about the tatas peeking out of the buttons, but didn’t look too big or baggy

This was cute enough, buttons were really different and made the shirt interesting. Wasn’t super breathable. Somewhat heavy fabric.

Light and breezy. Ornate buttons (some of the buttons were very difficult for me to button!). Just not my favorite.

I was looking for a set that would work in the fall and this did not disappoint. I was annoyed the smaller size was not available because I was swimming in the shirt, but went well with the oversized feel when paired with the shorts. Its certainly a loose fit throughout and the buttons are actually heavy. I also was able to pair with a work skirt to get more use out of. I will 100 be renting again in the smaller size as this is great to thrown on for any activity.

Good shirt but nothing to write home about. The buttons were a nice detail. Runs a little big but I like the oversized look

Probably not something I would buy, but it was a fun rental. I buttoned it all the way to the top, which I often do for collared shirts. Quite often when I wear that look, I tuck it in, but the shirt was a little too big to tuck in. Paired it with wide leg jeans for a very comfortable and casual look.

It was a little long for my taste but made it work. Possibly size down for a more fitted look. Idea to wear with white shorts was from the picture with the model. Just happened to have a pair of white shorts that have same scalloped finish as the top. Buttons are VERY difficult to work with. They are a bit too big for the button holes. Need to have a little patience with the buttons and figure out just the right angle to unbutton or button. Wore a few times out to dinner.

Pros: I love the buttons on this shirt and the scallops are adorable. It’s a nice summer weight but not flimsy. Cons: it’s very oversized which made it hard for me to wear untucked to show off those adorable scallops. I have the matching shorts and when worn together it looks like pajamas because of the fabric. I might try again but like 3 sizes smaller.

Love the buttons and scallop detail but this is too oversized for me. Made me feel sloppy. It’s comfortable for sure but fell short of actually looking sharp

Fit is great and I received multiple compliments when wearing this.

I wore this with jeans in London in the cold rain, and in Hawaii over a bathing suit. It's the perfect versatile top! The buttons are slightly heavier metal than expected, but not an issue for wear

Such cute details and so easy to wear. The scalloped edges are amazing

Lightweight material so great for summer or vacation, buttons are special, high-quality, lots of compliments, I wore both open and tucked in would rent again

Fit slightly oversized in a cute casual way

Perfect

A little loose

I felt like this top gave me the best of office friendly while converting into date night well! I kept it for a double shipment and got so many compliments on it! The gold buttons are a great plus.

Wore while 29 weeks pregnant. Sized up and it was perfect. Super cute.

Very comfortable shirt! The buttons and scallops add a fun layer to a simple black shirt. Allows you to be able to dress it up a little when needed, but also wear for an every day shirt.

I wore this causally around town with jeans but paired it with black slacks for work.

Loved the buttton details. Could be dressed up or down. A little oversized fit. Rented with the matching shorts and wore a couple times on vacation.

I'm 7 months pregnant and the 42 worked great over maternity jeans! Super cute!

Fit was great for me, a little long which I didn't mind since everything else is cropped these days. Details of the scallops and gold buttons were such a hit

Lived in this for work for my first and second trimester. Was being discreet about my pregnancy at work and this is flattering, stylish, and not just another baggy sweater. Worked great for client meetings. Got my pre pregnancy size size

Cute shirt nothing special , but liked it

This is great for work or casual. Would purchase this item, fits true to size.

I have rented this twice. Nice comfortable flattering top.

Fits great love the scalloped edge dressy but comfortable

Great every day shirt slightly elevated